newer as it went — the gravel whiter, the edges rawer — and it ended,
abruptly, in a squared-off pad of gravel and a pair of survey ribbons on
stakes, directly behind the Brandt fence, at the Brandt gate.
Biscuit sniffed the new gravel with deep professional suspicion. Eloise
stood on the pad that somebody had built at the end of somebody's road,
looking at the back of her own fence, at the gate Walter had hung with his
own hands, and she experienced the particular nausea of a person who
has been handed the wrong end of a story and has just felt it turn over in
her grip.
She had been defending the fence as a fence. Positionally — she heard
her old supervisor's voice in her head, classifying — it might not be a
fence dispute at all. It might be a road dispute wearing a fence dispute's
coat. A three-foot encroachment, a gate that opens without authorization:
read the other way around, those are not complaints about a structure.
Those are the opening moves in the removal of an obstruction. Somebody
wanted to come through here — through the line where her fence and
gate stood — with something wider than a mower. A maintenance road,
perhaps, that a map could later remember as an access road. And a road,
once it exists and has been used and maintained and photographed from
the air for a season, grows legal moss of its own. Eloise knew that much
from the calls: easements by use, prescriptive claims, the whole slow
jurisprudence of the driven-over ground. People fought those cases for
years, out on the county's edges, and the side that had poured the gravel
usually started two lengths ahead.
She walked home slowly and stood in her garden and looked at the
lilac, which was coming into leaf over the corner post, and at Walter's
boards, silvered and plain, and she said aloud, to the dog, the sentence
that had been forming in her all morning.
"They don't want it down because it's in the wrong place. They want it
down because it's in their way — which means the wrong place is
wherever they need it to be."
She was careful, in the notebook, to write it as a question rather than a
conclusion. Why the track? Whose vehicles? Paid from what account,
approved at what meeting? She requested, by certified letter, the minutes
and the work orders for greenbelt improvements for the previous twelve
months, and the association's contract with High Desert Site Services,
and the management agreement with Pinnacle Commons Management.
The reply, when it came, came from a lawyer this time — a Bend firm
with a name like a ski lodge — and it was three paragraphs long and
contained, by Eloise's count, one fact: that the association respectfully
declined to produce internal operational documents to individual
residents outside the processes provided in the covenants. It closed by
noting that her fines now stood at $4,850, that the final compliance date
was the Saturday of Nate Brooks's survey — a coincidence she did not
believe in for one second, since she had mentioned the survey date to no
one at the association, and had written it, in pencil, on a calendar that
hung in her own kitchen — and that the Enforcement Unit would attend
on that date to supervise removal and to take such further steps as
noncompliance required.
She read the letter twice. Then she telephoned Nate Brooks and asked,
in the voice she used for requesting a unit to step it up, whether there was
any possibility in the world that he could come at eight in the morning
instead of ten.
There was a pause on the line, of a man consulting a schedule and,
behind the schedule, the tone of the request.
"Mrs. Brandt," Nate said, "in twenty years of surveying, nobody has
ever asked me to come earlier to a fence. I'll be there at seven-thirty. If
somebody's planning a surprise at your place, I'd just as soon be set up
before the surprise arrives — and I'll bring my big tripod. People behave
better around expensive instruments. It's a known law of nature."
Then she telephoned Marge, and Devon, and — after a hesitation she
examined and approved of — Alisha Grant and Frank Yuen, and she told
each of them the same plain thing: that the association had fixed Saturday
for the fence, that the surveyor would be working from half past seven,
that she intended to be in her own yard drinking her own coffee in view
of her own fence, and that if any of them happened to be in their yards
that morning too, she would be glad of the company. She did not ask
anyone to intervene. She did not have to. There is a difference, on a street
that has been quietly frightened for sixteen months, between being asked
to fight and being told where to stand.
"From the curb, she said to me," Alisha said, down the line, in a voice
gone suddenly bright and hard. "All right, Mrs. Brandt. Saturday I'll be
standing on mine. Let everybody see exactly who's standing where, this
time."
And Frank Yuen said, "I will bring my calipers," in the tone of a man
who has been waiting, without knowing it, for someone to give his
instruments a war to go to.