At the narrow neck of the canyon, where two leaning slabs of sandstone formed the natural archway known as the Devil’s Gate, Samuel Whitmore sat astride his black gelding, Pilot. The Sharps rifle rested across the pommel of his saddle, its heavy hammer lowered to half-cock. His long oilcloth slicker was soaked through at the shoulders, water dripping from the brim of his campaign hat onto his beard, but his hands were steady and dry inside their buckskin gauntlets.
Down the winding switchback came the remnants of Silas Crowe’s outfit.
They walked in single file, their boots slipping in the fresh red mud. Jasper Cole walked in front, his hands laced behind his head, his head bowed. Behind him came Will Calloway, supporting his brother Vance, whose boot was dragging from a sprained ankle sustained when he tumbled out of the cabin's rear window in the dark. Silas Crowe walked behind them, his face dark and swollen with rage, his arms bound at the elbows with his own scarlet neckerchief. Boone Mercer was slung across the bare back of a mule, his jaw bound up with a strip of Clara’s linen skirt, groaning with every jolt of the animal's shoulders. Cruz, the vaquero, had been left at the cabin wrapped in blankets; his collarbone was shattered, but Samuel had already plugged the wound with carbolic lint and clean flour before disarming the rest of the gang.
Behind them all rode Clara, mounted once again on June.
The gray mare had met them at the base of the switchback, having followed the scent of the pack horses through the storm. She walked with her head low and alert, her ears pricked forward toward Samuel. Clara carried her recovered Colt .38 in her lap, her face pale under the gray morning light, but her seat in the saddle was square and easy.
Samuel did not move until the prisoners halted ten paces from the arch of Devil’s Gate. His washed-blue eyes moved over them slowly, counting each man, cataloging their injuries, noting the absence of sidearms and the vacant, hollow stares of men whose luck had run into a stone wall.
Finally, his gaze lifted to Clara.
"You kept your hair," Samuel said. His voice was quiet, carry-over gravel from a lifetime of speaking over cavalry drums.
"They weren't looking for my hair, Pa," Clara answered, reining June in beside the black gelding. "They were looking for your twenty thousand dollars."
Samuel’s brow twitched once—the only sign that the words had struck home. He looked down at Silas Crowe.
"Who told you that story, Crowe?" Samuel asked.
Silas lifted his head, his lip curling in a bloody sneer. "Old man Miller in Rawlins. Said you took the paymaster's chest when the Second went down on the Rosebud. Said you bought that dirt on the Little Laramie with government gold."
Samuel looked at the outlaw for a long moment, then reached into his pocket and pulled out a small cloth pouch of plug tobacco. He cut a corner off with his thumbnail and placed it between his cheek and jaw, chewing slowly before speaking.
"Miller was a teamster who ran at the first shot," Samuel said evenly. "He ran so fast he left his mules behind. The money was delivered to Colonel McKenzie at Camp Robinson three weeks after the fight, down to the last copper cent. The ledger is on file in the War Department in Washington. If I had twenty thousand dollars, do you think my daughter would be riding thirty miles through the dust to carry fever bark to Samuel Bell?"
Silas’s face went gray beneath the trail grime. "You're lying."
"I don't lie to thieves," Samuel said. "It takes too much breath. Clara, did any of them get into the Bell medicine?"
"The quinine is safe," Clara said, patting the leather saddlebag on June’s flank. "The carbolic salve took a spill, but the jars didn't break."
"Good," Samuel nodded. "Bell’s wife has been sitting by that window since yesterday noon. The fever will have peaked by sunrise. We drop these five off with the town marshal in Medicine Bow, then you can ride the north road and finish your chore."
"I can take them in, Pa," Clara said. "You've been in the saddle since dusk."
"We both take them in," Samuel replied, turning Pilot’s head toward the southern basin. "Posse business is noisy business. If I bring five road agents into Medicine Bow tied to their own saddle strings, Wallace will want an affidavit that takes four hours to scratch out on foolscap. I’d rather have you there to make sure he spells our names right."
He nudged Pilot forward, taking the lead rope that bound Silas Crowe’s mount to the rest of the file.
As they began the long descent toward the valley, Clara looked back over her shoulder. The high limestone bluffs of the Medicine Bow range were catching the first rays of the morning sun, turning from cold slate to a brilliant, burning gold.
High above the tree line, near the rocky bench where the old prospector’s cabin stood, a lone figure moved through the scrub oak.
It was Eli Turner. He was on foot, carrying nothing but a blanket roll, heading west toward the Utah border—away from the ranches, away from the telegraph lines, and away from the gallows that waited for Silas Crowe.
Clara watched him until he vanished into the blue shadows of the timber. She didn't point him out to her father, and when Samuel looked back to check the line of prisoners, he saw only the empty rocks and the gray sage swaying in the morning breeze.