Gus listened to them, and he felt the shame he had carried for two years settle into something different, something heavier and also something cleaner. He had thought his apology belonged to Ingrid alone, because it was Erik's toolbox he had carried. But it belonged to these women too, and to their children, and to the camp, and the only way to pay it was the way he was paying it now: by saying the truth aloud, in a room where it would be written down, and by standing there while it was said, without flinching and without leaving.
The commissioners retired to consider, and the waiting was the hardest part, because waiting is always the hardest part for men who have said everything they have to say and can only hope it was enough. Gus sat beside Ingrid on a bench outside the hearing room, and his knee throbbed, and his hands were empty without the toolbox, which the chairman had kept for the record, and Ingrid took his hand, briefly, and said, "Whatever they decide, it has been said. That matters."
When the commissioners returned, the chairman read their decision in a flat, official voice, and the words were these: the company was fined for the use of unsound timber, and was ordered to pay compensation to Erik Johansson's family, and to the families of the other men killed in the collapse of 1881, and to the residents of Alkali Springs for the losses suffered while the camp was cut off, and to build and maintain a proper bridge at the Alkali Springs crossing at the company's expense, the bridge Gus and Ingrid and Sani had already built to stand as the model and, until the company's own work was inspected, as the crossing itself.
Holloway's lawyer objected, and Holloway said nothing at all, and the newspaperman wrote fast in his notebook, and the two widows in the back row wept quietly, and Ingrid closed her tin box with a click that sounded, in the quiet room, like a door closing on two years of silence.
The chairman read the findings of fact before he read the decision, and Gus was glad of it, because findings are harder to forget than punishments. The board found that the timber used in the Dry Creek bridge had been unsound when it was put in place, and that the company had known or should have known it, because the practice of painting dead timber had been called out by its own inspectors before and ignored. The board found that the company had failed, after the flood, to repair the Alkali Springs crossing, although the crossing served a settled camp and although the company held the grant for the water. And the board found that the petitions of Ingrid Johansson had been received and had not been answered, and that a company which takes a grant from the territory takes with it the duty to answer the people who live under that grant.
Holloway's lawyer asked for time to appeal, and the chairman said the company could appeal the fine if it wished, but the compensation was to be paid within thirty days, and the bridge at Alkali Springs was to be built and maintained at the company's expense regardless of any appeal, because a camp could not wait for lawyers while its wool rotted and its children went without a doctor. The lawyer wrote something down and said nothing more, and Holloway, who had not spoken since his own testimony, stood and put on his hat, and walked out of the room without looking at Gus or at Ingrid or at the widows, and Gus thought that was fitting, in its way: a man who had hidden behind paper for two years leaving through a door, quietly, while the people he had hidden from remained.
Outside the hearing room, the newspaperman from Rock Springs asked Gus if he had anything to say for the paper, and Gus thought for a moment, and then he said only this: that Erik Johansson had kept a piece of rotten wood because he believed somebody, someday, would want to know the truth, and that today somebody had. The newspaperman wrote it down, word for word, and Gus hoped it would print true, because Erik deserved at least that much: to be remembered not as a man who died under a bridge, but as a man who kept the proof that the bridge should never have been built that way.