The next involved a retired school custodian.
Then came a complaint from a woman who had visited alone and asked about a certified pre-owned vehicle.
Some complaints were vague. A few described ordinary misunderstandings that might have been resolved through better communication. Others were detailed enough to make Richard uncomfortable.
One customer wrote that Brad had repeatedly addressed her husband even though she was the person paying for the vehicle.
Another said he had been told that a particular model was "too much car" for someone with his income, even though he had not discussed his income.
A third described being laughed at after asking whether the dealership offered financing for someone with limited credit history.
Richard noticed a pattern.
The complaints did not all involve the same kind of customer.
They involved people who did not fit Brad's preferred image of a buyer.
They involved people who needed extra time, asked basic questions, wore work clothes, arrived in older vehicles, or had limited experience buying cars.
They involved people who could not be judged quickly by the appearance of their shoes or the cost of their watches.
Richard opened the performance records.
Brad's sales numbers were excellent.
He had sold more premium vehicles than most of the other salespeople. His average transaction value was high. He rarely needed help closing a deal. He was confident in front of customers who knew exactly what they wanted and had the financial means to buy it.
The dealership had rewarded those strengths.
What it had not measured was the number of people who never reached the point of becoming customers.
Richard found a report from the previous year showing that Brad had received several internal coaching notes. Each note mentioned a different issue: impatience with customers, premature assumptions about financing, complaints about his tone, or a tendency to prioritize high-value leads.
None had resulted in formal discipline.
One note included a comment from a former sales manager.
Brad's style can be abrasive, but his numbers justify coaching rather than punishment.
Richard read that sentence several times.
He remembered the manager who had written it. The man had since moved to another dealership, leaving Richard to inherit the team.
At the time, Richard had accepted the recommendation.
He had not asked what "abrasive" meant.
He had not asked how often customers complained.
He had not asked whether Brad's sales performance depended, in part, on ignoring people he believed were unlikely to buy.
The problem had been placed in a category that made it seem manageable.
Coaching.
The word had become a convenient place to put uncomfortable facts.
At 3:05, Richard called the dealership's general manager, Elaine Whitaker.
Elaine had been at Prestige Motors for eighteen years, first as a finance manager, then as a regional operations director, and finally as general manager. She was direct, disciplined, and deeply protective of the dealership's reputation.
She arrived at Richard's office ten minutes later carrying a notebook.
"Tell me what happened."
Richard explained the encounter with Earl Washington. He showed her Patricia's report, Brad's preliminary statement, and the complaints he had collected.
Elaine read in silence.
When she finished, she placed the papers on the desk.
"How many?"
"Eight formal complaints in two years. Three internal coaching notes. There may be more."
"Why weren't they escalated?"
"Most were marked resolved. Some were handled informally."
"By whom?"
"Different managers. The files don't always say."
Elaine looked through the papers again.
"These complaints are serious."
"Yes."
"Did Mr. Washington threaten to cancel the order?"
"No."
"Did he ask us to fire Brad?"
"No."
"Then we need to be very careful not to make this about saving a sale."
Richard nodded.
"That's what I told him."
Elaine studied the statement from Patricia.
"What exactly did Brad say?"
Richard repeated the comments.
Elaine's expression hardened.
"That is not a misunderstanding."
"No."
"And he changed his attitude when he learned who the customer was."
"Yes."
Elaine closed the notebook.
"Then the issue isn't whether Brad can sell cars. The issue is whether he can represent this dealership."
Richard glanced toward the showroom.
"He's going to say he's being punished because the customer turned out to be wealthy."
"Then we'll show him the evidence that existed before Mr. Washington walked through the door."
Elaine stood.
"Get me every complaint. I want the original records, the resolution notes, and the names of the managers who handled them. I also want to know whether our customer satisfaction system excludes people who don't buy."
Richard hesitated.
"That could be a much larger review."
"Good."
Elaine walked toward the door, then stopped.
"Richard, how many salespeople have we praised for closing deals without asking how the customer was treated?"