They rode to the county seat in Dinah's wagon, the three of them crowded on the seat, the account book and the tally ledger wrapped in oilcloth between Esther's feet, and the road was rutted from the spring thaw. Esther watched the country pass — the creek, the low hills, the fences Jesse had mended in the first winter, standing straight now where they had sagged — and she thought about how strange it was that all of this, all the work of a year, had to be carried into a room and explained to men who had never lifted a fence post on her land.
The county office was a plain brick building on the main street of the county seat, with a clerk's desk and a long table and three chairs behind it for the board. It was not a courtroom, and it was not a town square, and Esther was glad of that. There would be no crowd here, no shouting, no performance for an audience. There would be a table, and papers, and questions asked in ordinary voices, and that, she thought, was the right shape for a question about a marriage and a water right. A marriage was not a spectacle. It was a life, lived in a house, and a water right was not a slogan. It was a ditch, dug by hand, and a creek that ran whether men argued about it or not.
Milo Ashby was already there when they arrived, the county clerk, forty years old and careful with his hands, with the mark registry and the land records laid out in neat stacks on the table. He greeted Esther with a nod that was neither warm nor cold, but professional, and he greeted Jesse the same way, and Esther took comfort in that. Milo Ashby was a man who believed in records, and records, she had learned, were kinder than rumors, because a record could be checked.
Reverend Ezra Field arrived next, tall and gray and quiet, carrying the marriage record book of the county in both hands, the way a man carries something fragile. He had married Esther and Jesse in the small church at Lone Pine, with Dinah Yost standing as witness, and he had written the date and the names and the witness's name in his book in his careful hand. He set the book down on the table and laid his hand on it for a moment, as if to steady himself, and then he sat down and folded his hands and waited.
Orson Dwyer arrived last. He came in alone, in a dark coat, with a leather case under his arm, and he smiled at the board as a man smiles when he believes the room is already his. He was fifty years old, a railroad land agent, and he had been polite to Esther for years in the way that a man is polite when he is waiting for a woman to become tired enough to give up. Years ago, before George Breen died, Dwyer had offered Esther what he called protection: marry him, he had said, and the ranch would be safe, and the water right would be secure, and she would never have to worry again. She had refused him then, because she had seen, even in that offer, the shape of a hand closing around something that was not his. Now he was back, and his argument was dressed up in law, but Esther knew it for what it was: the same hand, reaching again.
The board chairman, a broad man with spectacles and a voice that sounded tired before the morning had properly begun, called the hearing to order. He read the question aloud from a paper: whether the marriage of Esther Breen and Jesse Corso was valid under the law of the territory, and whether the water right of the Breen ranch, drawn from the creek, belonged to that ranch and its owners.
Dwyer spoke first. He was good at speaking first. He laid out his case in a smooth, reasonable voice, as if he were doing the board a favor by explaining something simple. The mark, he said, was not a signature. A man who could not write his name could not be said to have signed anything in the true sense, and a marriage record that rested on a mark, and ranch papers that rested on a mark, were papers built on sand. And a marriage, he said, glancing at Esther with something that was almost pity, that had been entered into in haste, in the autumn, by a widow alone on a ranch and a drifting man with nowhere to go, could not be called a marriage in the full sense of the word. It was an arrangement. It was shelter, not matrimony. And a water right, he said, belonged to those who could hold it and work it, not to a paper marriage.