Elias unfolded it.
IF COLE ASKS ABOUT THE OCTOBER AGREEMENT, TELL HIM HIS FATHER SIGNED IT WILLINGLY. DO NOT MENTION THE WITNESSES.
The message bore Silas Mercer's initials.
Elias stared at them.
"My father signed willingly," he said quietly.
Elena stood beside him.
"That does not mean he agreed to murder."
"No. But it means he was part of something."
"And now you must decide what to do with that knowledge."
He folded the telegram and placed it inside his coat.
"I know what I have to do."
For the first time that evening, Elena did not ask him to explain.
They left the telegraph office and walked toward the hotel to collect their horses.
Halfway across the street, Elias noticed a figure standing beneath the awning of the abandoned saloon.
The man stepped into the light.
It was Daniel Grey.
His face was grim, and his right sleeve was dark with blood.
"Daniel!" Elena hurried toward him.
He raised a hand.
"Don't come closer. There's something you need to hear."
Elias looked at the wound.
"Who did this?"
"Two men followed me from the southern trail. I lost one. The other is probably still watching."
"Where is the second man?"
Daniel glanced toward the rooftops.
"Close enough to hear us if we speak too loudly."
Elena's face tightened.
"What happened?"
Daniel looked at her, and for the first time since their reunion, the older man's expression broke.
"I found someone at the old crossing."
"Who?"
He swallowed.
"A man who says he knew your mother. A man who claims he can prove what happened to Mateo."
Elena went very still.
"Mateo is dead."
"Maybe," Daniel said. "But the man at the crossing says he saw him alive after the attack."
Elias looked from Daniel to Elena.
A new danger had entered their lives, one that had nothing to do with land deeds or stolen water.
Elena's hand moved to the turquoise pendant at her throat.
"Then we are going to find him."
They left Blackwater under a moon hidden behind clouds.
Daniel rode between Elias and Elena, his wounded arm bound tightly against his side. He had refused to remain in town, insisting that the man at the crossing would not wait until morning.
The trail descended through a narrow canyon where the wind carried the smell of wet stone. Somewhere below, the river moved over its rocky bed, whispering through the darkness.
Elias rode with his rifle across his saddle.
He had grown up in this country, yet the canyon seemed unfamiliar tonight. Every shadow looked occupied. Every broken branch suggested a watcher.
Elena rode ahead.
Her horse moved confidently over the uneven ground, and she seemed to know every bend in the trail. Elias watched her closely, remembering how she had arrived at Blackwater with a single satchel and a determination that had unsettled him.
He had thought she was a stranger bringing trouble into his home.
Now he understood that the trouble had been waiting for her long before she ever met him.
"How much farther?" he asked.
"Not far," Elena answered.
Daniel pointed toward a narrow opening between two boulders.
"The crossing lies beyond that."
They dismounted and led their horses down the final stretch. The river appeared beneath a pale strip of moonlight, its surface broken by stones and shallow pools.
A small fire burned on the opposite bank.
Beside it stood a man.
He was lean and gray-haired, dressed in an old brown coat. One hand rested on a walking stick. When Elena stepped into the open, he lifted his head.
"Elena Grey."
She stopped.
"Who are you?"
"My name is Samuel Whitmore."
Elias stepped forward.
For several seconds, neither man spoke.
Samuel was older than Elias remembered from his childhood visits to St. Louis. His hair had turned almost entirely white, and deep lines marked his face. But the eyes were the same—sharp, watchful, and troubled.
"You might have written," Elias said.
"I did."
"You might have told me the truth."
"I should have."
"Instead, you arranged my marriage to a woman whose mother was involved in my father's darkest secret."
Samuel looked at Elena.
"I did not arrange your marriage to punish either of you."
"Then why?"
"Because your father asked me to find a way to return what he had taken."
Elias's anger faltered.
"Thomas asked you?"
"Not directly. He wrote to me after the attack on Red Mesa. He confessed that he had signed the first agreement with Mercer. He believed he was securing the spring through a lawful settlement. He did not know Mercer intended to force the families away."