"That is not what the ledger says."
"No. The ledger records the business arrangement. It does not record what happened afterward."
Samuel motioned toward the fire.
"Come closer. I have brought the papers."
He opened a leather satchel and removed several folded documents.
The first was a copy of the original agreement between Thomas Cole and Silas Mercer.
The second contained a list of payments made to men who had participated in the attack.
The third was a statement written by Thomas himself.
Elias took it with unsteady hands.
I, Thomas Cole, state that the agreement concerning Red Mesa Spring was never completed by the consent of the families who lived there. Silas Mercer arranged for armed men to remove them by force. I arrived after the attack began. I attempted to stop it, but I failed to prevent the deaths that followed.
I helped Maria Grey escape because she was carrying evidence that Mercer had ordered the attack. I promised to testify against him. I did not keep that promise.
I have allowed fear to make me a coward. My son deserves to know that his father was not innocent.
The letter ended with Thomas's signature.
Elias lowered it.
He had spent years remembering his father as a stern but honorable man. The old man's boots had stood beside the door every evening. His voice had carried across the ranch yard. He had taught Elias to mend fences, break horses, and never turn his back on a friend.
But he had also remained silent.
He had known a woman was dead. He had known families had been driven from their homes. He had known Silas Mercer had built his fortune on stolen land.
And he had done nothing.
"Why didn't you bring this to me sooner?" Elias asked.
Samuel's face tightened.
"Because I was afraid Mercer would kill you before you were old enough to understand what you were defending. Then your father died, and I convinced myself that silence was the safer choice."
"You had no right to decide that for me."
"No," Samuel said. "I did not."
Elena took the papers from Elias and examined the signatures.
"Where is the original testimony?"
Samuel reached into his satchel again.
"That is what I came to show you."
He unfolded a document bearing several names. At the bottom was a statement written in a different hand.
Elena recognized it immediately.
"My mother's handwriting."
She leaned closer.
The document described the attack from Maria's perspective. It named the men who had entered the camp, recorded the time the first shots were fired, and identified Silas Mercer as the man who had given the order.
But the final lines held Elena's attention.
Mateo Grey was taken alive. He was wounded, but he was breathing when they carried him toward the southern road. I begged Thomas Cole to help him. Thomas said he would return with men who could bring the boy back.
Elena read the words again.
"Mateo was alive."
Daniel's face changed.
"Your mother told me he was missing. She never said he had been taken."
"Perhaps she did not know where he had gone," Samuel said.
Elena looked at him.
"Do you know what happened to him?"
Samuel hesitated.
"After the attack, Mercer sent several prisoners south. Some were taken to a work camp near the old mining road. I have reason to believe Mateo was among them."
"Is the camp still there?"
"No. It closed years ago."
"Then where did they go?"
Samuel looked toward Elias.
"That is why I need your help. There is another document, one Mercer has kept hidden. It contains the names of the men who transported the prisoners. One of those men is still alive."
"Who?"
"Jonah Pike."
A sudden rustle came from the rocks behind them.
Elias turned, rifle rising.
"Show yourself!"
A gunshot shattered the night.
Samuel staggered backward. His hand flew to his shoulder, and he fell beside the fire.
Daniel drew his revolver.
Elena dropped beside Samuel, pressing her hands against the wound.
"Stay with us!"
Elias fired toward the rocks. A figure moved between the boulders, then vanished into the canyon.
Another shot struck the ground near Daniel's horse.
"Get down!" Elias shouted.
Daniel dragged Samuel behind a large stone while Elena kept pressure on the wound.
The gunman fired again.
Elias moved toward the riverbank, using the boulders for cover. He caught sight of a man crouching behind a juniper bush.