"“Stop yelling, boy—you fit the complaint, and now you’re going to learn what happens when you talk back to me.”

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

On Tuesday she called dispatch. She did not go downstairs to do it. She stayed in the small room and used the phone on the table, because she wanted the call on the record and she wanted her notes in front of her. She asked for the supervisor on duty and then she asked, in the careful, unhurried voice she used for all such calls, for confirmation of the tape length and the log. The supervisor told her the call was forty-one seconds long. Whitfield repeated the number back. Forty-one seconds. She asked if there was a second call, a follow-up, a second caller, any additional information logged after 14:03. There was not. She asked if the caller had given a name. The caller had not. She asked if the caller had stayed on the line. The caller had not. She asked for the audio file to be preserved and for a written confirmation of the chain of custody for that audio, and the supervisor said it was already preserved and that he would send the confirmation by the end of the day. Whitfield thanked him and hung up, and then she sat with the number forty-one written in the margin of her pad. Forty-one seconds to create a record that contained almost nothing, and then seventeen minutes in a park to act as if it contained something. She wrote: Dispatch audio 0:41. Single caller. No crime alleged. Log lines spare and consistent with audio. No elaboration by dispatcher. That was the fact, and she would not let it be elaborated later by memory.

It was on Tuesday afternoon, while she was cross-checking the inventory of records, that she discovered what was not there. She had assumed, as most people would, that there would be body-camera footage. Mercer was a sergeant. The department had body cameras. The park was a public place in daylight. She went through the file twice, then she called the equipment office, then she called Mercer's supervisor, and then she sat down and wrote the finding in her pad in capital letters so she would not soften it later. NO BODY-CAMERA FOOTAGE. Mercer had not been wearing an activated body camera that afternoon. There was no footage from his perspective, no audio from his microphone, no record of what he said before the witnesses began recording, no record of what he said after they stopped. The three witnesses' videos and the dispatch audio were the only record. She understood immediately what that absence meant, and she understood that she would have to explain it in plain language to people who would want it to mean something else. It did not mean Mercer was guilty. It did not mean he was innocent. It meant the department could not corroborate his account from its own equipment, and it meant the civilian videos, imperfect and partial as they were, were not supplementary. They were primary. She wrote that down too, and she underlined primary. She also wrote a note to herself to check the activation policy, the assignment log for that shift, and whether Mercer had signed out a camera that day. Those were facts she could establish without speculation, and she would establish them before she wrote her memo.

On Wednesday she interviewed the dispatcher. She did it in the same small room, at the same table, with the same monitor turned off and pushed to the side so it would not distract them. The dispatcher was a woman in her thirties who had been on the job for six years, and she was nervous in the way people are when they know they did nothing wrong but are afraid they will be blamed anyway. Whitfield began by telling her that, by telling her she was a witness to a record, not a subject of the investigation, and she watched the woman's shoulders drop a fraction. Then she played the forty-one-second tape once, on the small speaker, and asked the dispatcher to walk her through it second by second. The dispatcher did, calmly, pointing to the log as she spoke. Call received 14:02. Caller reports young man in gray hoodie loitering near playground. No crime alleged. No further description offered. Dispatcher asks if the caller can describe the person further. Caller says no, just the hoodie, just loitering. Dispatcher logs it as suspicious-person check at 14:03. That was it. Whitfield asked if the dispatcher had added anything later, if Mercer had called in with additional information, if anyone had amended the log. No. The log was as it had been at 14:03. Whitfield asked her to initial each line of the printed log, and the dispatcher did, and then Whitfield initialed beside her. It was a small act, but it fixed the record in place. She thanked the dispatcher and walked her out, and then she returned to the room and wrote: Dispatcher credible, consistent, log unamended. No embellishment at intake. Escalation occurred in field, not on call.

News in the same category

"“Stop yelling, boy—you fit the complaint, and now you’re going to learn what happens when you talk back to me.”

45 Part