The courthouse was a two-story brick edifice with tall, narrow windows and an unpainted wooden cupola that housed an iron bell. When Clara and Samuel walked up the limestone steps, the crowd clustered on the porch fell abruptly silent. Men leaned back against the iron railings, their eyes following the young woman who had walked out of Devilās Gate alive.
Inside, the courtroom was stifling, heated by two massive cast-iron stoves that glowed dull cherry red in the corners. The benches were packed to the edges.
Behind the defense table sat Silas Crowe, Boone Mercer, and Jasper Cole, flanked by three territorial deputies armed with 10-gauge scatterguns. Silas looked diminished. The months in the dark stone cells beneath the courthouse had stripped the leathery bronze from his skin, leaving his face the color of wet tallow. His salt-and-pepper beard was trimmed raggedly, his gray wool prison smock hanging loose from his wide, bony shoulders. But when he turned his head and saw Clara enter the chamber, his small, dark eyes flared with that same cold, predatory hatred she had seen on the road to Bellās Creek.
Beside him, Boone Mercerās jaw was wired with twisted silver threads, his lower lip pulled downward in a permanent, hideous sneer. He did not look at Clara; his gaze was fixed on his own dirty fingernails, his spirit crushed not by the law, but by the public disgrace of having been laid low by a rancher's daughter.
Judge Claggett presided from a high oak bench beneath the seal of the Territory of Wyoming. His spectacles glinted under the oil lamps as he called the case of The Territory of Wyoming versus Silas Crowe, et al.
The prosecutor, a young territorial attorney named Horace Greeley Vanceāno relation to the Denver reporter, but cursed with the same flamboyant rhetoricāspent an hour outlining the crimes: armed highway robbery, conspiracy to extract ransom through threat of murder, and unlawful restraint upon the person of Clara Whitmore.
When Clara was called to the stand, a rustle like wind through dry reeds went through the gallery.
She walked to the wooden witness box with measured steps, took the Bible in her bare right hand, and swore the oath in a voice that was neither loud nor faint. Her eyes swept across the crowded room, past the staring faces of strangers, until they rested on Silas Crowe.
"Miss Whitmore," the prosecutor began, pacing before the jury box with his thumbs hooked in his waistcoat pockets. "Tell the court what occurred on the afternoon of July fourteenth of this present year, on the public trail between Medicine Bow and Rattlesnake Creek."
Clara did not look at the jury. She kept her eyes on Silas.
"I was riding north with medicine for Samuel Bell," she said clearly. "Seven men intercepted me. Silas Crowe was the leader. He demanded my horse and my supplies. When I refused to give up my carbine, they surrounded me with drawn weapons."
"And did they threaten your life?" Vance demanded, turning toward the twelve ranchers and merchants sitting in the jury box.
"Silas told me that I was to be held for ten thousand dollars ransom," Clara said. "He said that if my father did not bring the money to Devilās Gate, Boone Mercer would kill me."
From the defense table, Silasās attorneyāa pale, sweat-soaked practitioner from Cheyenne appointed by the courtāstood up wearily. "Objection, Your Honor. The witness is attributing words to my client that may have been uttered in the heat of a misunderstanding."
"Overruled," Judge Claggett snapped. "The witness will proceed."
For an hour, Clara answered every question with direct, unadorned precision. She did not exaggerate her peril, nor did she minimize it. She described the knot in the rope, the rainstorm on the ridge, the shattered stove, and the surrender at the canyon mouth.
"And during all this time," the prosecutor asked, his voice swelling for the benefit of the gallery, "did you plead for your life? Did you ask these ruthless villains for mercy?"
Clara looked at the prosecutor with a faint, cold curiosity. "No, sir."
"You did not?"
"I did not," she said simply. "Pleading with men like Silas Crowe is like asking a winter blizzard not to freeze your cattle. It wastes your breath and gives them the notion that you believe they have the power to decide your fate. My father always told me that when trouble comes, you don't argue with it. You just outlast it."
In the second row of the gallery, Samuel Whitmore sat with his arms folded across his chest, his gray head tilted slightly, an imperceptible nod touching his chin.
The defense attorney did not cross-examine her. He looked at Claraās eyes, looked at the twelve men in the jury box who were already glaring at his client with murderous disdain, and sat down without speaking a word.
The verdict took less than forty minutes.
Guilty on all counts.
Judge Claggett adjusted his spectacles and ordered Silas Crowe to stand. The outlaw leader rose slowly, his shackles clinking against the wooden floorboards with a dull, hollow sound.
"Silas Crowe," Claggett said, his voice ringing through the silent chamber. "You have lived by violence and terror on this frontier for fifteen years. You have preyed upon travelers, stolen the bread of working families, and attempted to extort wealth from an honorable veteran of this nationās army. The court sentences you to twenty-five years at hard labor in the Territorial Penitentiary at Rawlins. And may God have mercy upon your wretched soul."