The Northstar board meeting began at 8:00 a.m. on Thursday.
Unlike the earlier technical sessions, this meeting was closed to the public and limited to the board, legal counsel, the independent review team, and representatives of Reed Meridian.
There would be no dramatic speeches.
No one would pound the table.
The most consequential decisions would be made through motions, recorded votes, and documents that would later become part of the formal record.
I sat beside Jonathan Mills and Elaine Porter.
Across the table, Gregory Shaw reviewed a stack of papers. Robert Ellison, the board member whose name appeared in the original authorization memorandum, sat to his right.
Peter Lang was not a board member and did not attend the meeting.
The board chair, Margaret Bell, opened the session by stating that the purpose was to review the preliminary findings and determine what further action Northstar should take.
Dr. Evelyn Park presented the results.
The investigation had confirmed that the archive migration took place as documented. The relevant files remained intact, but access permissions had been narrowed without sufficient supporting explanation.
The review had also identified multiple consulting payments for which Northstar had not yet produced adequate evidence of the services performed.
The total value of payments requiring further documentation was approximately six million dollars.
That figure did not represent a finding that six million dollars had been stolen or improperly spent.
It represented the amount for which the available records did not yet provide sufficient support.
Dr. Park repeated that distinction twice.
The board members listened in silence.
When she finished, Margaret Bell turned to Gregory Shaw.
"Mr. Shaw, can you explain why the archive permissions were changed?"
Shaw adjusted his papers.
"The folders contained commercially sensitive information related to a pending transaction. We believed it was appropriate to limit access."
"Who made that decision?"
"The request originated from my office."
"Was the change approved through the normal records-management process?"
"I believed it was."
"Can you provide the approval?"
Shaw hesitated.
"The documentation is incomplete."
Margaret Bell looked toward the company's legal counsel.
"Is that accurate?"
The attorney confirmed that the approval record did not contain the level of detail normally required for a change of that scope.
Bell turned back to Shaw.
"Why were the consulting payments processed without the supporting reports?"
Shaw looked down at the invoices.
"Some of the work was advisory in nature. Not all of it produced a formal report."
"Then how were the services evaluated?"
"Through discussions with the consultants and the internal teams involved."
"Where are the records of those discussions?"
"We are still trying to locate them."
A board member on the far side of the table spoke.
"How long have you been trying to locate them?"
"Since the review began."
"Why weren't they maintained with the payment records?"
Shaw took a breath.
"That is something we need to investigate."
Margaret Bell wrote a note.
Robert Ellison shifted in his chair.
"I want to caution the board against treating administrative deficiencies as proof of misconduct," he said. "Northstar has operated across several regions, with different systems and reporting structures. There may be innocent explanations for some of these gaps."
"That is a fair caution," Bell replied. "But it does not answer the questions."
Ellison nodded.
"I agree."
I watched the exchange carefully.
There was no reason to assume Ellison was guilty simply because his name appeared on the authorization memorandum. He had a responsibility to explain his role, and the board had a responsibility to examine it.
The meeting continued.
Elaine Porter reviewed the financial consequences of the missing documentation. She explained that Reed Meridian could not verify certain liabilities, consulting expenses, and transaction-related obligations without additional evidence.
The uncertainty affected the valuation of Northstar.
It also affected the protections that would need to be included in any purchase agreement.
"If the records cannot be verified," Elaine said, "we would need either a price adjustment, an escrow arrangement, specific indemnities, or some combination of those protections. Depending on the magnitude of the unresolved items, we may decide that the transaction is no longer commercially reasonable."
Margaret Bell nodded.
"Can you quantify the potential exposure?"
"Not responsibly at this stage. The six million dollars represents payments requiring additional support, not necessarily a loss. The actual exposure could be lower. It could also be higher if the missing records reveal additional obligations."
Shaw leaned forward.
"That uncertainty is exactly why I have concerns about the way this investigation is being presented. We are discussing potential exposure as though it were established."
Elaine met his gaze.
"We are not. We are explaining why the absence of evidence matters to a purchaser. If you provide the supporting records, the uncertainty can be reduced."
Shaw said nothing.
The board then considered the status of the acquisition.
Margaret Bell asked me to explain Reed Meridian's position.
I stood.
"We remain interested in Northstar's operating business. It has skilled employees, valuable infrastructure, and a customer base that could benefit from investment. But we cannot proceed on the assumption that every unexplained payment is legitimate or that every missing record is evidence of wrongdoing."
I looked around the table.
"Our position is simple. We need accurate disclosures, independently verifiable records, and a fair process for determining what the company is worth. If the review establishes that the payments were legitimate, we will take that into account. If it establishes that material obligations were concealed, we will take that into account as well."
Margaret Bell asked whether we would consider continuing the acquisition with additional protections.
"Yes, if the evidence supports it and the resulting terms are commercially reasonable."
"And if the records remain incomplete?"
"Then we may have to withdraw."
The chair thanked me and called for a recess.
During the break, Jonathan and I stepped into the hallway.
"What do you think?" he asked.
"I think the board understands the seriousness of the problem."
"Do you think Shaw is hiding something?"
"I think he has not provided adequate answers. That is not the same as proving why."
Jonathan nodded.
"You're consistent."
"I hope so."
When we returned, the board announced its decisions.
First, Northstar would appoint an independent compliance monitor to oversee the remaining review.
Second, Gregory Shaw would be temporarily removed from responsibility for approving external consulting payments while the board examined his role in the authorization process.
Third, all consulting payments involving Meridian Strategic Services and related entities would be suspended pending verification.
Fourth, Northstar would preserve all relevant records and provide the forensic team with access to the remaining authorization logs.
Finally, the board would reconvene in ten business days to consider the findings and determine whether further action was necessary.
The decisions were significant, but they were not declarations of guilt.
They were safeguards.