She Married Him to Give Him Shelter, Not Knowing He Owned the Whole Territory

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Esther did not answer at once, because she did not know, and because she had learned — in three years of widowhood, and one winter of marriage — that the worst answers are the quick ones. She went to the window and looked out at the creek, which ran low and bright through the low ground, the way it had run since before any of them were born, and she thought about what the creek meant. It was not just water. It was the reason the ranch existed. It was the reason George had chosen this ground, and the reason she had stayed after he died, and the reason Dwyer had wanted her hand seven years ago, and the reason he wanted her ruin now.

 

She thought about the neighbors, too. About Karin Solberg and her milk cows, and Anders Solberg and his narrow strip, and the schoolteacher, and the storekeeper's wife who had come in fear and spoken anyway. Dwyer would go to them with money, and some of them would be tempted, because money in the spring, when the seed must be bought and the debts from winter are still on the books, is a hard thing to refuse. And some of them would be afraid, because Dwyer held the railroad's ear, and the railroad held the freight rates, and fear is a currency that spends as well as cash.

 

But she thought about something else, too, something Dinah had said at her table, in the lamplight, with the bread between them: that the strongest evidence is not paper but a shared life others have seen. And she wondered, standing at the window with the creek running below, whether the same was true of water. Whether a creek that had been shared — that had watered Karin's cows and Anders's strip and the schoolhouse garden and the Breen lambs, all in their turn, for years — whether such a creek could be bought away share by share, or whether the people who had shared it would remember the sharing, and refuse.

 

The answer began to come that same week, and it came the way bad news and good news both come in a valley: in fragments, at fences, in the pauses between other sentences.

 

Dwyer went first to the Solberg place, because Karin Solberg was old and her sons were gone to the mines, and he thought an old woman alone would sell. He offered her twice what her share was worth, in cash, on the table, and he spoke of her sons, and of the railroad, and of the siding that might come, and of the comfort of money in the bank. Karin Solberg listened to all of it, the way she listened to everything — with her hands folded and her eyes on his face — and then she said, "Mr. Dwyer, my cows have drunk from that creek for twenty years, and my mother before me. I will not sell the water my cows drink to a man who wants to dry up my neighbor's ground. You may keep your money. It will not drink."

 

He went to Anders Solberg next, and Anders — who had once had his fence mended in February by a man with no fence of his own — laughed in Dwyer's face, not unkindly, and said that a man who mends your fence in the cold has earned something more than a neighbor's silence, and that he, Anders, was not in the habit of selling his friends' water to their enemies.

 

But not everyone refused. That was the hard part, and Esther would not have been honest if she had pretended otherwise. Two places down the creek, a young family newly arrived and deep in debt — the same young couple who had come to Dinah's table with a baby in a basket — were offered a sum that would have paid their mortgage outright, and they wavered. Esther heard about it from Dinah, who heard about it from the storekeeper's wife, and she lay awake that night thinking about them: about how easy it is to judge a person who is offered the price of their freedom, and about how she herself, seven years ago, had been offered a marriage for the price of her water, and had said no only because she already had a husband and a home.

 

She went to them herself, the next morning, before Dwyer could return. She did not go with money, because she had none to offer. She did not go with threats, because she had none to make. She went with the truth, and with Jesse beside her, the way they went everywhere now, side by side, the way people walk who are used to each other's pace.

News in the same category

She Married Him to Give Him Shelter, Not Knowing He Owned the Whole Territory

45 Part