The Billionaire’s Bride Pushed His Mother Off the Rooftop

Chapter 28

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I allow it generally," Petra said. "I do not allow it in this."

"And why not, Mrs. Vogel?"

"Because I have a practice," she said, "of not recording what I am not certain of, and of recording that I am not certain when I am not. The detective has my statement. In it I recorded that I did not hear the last words the bride spoke before it happened. I did not hear them, so they are not there. What is there, I heard." The attorney made a note. "If I were a person who filled gaps, that gap would be filled. You may judge the rest by it."

They were interested, most of all, in the logbook. Its existence had surfaced through the office copies — the monthly summaries Petra had typed for nineteen years and sent down to the flagship's office, which the defense had obtained and read with the dawning recognition that the household had been documented like a ship. They asked whether the books themselves could be produced. They asked whether entries had ever been altered, supplemented, rewritten after the fact — and Petra, who had expected the question and had brought, at Anand's suggestion, nothing but her answers, said that the books were written daily, in ink, in sequence, that corrections were made by a single line through the error with the truth beside it and the date of the correction noted, and that any examiner the court appointed was welcome to the chemistry of the inks, which would be found to agree with the dates on the pages. She said it without pride, the way she would have described the ironing. Anand, seated behind her as the household's counsel — present by her own wish, in the new dispensation her counter-terms had made, and silent by her instruction unless the law required otherwise — said nothing for six hours, and on the way down in the lift observed that he had attended depositions for thirty years and had never before watched a witness treat the other side's counsel as a problem in record-keeping.

"You were not a witness, Mrs. Vogel," he said. "You were an audit."

The bride's own deposition, which Clara read in transcript because the foundation's counsel received the file's courtesies, ran to two days and did not waver: a slip, a turn, a heel; shock; a conversation in a corridor that had been about gratitude and had been twisted; a telephone call that had been about the witness's welfare and had been recorded without her knowledge by people acting for the family that had ruined hers. Her attorneys' theory assembled itself in the filings like weather: the chair had been about to destroy the Cranes on the word of an accountant; the bride had gone up to plead; the old woman, agitated, had turned too quickly at the rail; the housekeeper, ambitious or terrified or dazzled by her own heroism — the filings rotated the motive like a gem in tweezers — had built a push out of a fall, and the family, needing a villain who was not its own matriarch's judgment, had closed ranks around her story. It was, Petra thought, reading none of it (Clara reported the shape of it in the kitchen, standing in the service doorway, with her arms folded and her fury tidy), a well-built account. It had everything except a document. It had a heel and a turn and a dusk and a distance, and it required, at every joint, that the paper be lying: the log with three keycards; the film with ninety seconds; the tape with the money; the statement signed before midnight in an unshaken hand. Paper, Petra had believed since she was twenty-eight years old and newly widowed in a strange city's kitchen, does not lie. It can be made to say false things by the people who write it. But it cannot be made to forget who wrote it, or when, or in what order — and the order, that winter, was assembling itself in a prosecutor's file room into the shape of a staircase, each step dated, each step signed, going up thirty floors to a terrace door that opened at seven and closed at the end of ninety seconds.

News in the same category

The Billionaire’s Bride Pushed His Mother Off the Rooftop

45 Part