She Laughed and Said "Let's See How You Survive Without My Money"

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"The prenuptial agreement is clear," said Margaret Hart, a woman in her sixties with iron-grey hair and the manner of a surgeon. "It was drafted by our firm, at your request, before your marriage. It protects each spouse's premarital intellectual property and separately held companies. Mr. Sutton's company, Sutton Systems LLC, was formed before the marriage. The Northstar platform was patented before the marriage. The agreement excludes both from the marital estate. There is no claim to be made against either one, by you or by the court, unless Mr. Sutton voluntarily agrees to transfer them, which he has no reason to do."

Natalie stared at the papers, and she said, "But the system runs our stores. All of them. Without it, we can't sell anything. How can it be his?"

"Because he built it," Margaret Hart said, simply. "And because he built it before he met you. And because the agreement you asked us to draft says that what he built before he met you is his. You cannot have it both ways, Natalie. You cannot draft an agreement that protects your family's money and then be surprised when it also protects his."

"And the maintenance?" Natalie asked. "He shut the whole company down. Surely that's illegal. Surely there's something we can do."

Margaret Hart opened the license agreement, and she turned to a page she had marked with a yellow tab, and she read aloud, slowly, "'The licensor reserves the right to suspend service for scheduled maintenance, provided that written notice is given to the licensee's designated account contact not less than forty-eight hours ahead of time.' Mr. Sutton gave notice on Monday, to Agnes Porter, by email. The notice was received. The maintenance was scheduled. The suspension is in full compliance with the agreement. There is no breach. There is no sabotage. There is a man exercising a contractual right, and there is a company that failed to read its own email."

The room was silent, and Natalie looked at the papers, and she looked at Margaret Hart, and she said, "So what do I do?"

"You negotiate," Margaret Hart said. "You offer to buy the system, or to license it on new terms, and you pay what it's worth, and you stop treating Mr. Sutton as though he were an employee you can order around, because he is not your employee, and he never was. He is the owner of the most valuable asset your company has ever had, and until you understand that, you will keep losing."

Natalie left the office with the papers in her bag, and she walked out onto Congress Avenue, and the afternoon sun was bright, and the street was full of people, and she thought about the gala, and about the envelope, and about the laughter, and she thought about the man she had married nine years ago, the man who had fixed her registers in eleven minutes, and she understood, finally, that she had spent nine years believing a story about her husband that had never been true, and that the person who had told her that story was still sitting in his office on the ninth floor, waiting for her to do what he wanted, and she made a decision, standing there on the sidewalk with the papers in her bag, that she would not do what he wanted, not anymore, and that whatever happened next, it would be her decision, and hers alone.

***

Natalie came to see me on the second day, and she came alone, without lawyers and without Owen, and she knocked on the door of the small apartment I had rented the morning after the gala, a place above a bookstore on South Congress with a window that looked out over the street, and when I opened the door, she was standing there in a grey suit with her hair pulled back, and she looked tired in a way I had never seen her look tired before, not the tired of a long day but the tired of a person who has not slept and does not expect to sleep again for a long time.

"Can I come in?" she asked, and her voice was different, quieter, stripped of the boardroom polish, and I stepped aside, and she came in, and she looked around the apartment, at the boxes I had not yet unpacked and the laptop on the kitchen table and the multimeter in the drawer, and she said, "This is where you live now?"

News in the same category

She Laughed and Said "Let's See How You Survive Without My Money"

45 Part