How old is Sarah?
Thirty-four.
Maggie slowly set down her coffee.
Jack stared into his cup.
Thirty-four.
Exactly the age Rebecca's child would have been.
Maggie whispered his name.
He stood abruptly.
Don't.
I'm not going to tell you what to think.
Good.
But you need to ask her.
And say what? Sorry about yesterday's groceries. By the way, I was told my pregnant girlfriend and our baby died thirty-four years ago, but you've got her necklace and her eyes?
Maggie considered that.
When you put it like that, perhaps don't start with the groceries.
Despite himself, Jack almost laughed.
The sound died quickly.
Maybe Rebecca gave the necklace away, he said.
Maybe.
Maybe Sarah bought it.
Maybe.
Maybe I saw it wrong.
Maggie folded her arms.
You want me to agree with you or help you?
Jack sat again.
Help.
Then start by finding out what Sarah knows about her mother. Don't tell her what you suspect. Don't tell her what you want the answer to be. And don't turn an innocent woman into the solution to thirty-four years of unanswered questions.
Jack looked at her.
Since when did you become a philosopher?
Since you started behaving like an idiot.
He nodded slowly.
Maggie was right.
If Sarah was Rebecca's daughter, she had already lived an entire life without him. She had lost a husband, struggled to raise a child, and reached a point where she couldn't afford to feed herself.
Jack had no right to walk into that life and demand that she make sense of his past.
But he had every reason to ask questions.
And he intended to begin that morning.
At 7:14 a.m., Jack knocked on Sarah Carter's front door.
He carried two coffees and a paper bag containing breakfast sandwiches, fresh fruit, and a cinnamon roll that Maggie had insisted would be "good for morale."
Sarah opened the door wearing the same blue blouse and a pair of faded jeans.
For a moment, neither spoke.
Then she looked at the coffee.
Do bikers ever sleep?
Not after forty.
She almost smiled.
Then she noticed his expression.
What's wrong?
Can we talk?
Her stomach tightened.
About what?
Jack looked past her toward the kitchen.
Your mother.
Sarah's hand tightened around the door.
My mother?
Rebecca Hale.
Every trace of warmth disappeared from her face.
How do you know that name?
Jack slowly reached beneath his shirt and pulled out the silver charm.
Sarah froze.
Her fingers rose instinctively to her own necklace.
For several seconds, neither spoke.
Then she whispered, "Where did you get that?"
I made it.
She shook her head.
No.
I made two.
No.
Sarahโ
My mother gave me this when I turned eighteen.
Jack's voice dropped.
I gave hers to her when she turned twenty.
Sarah stepped backward.
The door opened wider.
She looked at his face, really looked at him, not as a stranger or a biker but as a man who had said her mother's name as though it still belonged somewhere inside him.
What are you saying?
I don't know yet.
Then don't stand on my porch and say things like that.
You're right.
Sarah's breathing quickened.
My mother never mentioned you.
Jack flinched.
I know.
No, you don't.
Sarahโ
Who are you?
He looked down, then back at her.
My name is Jack Sullivan.
The coffee tray trembled slightly in his hand.
I knew your mother before you were born.
Sarah said nothing.
We were together.
Her eyes narrowed.
Together how?
Jack let out a slow breath.
We were going to get married.
The porch seemed to tilt.
Sarah gripped the doorframe.
Jack continued carefully.
She was pregnant when I left for six months to work with my uncle in Montana. I wrote every week. At first she wrote back. Then nothing.
Sarah's lips parted.
Stop.
Her father told me she'd left town.
Stop.
Months later, he sent me a letter saying Rebecca and the baby were gone.
Sarah's face drained.
You're lying.
I wish I were.
My father was David Carter.
Jack went still.
Who?
David Carter. He died before I was born.
I never knew anyone named David Carter.
My mother told me he was my father.
Jack stared at her.
Sarah shook her head as if trying to dislodge a thought that had no right to exist.
You're a stranger who showed up yesterday. You gave my daughter money, brought half the neighborhood to my house, and now you're telling me my mother had some secret life with you?
I understand how it sounds.
No, you don't.
You're right. I don't.
Her eyes filled with angry tears.
My mother was a good woman.
I know.
Don't say that.
Jack swallowed.
I knew her when we were young. I loved her. Whatever happened between us, I never stopped caring about her.
Sarah looked down at the charm in his hand.
She gave me this necklace.
I know.
She told me it belonged to someone important.
Jack's heart struck painfully against his ribs.
What exactly did she say?
Sarah hesitated.
Then she shook her head.