“What happened?”
Caleb smelled the water.
Bitter.
He dipped a finger, then immediately spat after touching it to his tongue.
“Poison.”
Midnight stood against the far fence, untouched.
He had refused the water.
Caleb looked at the dark hills beyond town.
Silas’s warning echoed in his head.
Nizhoni whispered, “He won’t stop.”
“No.”
“What will you do?”
Caleb reholstered his revolver.
“Go to Black Ridge.”
They left before dawn.
Nizhoni insisted on coming.
Caleb argued.
She won.
“You don’t know where Tahoma searched.”
“You could tell me.”
“No.”
“You think I’m going to let you ride into whatever killed your brother?”
Nizhoni’s eyes flashed.
“Let me?”
Caleb sighed.
“Bad choice of words.”
“Very.”
Midnight followed Caleb without a rope.
Dusty carried their supplies.
By noon, Silver Creek was far behind.
The land changed as they traveled east.
Open desert became broken red stone. Mesquite thickened around dry creek beds. Black volcanic cliffs rose in the distance.
Caleb remembered pieces of it.
A cottonwood.
A crooked ridge.
The smell of sage after rain.
He had spent half his childhood trying to forget.
Now every mile reopened something.
Late in the afternoon, they reached the ruins.
Caleb stopped his horse.
Nothing remained of the Hayes ranch house except a chimney and foundation stones.
The barn had collapsed long ago.
Wind moved through dead grass.
Nizhoni watched Caleb.
“This was your home?”
“Once.”
He dismounted.
For several minutes, he wandered alone.
He found the old well.
The cottonwood where his mother had hung sheets.
The flat stone where he used to sit while his father repaired tack.
Then Midnight walked toward the ruined barn.
The stallion lowered his head.
Sniffed.
And pawed the earth.
Once.
Twice.
Caleb approached.
“What is it?”
Midnight pawed again.
Nizhoni came beside him.
“There.”
Something metallic showed beneath the dirt.
They dug with their hands.
A small iron ring emerged.
Attached to a wooden trapdoor.
Caleb’s heart began pounding.
He had lived on this ranch for thirteen years.
He had never known the trapdoor existed.
Together, they lifted it.
Stone steps descended into darkness.
Nizhoni lit a lantern.
They went down.
The chamber below was small.
A storage cellar.
Empty shelves.
Broken crates.
Then Caleb saw writing on the far wall.
Scratched into the stone.
C.H.
His initials.
Below them:
TRUST THE HORSE. NOT THE BADGE.
Caleb stared.
“That’s fresh.”
Nizhoni touched the carving.
“Not fresh. But not sixteen years old.”
A sound came from outside.
Midnight screamed.
Caleb extinguished the lantern.
Hooves.
Several horses.
Men.
Nizhoni whispered, “Broken Spur.”
Caleb drew his revolver.
They climbed quietly.
Through a crack in the trapdoor, Caleb counted six riders.
At their head was Sheriff Owen Bell.
Caleb knew Bell from Silver Creek.
A friendly man with a round face and graying beard.
He had bought Caleb whiskey after the cattle drive.
He had laughed during Nizhoni’s marriage joke.
And he wore a silver badge.
Caleb looked back at the message.
Not the badge.
Sheriff Bell dismounted.
“Hayes!”
Caleb did not answer.
“We know you’re here.”
Nizhoni whispered, “How?”
Caleb understood.
“Someone followed us.”
Bell called again.
“Silas Creed says you stole property.”
Caleb climbed out with his hands visible.
“Property?”
Bell smiled.
“The stallion.”
“Since when does a sheriff arrest a man forty miles from town over a horse nobody owns?”
“Since the man is also suspected of poisoning a well.”
Caleb laughed once.
“You’ve got that backward.”
“Hands where I can see them.”
Nizhoni emerged behind Caleb.
Bell’s face tightened.
“You too.”
Caleb looked at the sheriff.
“You knew my father.”
Bell shrugged.
“Everybody knew Thomas.”
“Did he trust you?”
That made Bell pause.
Caleb saw it.
“He shouldn’t have,” Caleb said.
Bell reached for his gun.
Midnight struck first.
The black stallion exploded from behind a collapsed wall, slamming into Bell’s horse.
