She Joked That She Would Marry Any Man Who Could Tame the Black Mustang. When Caleb Hayes Stepped Into the Corral, Neither of Them Knew the Horse Had Been Waiting for Him

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He smiled into the darkness.

“If you’d meant it, I’d still have said the same thing.”

“What?”

“That I wouldn’t take a wife won from a horse.”

Silence.

Then Nizhoni said softly, “Good.”

Caleb turned toward her.

“Good?”

But she had already closed her eyes.

At sunrise, Midnight led them into Black Ridge.

There was no other explanation for it.

Caleb mounted Dusty.

Nizhoni rode beside him.

Midnight walked ahead, stopping whenever they fell too far behind.

The trail narrowed into a canyon Caleb had never seen.

After two miles, they found a cabin.

Hidden between cliffs.

Smoke rose from the chimney.

Caleb drew his revolver.

The door opened.

An old man stepped outside.

He carried no gun.

His hair was white.

His left leg dragged slightly.

Caleb stared.

The old man stared back.

Then his face collapsed.

“Caleb?”

The revolver nearly slipped from Caleb’s hand.

He knew the voice.

Older.

Rougher.

But he knew it.

No child forgets the voice that once called him home for supper.

Caleb could not move.

The man descended one step.

“My God.”

Caleb whispered, “Dad?”

Thomas Hayes began crying.

Caleb didn’t remember crossing the distance.

One moment he stood twenty feet away.

The next, his father’s arms were around him.

Sixteen years vanished.

Then returned all at once.

Caleb shoved him away.

“You were alive.”

Thomas wiped his face.

“Son—”

“You were alive!”

“I couldn’t—”

“Sixteen years!”

“I know.”

“You knew where I was?”

“Sometimes.”

“Sometimes?”

Nizhoni stood back.

Midnight approached Thomas.

The stallion pressed his head against the old man’s chest.

Caleb stared.

Thomas rubbed the horse’s neck.

“You found him.”

Caleb’s anger sharpened.

“He found me.”

Thomas closed his eyes.

“That’s what I hoped.”

“You sent him?”

“No.”

“Then explain.”

Thomas looked toward Nizhoni.

His face changed.

“Tahome’s sister.”

She nodded.

“You knew him?” she asked.

Thomas swallowed.

“He saved my life.”

Nizhoni’s eyes filled immediately.

“Then tell me how he died.”

Thomas looked away.

“I can.”

Caleb stepped forward.

“Start at the beginning.”

Inside the cabin, Thomas Hayes told them the truth.

Or what Caleb thought was the truth.

Sixteen years earlier, Silas Creed had discovered a rich silver vein beneath Black Ridge.

Unfortunately for Silas, the access road crossed Hayes land, and the spring feeding Silver Creek originated beneath the same property.

Thomas refused to sell.

Creed forged cattle theft records.

Sheriff Bell signed them.

Thomas prepared to expose both men.

The night before he planned to ride to a federal marshal, someone burned the ranch.

Thomas survived with a bullet in his leg.

He believed Caleb had already reached Santa Fe.

Then Creed’s men found him.

Thomas escaped into Black Ridge but couldn’t travel far.

An Apache hunting party discovered him.

For months, he recovered.

“Why didn’t you come for me?” Caleb demanded.

“Because Creed watched everyone connected to us.”

“For sixteen years?”

“No.”

Thomas’s shame showed now.

“At first I thought staying dead protected you. Later…”

“Later what?”

“I became a coward.”

Caleb stared.

Thomas looked at his hands.

“The longer I waited, the harder it became to explain.”

Caleb stood abruptly.

“That’s your answer?”

“No. It’s my sin.”

Nizhoni remained by the door.

Caleb paced.

“And Tahome?”

Thomas’s face tightened.

“Five years ago, I decided to finish what I’d started. I found records Creed thought had burned. Land surveys. Payments to Bell. A federal deed proving our ownership of Black Ridge.”

“Where are they?”

“Hidden.”

“Where?”

Thomas looked toward Midnight.

Caleb understood.

“No.”

Thomas nodded.

“The horse knows.”

Caleb laughed in disbelief.

“You hid documents with a horse?”

“Not on him. Somewhere he can reach.”

Nizhoni stepped forward.

“Tahome followed Midnight.”

“Yes.”

“And Creed killed him?”

Thomas closed his eyes.

“I don’t know.”

“You said you could tell me how he died.”

“I can tell you why.”

