Yes, ma'am.
I wondered what happened to you.
I was told she died.
Eleanor's expression changed.
That was a lie.
The words landed with such force that Jack had to grip the back of a chair.
Maggie stepped forward.
Mrs. Price, can you tell us what happened?
Eleanor looked toward the window.
For a while, she said nothing.
Then she began.
Rebecca had been confined to the estate after her father discovered the pregnancy. She had tried to leave several times, and each attempt had resulted in tighter restrictions.
Frank Delaney had become a frequent visitor.
He claimed to be helping David Hale protect the family's reputation.
In truth, Eleanor believed Frank wanted Rebecca for himself.
He was always watching her, Eleanor said. "Always finding excuses to be near her. She despised him."
Jack felt sick.
Did she love anyone else?
No.
Was she married?
Eleanor shook her head.
Never.
Jack closed his eyes.
Eleanor continued.
Rebecca gave birth in a small private clinic. Her father arranged everything. He said the child had died.
Did you see the baby?
Eleanor hesitated.
Yes.
Jack opened his eyes.
What did you see?
A little girl. Dark hair. Hazel eyes. She was crying so loudly that the nurse laughed.
Jack's breath caught.
What happened to her?
Rebecca was told the baby had died. She was devastated. She refused to eat for days. Then, one evening, I heard her speaking to someone in the hallway.
Who?
Frank.
Eleanor's voice trembled.
He told her that if she continued asking questions, the child would never be safe.
Jack stared at her.
Are you saying he threatened a newborn?
I'm saying Frank Delaney was a cruel man who believed everything belonged to him.
Maggie leaned forward.
Do you know where the child went?
Eleanor nodded slowly.
Not exactly. But I remember the nurse's name. Helen Morris.
She gave Maggie an address.
Then she looked at Jack.
There's something else.
He waited.
Rebecca never stopped waiting for you.
The room seemed to grow smaller.
She believed you would come back. Even after her father told her you had abandoned her, even after he said you had married someone else, she believed you would come back.
Jack's eyes filled.
I wrote to her.
I know.
What?
Eleanor reached into the drawer beside her bed and removed a small envelope.
Inside were several letters.
Jack recognized his handwriting immediately.
His hands shook as he unfolded the first one.
Rebecca,
I'm coming home next week. I have enough money saved to rent a small place, and my uncle says I can have a job at the garage permanently. I don't know what your father will say, but I don't care anymore. I want to marry you. I want to raise our child with you.
Wait for me beneath the oak tree.
I love you.
Jack.
He read the letter again.
Then again.
How did you get these?
Eleanor's voice softened.
Your letters were intercepted. I found them in a box after David Hale died. I kept them because I thought one day someone might need to know the truth.
Jack pressed the paper against his chest.
For thirty-four years, he had believed Rebecca had stopped loving him.
Now he knew she had waited.
He had been wrong about the most important thing in his life.
Maggie placed a hand on his shoulder.
Jack bowed his head.
And for the first time since he was twenty-one, he allowed himself to grieve not only the woman he had lost, but the years he had spent believing she had chosen to lose him.
When Jack returned to Willow Street, Sarah was waiting on the porch.
She had the silver charm in one hand and Frank Delaney's business card in the other.
Did you know my mother was pregnant?
Jack stopped.
Yes.
Did you know she had a baby?
Yes.
Did you know that baby might have been me?
He couldn't answer quickly enough.
Sarah's face crumpled.
You knew.
I suspected.
And you didn't tell me.
I didn't have proof.
She laughed bitterly.
Neither do I. But at least I didn't spend thirty-four years looking for someone who might not exist.
Jack flinched.
Sarah immediately regretted the words, but she couldn't take them back.
She had spent the day thinking about her mother, the necklace, and the man who claimed to have loved her.
Now the truth seemed to be unfolding around her like a storm she could neither predict nor escape.
What happened to my father? she asked.
Jack shook his head.
I don't know.
My mother told me David Carter was my father.
I never knew him.
Then who was he?
I don't know.
Sarah pressed the heel of her hand against her forehead.
Every answer creates another question.
I know.
No, Jack. You don't. You got to mourn a woman you believed was dead. I had her. I grew up with her. I listened to her stories. I watched her grow old. And now I don't know which parts of my life were true.
Jack stepped closer.
Sarah, I can't undo what happened.
Then don't pretend you can fix it.
He stopped.
For a moment, the only sound was the rustling of leaves above them.
Finally, Jack said, "I won't."
Sarah looked at him.
But I won't stop looking for the truth.
She glanced down at the charm.
Neither will I, she thought.
Because if her mother had been forced to hide the truth, Sarah deserved to know why.
And if Frank Delaney had been part of it, he was going to discover that the little girl who had once sold a bicycle for five dollars had grown into a woman who would no longer allow other people to decide what she was allowed to know.
The first thing Sarah did was call her mother's old doctor.
The second was search every box of family photographs, letters, and documents she had kept since Rebecca's death.
The third was something she had never expected to do.
She called Jack Sullivan.
He answered on the second ring.
Sarah?
I need your help.
There was a pause.
All right.
I don't want money.
I understand.
I don't want you to arrange a job or send people to my house.