"“Stop yelling, boy—you fit the complaint, and now you’re going to learn what happens when you talk back to me.”

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The sweatshirt was in the evidence room by then, and on Wednesday afternoon Whitfield went down to see it, because she had learned early in her career that paper descriptions were not enough. The property officer brought it out in a brown paper bag, sealed with evidence tape, with a chain-of-custody form attached to the front in a clear sleeve. Whitfield read the form before she looked inside. Collected by Officer R. Patel from the Ellis home the following morning, from the paper bag on the laundry room shelf, with his father's consent noted. Sealed at 10:15. Logged into evidence at 11:20. Transferred to the property room that afternoon. Each transfer signed, each time noted. She asked the officer to open the bag, and he did, with gloves, on a clean sheet of paper. The gray hooded sweatshirt was folded loosely, and the grass stains were visible even in the fluorescent light of the evidence room, dark green streaks across the back and along one sleeve, with a faint smear of dirt near the hem. Whitfield did not touch it. She looked at it for a long time and then she asked the officer to reseal it and to note her inspection on the form. She signed and dated the entry. The sweatshirt was not a dramatic piece of evidence. It was a piece of clothing a nineteen-year-old had been wearing while drinking coffee on a bench, and now it was in a paper bag with a form attached to it, and the grass on it was the only physical trace of what had happened on the grass beside the concrete walkway. She wrote in her pad: Sweatshirt, gray hoodie, grass-streaked, in paper bag, chain intact. No tears noted. No contraband noted. She thought about Jordan Ellis's part-time work in the campus bookstore, about the fact that he would need another sweatshirt for his next shift, and she put that thought aside, because her job was not to imagine his week. Her job was to preserve the record of it.

The union representative called on Thursday morning. Whitfield had been expecting the call, and she had prepared for it by clearing her desk and by having Mercer's report and the dispatch log in front of her, not because she needed them but because she wanted the representative to hear the sound of paper when she turned a page. The representative was polite and experienced, a man who had made this call many times before. He said he was calling on behalf of Sergeant Mercer, that Mercer had sixteen years of service, that he had a good record, that he was concerned about the direction of the investigation. Whitfield listened without interrupting, and then she said, in the same even voice she had used with the dispatcher, that she understood, that she was conducting a fact-finding review, that she had not reached any conclusions, and that she would interview Mercer at the appropriate time with representation present if he wished. The representative asked if she could share what the videos showed. She said she could not share the contents of the investigation while it was ongoing, but she could confirm that she had received three civilian videos and the dispatch audio, and that there was no body-camera footage to review. There was a pause on the line after that, a short silence that told her the representative had not known about the missing camera either. He asked if Mercer would be placed on leave. She said that decision was not hers to make. He thanked her and said he would be in touch. Whitfield hung up and wrote down the time of the call, the name of the representative, and the substance of what had been said, in three short lines. She did not write down what she thought about the call, because what she thought was not part of the record.

The deputy chief asked to see her on Thursday afternoon, and Whitfield knew before she walked into his office what he was going to ask. His office was larger than the interview room, with a window that looked out over the parking lot and a desk that was neat in the way of a man who had learned to keep his surface clear. He offered her a chair and coffee, and she declined the coffee but took the chair. He began by talking about the department, about morale, about the difficulty of policing in a community where every interaction could be recorded. He spoke carefully, choosing his words, and Whitfield listened carefully, choosing hers in return. Then he asked the question, in the careful voice she had expected. He asked whether the case could be handled quietly, whether it needed to become a formal matter, whether there was a way to resolve it internally without a lengthy process. He did not say the words federal or civil rights. He did not need to. He said quietly, and Whitfield understood that quietly meant without a paper trail that left the building. She looked at him for a moment, and then she answered him directly, because indirect answers would have been a different kind of evasion. She said no. She said the case could not be handled quietly because there were already three videos in civilian hands, because there was a dispatch tape that was forty-one seconds long and a log that was spare and unamended, because there was a nineteen-year-old who had been on the grass and a father who had arrived at 14:17 and a chief of staff who had taken notes, and because quiet would require her to ignore what she had already seen and heard. She said she would follow the process, she would document what she found, she would write an interim memo, and she would let the facts determine the next steps. The deputy chief nodded slowly, and he did not argue. He said he understood, and he said he expected her memo by Monday. Whitfield stood, thanked him, and walked back to the small room, where the monitor and the files were waiting. She wrote down the conversation immediately, while it was fresh, including his exact word quietly and her exact answer, because she knew that conversation would matter later, even if no one else ever read her note about it.

News in the same category

"“Stop yelling, boy—you fit the complaint, and now you’re going to learn what happens when you talk back to me.”

45 Part