Nizhoni’s face hardened.

Thomas continued.

“Tahome found me. I trusted him. He agreed to take copies of the evidence to a federal judge in Tucson.”

Her voice trembled.

“He never arrived.”

“No.”

“Who knew his route?”

Thomas hesitated.

Caleb saw it.

“Who?”

Thomas whispered, “Sheriff Bell.”

Nizhoni stood perfectly still.

Thomas went on.

“Bell had contacted me secretly. Claimed he wanted to confess. Claimed Creed had controlled him for years.”

“And you believed him,” Caleb said.

“I wanted to.”

Nizhoni left the cabin.

Caleb followed.

She stood beside Midnight.

Her shoulders were shaking.

“Don’t,” she said.

He stopped.

“I wasn’t going to say anything.”

“Good.”

A long moment passed.

Then she turned.

Her eyes were wet.

“I spent three years wondering whether my brother died because he was reckless.”

“He died because he was brave.”

“You don’t know that.”

“Neither do you.”

She looked at him.

Caleb continued.

“But I know what it costs to live sixteen years believing the worst story people tell you.”

Her breathing steadied.

Caleb stepped closer.

“You don’t have to do that.”

Nizhoni looked down.

Then, very slowly, she rested her forehead against his chest.

Caleb stood frozen.

He lifted one hand.

Stopped.

Then gently placed it against her back.

Neither spoke.

Midnight stood beside them.

For the first time since Caleb met the horse, the stallion closed his eyes.

They found the hiding place that afternoon.

Thomas walked with them despite his bad leg.

Midnight led them deeper into the canyon.

At a narrow ledge, the stallion stopped beside a lightning-split juniper tree.

Thomas smiled sadly.

“He remembers.”

Beneath the roots was a metal box.

Inside were deeds, ledgers, letters, and photographs.

Caleb read until his hands trembled.

Payments from Silas Creed to Sheriff Bell.

False cattle reports.

Names of witnesses who later disappeared.

And the original federal patent granting Black Ridge and its spring rights to Thomas Hayes.

There was enough evidence to destroy Silas.

Then Caleb found a second envelope.

His name was written across it.

Thomas reached for it.

“Don’t.”

Caleb looked up.

“Why?”

“That isn’t important.”

Caleb opened it.

Inside was a photograph.

Two men stood beside the Hayes barn.

One was Thomas.

The other was younger Silas Creed.

They were smiling.

Across the bottom, someone had written:

To my brother Thomas. May no land ever divide us.

Caleb looked at his father.

“Brother?”

Thomas sat down heavily.

Nizhoni frowned.

“Silas Creed is your brother?”

Thomas nodded.

“My half brother.”

Caleb laughed without humor.

“So he’s my uncle.”

“Yes.”

“You forgot that part?”

“I was getting there.”

Caleb threw the photograph onto the ground.

“What else haven’t you told me?”

Thomas said nothing.

“What else?”

“I never knew how far Silas would go.”

“Not what I asked.”

Thomas looked toward the box.

Caleb saw the answer before he heard it.

“The ranch fire,” Thomas said slowly, “wasn’t Silas’s idea.”

Caleb stopped.

“Whose was it?”

Thomas’s voice cracked.

“Mine.”

The canyon went silent.

Nizhoni stared.

Caleb did not understand.

Thomas spoke quickly.

“I was trying to burn the records Creed had planted in the barn. I thought if the forged ledgers were destroyed, he’d lose leverage.”

“You burned our ranch?”

“The fire spread.”

“My mother was dead. I was thirteen. You sent me away because you knew you were setting the barn on fire?”

“I thought I could control it.”

Caleb’s hands began shaking.

Thomas stood.

“I made a terrible mistake.”

“Then why let everyone blame Silas?”

Thomas did not answer.

Caleb backed away.

The man he had mourned.

The father he had idealized.

The innocent victim.

All of it cracked.

“Did Silas shoot you?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“Because he found out I was destroying evidence.”

“So he was still guilty.”

“Yes.”

“But the fire?”

“Mine.”

Caleb looked at the ruined photograph.

Then at Midnight.

“That’s what the message meant.”

Thomas frowned.

“Which message?”

“‘Trust the horse. Not the badge.'”

Thomas went pale.

News in the same category

She Joked That She Would Marry Any Man Who Could Tame the Black Mustang. When Caleb Hayes Stepped Into the Corral, Neither of Them Knew the Horse Had Been Waiting for Him

7 Part