"The categories were technically valid," Dr. Park replied. "The concern is whether the supporting documentation was sufficient to justify the classification and the payment."
Gregory Shaw folded his hands.
"The company had a large number of consulting arrangements. Some were handled by departments that no longer exist. It is possible that supporting materials were stored elsewhere."
"That is possible," Dr. Park said. "We have requested additional records to verify that explanation."
The meeting continued for more than two hours.
At 11:30, Emily Foster's statement was introduced.
She did not attend in person. Her lawyer had submitted a signed account describing her role in maintaining the vendor records, the requests she received to reclassify invoices, and the occasions when she asked for supporting documentation.
Her statement was careful.
She did not accuse Shaw of stealing money.
She did not claim to know why the archive had been moved.
She described what she had seen, what she had been asked to do, and which records she had handled.
That restraint gave her statement weight.
When Northstar's attorney questioned whether she might have misunderstood the instructions, Jonathan responded that the investigation was not asking the committee to accept her interpretation without verification.
"We are asking the committee to compare her account with the contemporaneous records," he said.
Dr. Park confirmed that several dates and invoice numbers in Emily's statement matched the system logs.
Gregory Shaw's expression remained controlled, but he began taking notes more frequently.
At noon, the meeting paused for lunch.
I found a quiet place near the windows and called Amara.
"How is it going?" she asked.
"We're establishing the timeline."
"That sounds like lawyer language."
"It is lawyer language."
She laughed.
"Any surprises?"
"Some records were moved into a restricted archive shortly before the financial review. The company says it was a security measure. We need to determine whether the explanation is supported."
"Do you believe them?"
"I believe we need more evidence."
"Dad."
"What?"
"You know what I'm asking."
I watched a delivery truck reverse into a narrow loading bay across the street.
"I don't know what Gregory Shaw intended. But I know the process wasn't documented well enough, and I know that the missing support is material to the transaction."
"That's fair."
"I don't want to accuse someone of dishonesty just because the facts look bad."
"Good. But don't let caution turn into an excuse for ignoring what the facts do show."
I smiled.
"You sound like your mother."
"I'll take that as a compliment."
"It was meant as one."
We ended the call, and I returned to the conference room.
The afternoon session focused on Meridian Strategic Services.
The forensic team had examined the company's invoices, payment records, and available correspondence. The firm had received approximately two-point-four million dollars from entities associated with Northstar's consulting network over eighteen months.
The records described a range of services, including market analysis, financing strategy, and transaction advisory work.
However, the team had found little evidence identifying the people who performed the work.
There were no detailed time records.
Several invoices referenced reports that had not been located.
Two payments appeared to have been processed before the dates on the corresponding invoices.
And one invoice listed a consulting engagement that, according to the company's calendar records, had never been scheduled.
Northstar's attorney objected to the suggestion that the payment was improper.
"The absence of a calendar invitation does not establish that a meeting did not occur," he said.
"Agreed," Dr. Park replied. "That is why we are requesting additional evidence."
Jonathan turned toward Gregory Shaw.
"Can you identify the person who performed the services listed on this invoice?"
Shaw examined the document.
"I would need to review the engagement records."
"Do you know whether the work was performed?"
"I cannot answer that based on this document alone."
"Who approved the payment?"
"My office approved many consulting payments. I would need to check the authorization record."
Jonathan nodded.
"That is precisely why we need the underlying records."
The exchange was calm.
No one shouted.
No one accused Shaw of criminal conduct.
Yet the room had changed.
The questions were no longer theoretical. The investigation had identified specific payments for which the company could not immediately produce the supporting evidence.
At 3:05 p.m., Dr. Park presented the findings concerning the airline connection.
Because the airline investigation was separate, the information was limited to records relevant to the consulting payments and the possible outside relationship involving Richard Cole.
The documents showed that Meridian Strategic Services had communicated with Cole about customer-service requests for business guests. One payment record listed an individual with the same name as the airline employee.
The forensic team had not yet established whether the payment recipient and the employee were the same person.
Nor had it established that the payment was connected to the seating incident.
Richard Cole's identity and employment details would need to be verified through the airline's records and the relevant financial documentation.
Victoria Hargrove's legal representative asked whether there was any evidence that Victoria had authorized a payment to Cole.
Dr. Park answered carefully.
"Not in the records reviewed to date."
The representative nodded.
"Then we should not imply that Ms. Hargrove was involved."
Jonathan agreed.
"We have made no such finding."
I looked toward Gregory Shaw.
He was studying the documents with an expression I could not interpret.
He might have been concerned about the missing records.
He might have been frustrated by the investigation.
He might have been calculating how the findings would affect the company.
I could not know.
At 4:10 p.m., the session concluded.
The committee agreed on three immediate steps.
First, Northstar would provide the remaining authorization records within five business days.
Second, the independent forensic team would verify the identity of the payment recipient listed in the Meridian Strategic Services records.
Third, Reed Meridian would maintain its hold on the acquisition until the financial disclosures could be verified.
As the participants gathered their papers, Gregory Shaw approached me.
"Mr. Reed, may I speak with you for a moment?"
Jonathan looked at me.