nineties on Lot Eighteen, one probably taken out when the county relaid
the water main in 2004. Nine remain where Voss set them. I recovered
each one, photographed it in place, and tied it to the county's control
network. Mrs. Osei, an independent licensee with no connection to my
firm, re-ran my corner recoveries from the raw observations and
countersigned the record of survey. That record is filed at the county.
Anyone in this room can pull it up this afternoon."
"And the fence at Fourteen Larkspur Lane, measured from those
monuments?"
"The fence stands inside Lot Fourteen along its whole length. At the
lilac, the original pin is nineteen inches on the greenbelt side of the fence
line. The fence never reaches the boundary, let alone crosses it. Mr.
Brandt built shy of his own line in 2009 and rebuilt on the same posts in
2022. He gave the association nineteen inches of his own land rather than
argue about a tape measure. It is, if I may say so, the most considerate
fence I have ever surveyed."
A small sound went through the gallery, not quite a laugh. The judge
did not look up from her notes, but Eloise saw her write something down,
and realised she would give a great deal to know whether the judge had
written the measurement or the word considerate.
"The path," Tran said.
"The path is on the lots. The association's gravel path, as built and as
maintained for at least twenty years, crosses the true line along the whole
row and lies on private land for most of its length. At Lot Fourteen it
takes up to four feet two inches of Mrs. Brandt's lot. At Lot Twelve, the
greenbelt gate — the association's gate, with the association's lock —
stands three feet nine inches inside Mrs. Toomey's lot. The drainage
swale crosses the line at Lot Twenty-two and runs on Mrs. Grant's land.
The association has been maintaining its path, its gate, and its drainage
on its residents' property for two decades, and fining the residents, in the
case of Mrs. Brandt, for the privilege of standing in its way."
He testified about the track last, and he testified about it the way he
had testified about everything, as a man reading measurements off the
earth. The twelve-foot gravel way along the north line was not, in his
professional opinion, a maintenance path that had grown. It was a graded
haul road: crowned, ditched, laid with a depth of aggregate no footpath
requires, built to a width and a turning radius at the Brandt gate that
matched, he said, the county's own standard detail for construction
access. "Maintenance of a walking path needs a pickup truck twice a
year. This was built for loaded tandems. And it ends — it does not pass, it
ends — at a staked rectangle on Lot Fourteen, here, in the photographs,
marked with a developer's lath and flagging, dimensioned forty by sixty.
In my trade that is a construction compound. Staging. Somebody
measured Mrs. Brandt's back lot for a site office and a materials yard, and
drove the stakes, and nobody asked her."
Sandhu's cross-examination was long and able and, as it proceeded,
increasingly confined to a narrowing strip of ground. He established that
Nate had been paid by Eloise — Nate agreed, and produced his invoice,
and observed that the association had paid its own surveyor a comparable
sum. He established that pins can be disturbed — Nate agreed, and
explained, with the patience of a man who has had this conversation at
fence lines for twenty-six years, how nine pins agreeing with one another,
with Voss's notes, and with the recorded distances along the whole row
could not have wandered into agreement by accident. He established that
Nate was not a lawyer and could not say who owned what. "I don't decide
ownership," Nate said. "I find the corners. The corner at the lilac is where
Voss put it in 1978. Everything else in this courtroom is arithmetic done
standing on that iron." Claire Osei testified after Nate, briefly, in the
manner of a woman confirming a sum. She had re-run the recoveries. The
pins were the pins. The line was the line. She would have signed for
either side, she said, because the iron does not know who retained her.
Sandhu, wisely, asked her almost nothing.
Then the association called its own surveyor, and the case turned, in
the space of one afternoon, from a disagreement into a demonstration.
Raymond Kittredge was a licensed surveyor of twenty years' standing,
and Eloise tried, out of professional sympathy, to be fair to him in her
mind as he took the stand. He had been retained by Pinnacle Commons
Management in the spring, given the subdivision's covenants and a work
order, and asked to verify an encroachment. He had measured the Brandt
fence and found it, as his report said, three feet inside the boundary of the
common parcel. On direct examination he was confident and unhurried.
The boundary, he explained, was shown on the association's improvement
drawings — the greenbelt plan, drawn when the path was built — and he
had measured from the path's established edge, the line the association
had maintained and treated as its boundary for twenty years.
Tran rose for cross-examination with Voss's field notes in her hand,