The room they were given was the old muniments room on the second floor, where the household kept the deeds and the drainage plans and the bound volumes of accounts going back to a time when the accounts were written in a hand so beautiful it seemed a shame to add numbers to it. George Ashworth had administered my mother's trust from that room, or from rooms like it, for longer than I had been alive. The trust was not the palace's money, exactly, and it was not the companies' money, exactly. It was Catherine Radcliffe's money, settled before I was born, holding the voting shares that stood between Radcliffe Global and Harrington Industries like a gatekeeper between two houses that had spent fifty years pretending they were not related. And the gate had a lock with two keys. That was the whole design. The trust's voting power could only be exercised by two guardians acting together, one from each twin's line — my sister's line and mine — and for twenty-seven years there had only ever been one guardian in the world, because for twenty-seven years, as far as any document admitted, there had only been one twin.
I was the second key. I had been confirmed as such, in a sealed room, with lawyers, under my sister's own designation, made in her own hand before she went into the hiding that everyone mistook for death. I do not think I understood, until the auditors came, what it meant that the seat had sat empty for so long. An empty chair is not a neutral thing. An empty chair is a room that never has to reach a decision. And a room that never has to reach a decision is a very comfortable room for the man who keeps the minutes.
His name was on the door of that room in the way that matters. Not painted. Just assumed. George Ashworth, sixty-three years old, family counsel since before the twins were born, trustee of the Catherine Radcliffe Trust, adviser to the board of Radcliffe Global, adviser, in quieter ways, to Harrington Industries as well — a circumstance that would have been a scandal in any decade when anyone had been required to look at it directly. Nobody had been required. That was the point of the empty chair.
The review had not been Adelaide's idea, which surprised people, and it had not been Julian's, which surprised people more. It had been Isabelle's, and then, within a day, mine, because my sister and I had independently arrived at the same sentence, which we discovered when we compared notes over tea in the small sitting room she had taken back like a country she had once governed. The sentence was: before we sign anything, we read everything. Isabelle said it with the weariness of a woman who had learned what signatures cost. I said it with the plain stubbornness of a librarian. The auditors were what the sentence looked like when it was given a budget.
I want to be careful about George Ashworth, because it would be easy, and it would be wrong, to make him into the villain of a story that already had enough of them hiding in better tailoring. He was not a cartoon. He did not twirl anything. What the auditors found, over six weeks of Tuesdays and Thursdays and eventually every day of the week, was not a theft so much as a climate. Trustee fees, set by the trustee, approved by a committee the trustee convened, minuted by a secretary the trustee employed. Merger votes — the great recurring question of whether Radcliffe Global and Harrington Industries would finally combine the shares my mother's trust controlled — "held in abeyance" year after year, while George brokered what the auditors, in their bloodless prose, called parallel arrangements with both boards: consulting understandings, advisory retainers, introductions that became contracts, each one defensible in isolation and none of them ever laid side by side on one table where both families could see the whole pattern. There were arrangement letters, two sets of them, written in a hand so even and reasonable that you could read them for an hour before you noticed that each set promised the other board the opposite thing, and that the only man who had ever held both sets was the man who wrote them.
He had not stolen the fortune. That is the strange thing, and I made the auditors say it twice to be sure I had understood. The capital was intact. The income was accounted for, to the penny, in those beautiful bound volumes. What George Ashworth had harvested, across twenty-seven years, was the stalemate itself. As long as the second guardian's seat stayed empty, the trust could not act, and as long as the trust could not act, both companies needed a man who could stand in the doorway between them and be trusted by each to whisper to the other. He had made himself into the hinge of a door that was never allowed to open, and he had charged both sides for the oil.
Serena's father had said it, months before, in a room I was not in, and the sentence had traveled to me the way true sentences in that world always traveled, thirdhand and undated: if the Doyle woman ever surfaced, the Ashworth accounts would finally have to be opened. I had thought, when I first heard it, that it was a threat. I understood, in the end, that it had only been a weather report.