Earl Simmons had scored four thousand, one hundred and some matches in his life, and he could have told you, if you had asked him that morning, that there was nothing left in this world that could surprise him at a shooting ground. He had seen rifles dropped and rifles blessed. He had seen a groom shoot in his wedding suit and a grandmother shoot in her church hat. He had seen lightning split a cottonwood not fifty yards from the firing line and every man on it flinch except one old woman who finished her string, lowered her rifle, and asked whether the storm intended to pay an entry fee. He had seen cheating, and weeping, and one famous fistfight over a quarter of an inch on a paper target, and he had outlasted six directors, four pavilions, two fires, and one attempted theft of the association bell. Nothing surprised Earl anymore. That was the settled condition of his seventy-second year, like the stiffness in his left knee and the thin place on the crown of his head where the sun got in under his cap.
And then Claire Donovan picked up her rifle, lifted it to her shoulder for one short breath to feel its weight, and Earl Simmons stood behind the officials' table with his clipboard against his chest and his mouth hanging open like a boy.
He was aware of it, distantly. He was aware of the clipboard first, because his hands had tightened on it without his permission, the way a man's hands will tighten on a rail when a boat shifts under him. The board was an old one, older than the girl volunteer who had handed it to him that morning â dark wood gone darker at the edges from sixty years of thumbs, a sprung clip that had to be coaxed, and under the clip the day's score sheets in their proper order, founders' shot last, because the founders' shot was always last, because some things you did not hurry. His mouth he became aware of second, because the girl volunteer, whose name was Dana and who was seventeen and terrified of him for no reason he had ever given her, said, very quietly, "Mr. Simmons? Are you all right?"
"I'm standing," Earl said.
"You look like you saw â "
"I did see," Earl said. "I saw her when she was sixteen years old, is what I saw. Hand me my pen."
But his eyes did not leave the woman at the far end of the ground, and the pen, when Dana put it into his fingers, stayed there uncapped and forgotten, because Claire had lowered the rifle again and was holding it the way she had always held it, and it was not the hold that undid him. Plenty of people hold a rifle well. It was the pause. Before she lifted it, and after she set it down from her shoulder, there had been the pause â a half a breath, no more, in which her hands rested on the wood and her eyes went somewhere that was not the crowd, and not Brett Callahan, and not the bright hard morning at all. Earl had seen that pause twice in his life. Once across a kitchen-table's worth of years, watching June Hartley at a fence line with a rifle older than her marriage. And once, every match for six seasons, watching June Hartley's daughter.
"She used to do that," he said, to nobody, to Dana, to the forty years standing in a row behind his eyes. "Right before. Like she was asking it a question."
"Asking what, Mr. Simmons?"
"Whether it remembered her," Earl said. "I expect it does."
The sun stood high and white over the ground and the heat came up off the sand in a shimmer that made the far targets waver like things seen through water. The crowd along the rail made the low, restless noise crowds make when they are not yet sure what they have been given to watch â half of them had come for a champion's exhibition and a land vote and a brass band's worth of ceremony, and they had been given, so far, a quarrel over a token and a woman who would not speak. Phones were up all along the rail, a hedge of small bright rectangles. The flags worked above them, the Stars and Stripes and the blue association flags snapping and easing, snapping and easing, in a wind that brought the smell of dust and hot canvas and somebody's concession coffee. And in the middle of it Claire Donovan stood with her mother's stillness on her like a second shirt, and Earl Simmons, who had not believed in ghosts since he was nine years old and had decided the thing in the barn was his uncle, revised nothing â he only thought that time was a country, and some people could walk back into a room of it and set everything in it standing upright again.
"Mr. Simmons," Dana said, braver now, following his gaze. "Who is she? Everybody's filming like she's somebody."
"Everybody's filming because Brett told them not to miss it," Earl said. "That's a different thing from somebody. Brett wouldn't know somebody if she â " He stopped. He adjusted his cap, which was navy, with the association badge worked in gold thread that forty summers had not managed to fade, because Earl kept his cap in a drawer with tissue paper, a fact he would have denied at gunpoint. "She's Claire Donovan," he said. "Was Claire Hartley before she married. Her mama won this shoot the year I started scoring it. She won it herself six years running, back when â "