"The correspondence shows his office received them. Other records indicate he discussed the objections."
Chairman Liang sighed.
"Your mother asked them to correct the summaries before anyone signed."
Camille closed her eyes.
She could almost hear Anning's voice.
Read the obligations, Xiaoyu. Not just the promises.
Rebecca turned another page.
"An additional review of the internal accounting records suggests that certain consulting payments lacked adequate supporting documentation."
Camille opened her eyes.
"Bayfront Advisory?"
"Among others."
Chen Wei leaned forward.
"Some payments were connected to services that may have been legitimate. Others require further explanation."
Mei added, "The consortium has instructed independent counsel to evaluate appropriate next steps."
Camille nodded.
She was grateful that nobody in the room was declaring a criminal conspiracy merely because the documents looked troubling.
Her mother would have insisted on the same discipline.
But the next finding changed the atmosphere.
Rebecca removed a separate letter.
"This was produced by Whitmore Global's external counsel."
Camille recognized the date.
November 2006.
The month Anning had left Beijing.
The letter had been sent from Adrian Keller to a Northstar executive.
Its subject line read:
CONSULTANT COMMUNICATIONS β L. ANNING
Camille's hands began trembling.
Rebecca explained that the correspondence discussed options for resolving the dispute with Anning, including proposed confidentiality provisions and potential legal claims.
The language was aggressive.
Several passages suggested that the company's representatives wanted to discourage further challenges to the transaction.
Camille stared at the letter.
"Is this what drove her away?"
Rebecca paused.
"We know pressure was applied. We do not know whether this correspondence explains every reason your mother left the work."
Camille nodded.
"But it was part of it."
"It appears to have been."
For a moment, she wanted to leave the room.
She wanted to walk outside, breathe fresh air, and escape the strange sensation of watching her mother's suffering translated into paragraphs of corporate correspondence.
Instead, she remained seated.
"What happened after she refused?"
Rebecca turned another page.
"The records show that the proposed investment was abandoned in its disputed form. Your mother's objections contributed to that outcome."
Chairman Liang looked at Camille.
"She protected us."
Camille's eyes filled.
"She paid for it."
The room became silent.
Liang lowered his head.
"Yes."
Camille looked toward the documents.
For twenty years, her mother had been described as a difficult consultant who interfered with negotiations.
Now the records showed that she had raised substantive concerns.
And those concerns had been serious enough to require major revisions.
Camille took a slow breath.
"What about Harbor Point?"
Mei opened another folder.
"The current review has identified contractual inconsistencies and weaknesses in how community commitments were incorporated into the project's financial structure."
Camille leaned forward.
"Which ones?"
Chen displayed the relevant provisions.
The project documents described support for displaced residents.
But several commitments were conditional on later commercial decisions.
The public presentation did not always communicate those limitations clearly.
Camille studied the text.
"There."
She pointed to a paragraph.
"The assistance program can be modified if the development phases are restructured."
Chen nodded.
"Yes."
"And there is no clear mechanism ensuring affected tenants receive comparable support if that happens."
"Correct."
Camille turned another page.
"The permanent employment estimate also depends on assumptions about the convention center and retail occupancy."
Mei nodded.
"Those assumptions haven't been adequately distinguished from confirmed commitments in the summary materials."
Camille leaned back.
She felt a mixture of relief and frustration.
Relief because the issues she identified were real.
Frustration because they could have been addressed earlier if the developers had listened.
Chairman Liang studied her.
"What do you recommend?"
Camille looked toward the window.
Then she answered.
"An independently monitored revision of the project. Clear relocation commitments. Separate reporting of temporary and permanent jobs. Better disclosure of financing risks. And meaningful participation by residents before final approval."
Mei nodded.
"Would you support the project if those changes were made?"
Camille considered the question.
"Possibly."
Liang raised an eyebrow.
"Not definitely?"
"No."
She looked directly at him.
"I don't think a project becomes good merely because we fix some bad paperwork."
A faint smile crossed his face.
"Go on."
"We need to determine whether the actual benefits justify the costs. Some people may still lose homes or businesses. They deserve more than a polished presentation."
Liang nodded slowly.
"Your mother would have approved of that answer."
Camille smiled sadly.
"I hope so."
The meeting continued for another hour.
By the end, the consortium had agreed to maintain its investment suspension pending completion of the relevant reviews and a revised proposal.
Camille gathered her notes.
As she rose, Rebecca touched her arm.
"There's something else we need to discuss privately."
Camille turned.
"What?"
Rebecca led her into a smaller office.
She closed the door.
Then she placed another document on the table.
"This came from Adrian Keller."
Camille's expression hardened.
"What does he want?"
"He has provided a written statement concerning his involvement in the Northstar dispute."
Camille stared.
"Why now?"
Rebecca looked at her carefully.
"According to his statement, he believes the historical record should be corrected."
Camille gave a humorless laugh.
"Twenty years later."
"Yes."
She sat down.
"What does it say?"
Rebecca opened the document.