Chaos erupted.
Caleb grabbed Nizhoni.
“Run!”
Gunfire shattered the afternoon.
They dove behind the stone chimney.
Midnight kicked one rider from his saddle.
Dusty broke his tether and bolted.
Nizhoni fired once.
A rifle spun from a man’s hand.
Caleb shot a second rider’s hat clean off.
Not because he missed.
Because he didn’t want six dead men if three frightened ones would run.
“Back!” someone screamed.
Midnight charged again.
The riders scattered.
Sheriff Bell climbed onto another horse.
Before leaving, he shouted:
“You don’t know what your father was!”
Caleb stepped into the open.
“Then come back and tell me!”
Bell rode away.
Five minutes later, only dust remained.
Nizhoni lowered her rifle.
“Your horse has a violent sense of loyalty.”
Caleb looked at Midnight.
“He’s not my horse.”
The stallion walked directly to him.
Nizhoni raised one eyebrow.
Caleb sighed.
“Fine.”
That evening, they camped in the ruins.
The air turned cold after sunset.
Caleb sat beside a small fire while Nizhoni cleaned a scrape on Midnight’s shoulder.
“You could marry him,” Caleb said.
She looked over.
“The horse?”
“Seems the better choice.”
“He has better manners than you.”
“Exactly.”
Nizhoni smiled.
Then the smile faded.
“Do you regret entering the corral?”
Caleb considered.
“No.”
“Even now?”
“No.”
“Why?”
He looked at the fire.
“Because for one minute, everyone expected me to run.”
Nizhoni waited.
Caleb rubbed his hands together.
“I’ve spent most of my life doing exactly that.”
“From what?”
He gave a quiet laugh.
“Take your pick.”
She sat across from him.
“Your father?”
“Myself.”
Caleb stared into the flames.
“When our ranch burned, I was thirteen. My mother had died the year before. Father told me to ride to Santa Fe and stay with an uncle.”
“What happened?”
“Three days later, I heard the ranch was gone.”
“And your father?”
“No body.”
“Yet everyone said he died.”
“Everyone said he was a thief first.”
Nizhoni remained silent.
Caleb continued.
“Silas Creed claimed Father stole sixty head of cattle and sold them across the border. Sheriff Bell signed the warrant. The ranch was seized for debt after the fire.”
“Did you believe them?”
“I was thirteen.”
“That is not an answer.”
Caleb looked at her.
“No.”
“Why?”
“Because my father couldn’t lie about a broken fence without turning red.”
Nizhoni smiled faintly.
“So you ran because people called him a thief?”
“I ran because they started calling me one too.”
“Children can be cruel.”
“So can adults.”
She studied him.
“And after sixteen years?”
“After sixteen years, it’s easier to leave first.”
The fire snapped.
Nizhoni looked toward Midnight.
“My brother was like that horse.”
Caleb glanced at her.
“Angry?”
“Impossible.”
He smiled.
She didn’t.
“Tahome believed every mystery had an answer if he walked far enough.”
“And did it?”
“He died looking.”
Caleb’s expression softened.
Nizhoni touched the bracelet around her wrist.
“Before he left the last time, he told me something strange.”
“What?”
“He said, ‘If the black horse returns without me, do not follow him. Wait for the man he chooses.'”
Caleb’s heartbeat slowed.
“What?”
“I thought he was being poetic.”
“Why didn’t you tell me this?”
“Because I didn’t know whether you were that man.”
“And now?”
Nizhoni looked directly into his eyes.
“Now I am afraid you are.”
A long silence stretched between them.
Caleb said quietly, “You knew when I gave my name.”
“I suspected.”
“The marriage challenge?”
“Was a joke.”
“Good.”
She narrowed her eyes.
“Good?”
“I’m fond of staying alive.”
Nizhoni threw a small stick at him.
He caught it.
Then she laughed.
Caleb laughed too.
For a little while, beside the ruins of everything he had lost, he felt something unfamiliar.
Not happiness exactly.
Possibility.
Later, when the fire had burned low, Nizhoni asked from beneath her blanket, “Caleb?”
“Yeah?”
“If I had meant the promise?”
He stared up at the stars.
“What promise?”
“Do not make me kill you.”