That evening Gideon went to Fenna's street. A man named Abel Pryn managed the local delivery roster from a room behind a chandlery. Abel had served Gideon's father and addressed Gideon as chief before the visitor could stop him. The old title came out with the easy warmth of habit. Gideon explained that the council had changed the household rule. Abel listened, nodded and asked whether the girl should make up her two missed Saturdays when she turned sixteen.
“No,” Gideon said. “Nothing is owed.”
Abel's smile changed. “But the household received help.”
“The help was given under arrangements that should never have passed a debt to a child.”
“My own father worked every winter.”
“I know.”
“I did too. It's how the place kept going.”
“That is not a reason to demand it of Fenna.”
The argument went back and forth until Gideon understood what Abel was protecting. It was not only a roster or the useful hours of a pair of young hands. It was the meaning of his own childhood labor. If the inherited obligation had been wrong, then a part of the pride with which Abel remembered his father might have been misplaced. Gideon did not know how to repair that loss, and refused the easy remedy of pretending no loss existed.
“You were useful,” he said. “You worked hard. Both can be true without making the rule right.”
Abel looked toward the warehouse door, where evening light outlined the iron hooks used for ropes. “And if everyone refuses?”
“Then we pay for the work or find a way to do less of it.”
“You have money for that?”
“Not as much as I would like.”
Abel gave a reluctant laugh. “At last a chief who can count.”
“I'm not the chief.”
“I heard.”
Gideon took a copy of the revised roster and crossed out Fenna's name while Abel watched. It was a small act, not a complete liberation; the first few Saturdays would still be filled by those who had learned to volunteer before anyone asked. But when he knocked at Fenna's door, the girl and her grandmother listened to him explain the change. Her grandmother asked him twice whether the family would be punished. He said no twice, and left his contact address with them rather than treating his own assurance as enough.
On the return walk, he passed the old schoolhouse and remembered the ceremony at which he and Mara had made their promise to one another. Their father had taken him aside before the council dinner and said that the head of a family must never confess uncertainty where others could hear. Gideon had accepted the instruction because a fourteen-year-old wanted, more than anything, to know how adulthood was performed. Mara, five years younger, had spent the evening helping carry plates. Later, when everyone had gone, she asked why the children of the porters had been told to wait outside until their parents' duties were done. Gideon had answered that it was custom, and she had asked who had made the custom. He had no answer, so he told her that when they were in charge they would change it.
He had been earnest. That was what made the memory difficult. He had not lied to her then. He had believed there would be a clean moment at which justice could be done without making anyone angry, a moment after the current dispute, the current debts, the current emergency. Each time he attained a little more authority, the appropriate moment moved farther away. Now Mara had ended his command by asking him to do what he had once promised her he would do gladly. His shame was not that power had changed his values completely. It was that he had learned to speak the values fluently while arranging never to pay their cost.
In the first council session under the new rules, Tamsin asked each captain to describe what had been promised to households in his or her territory. They met in the waiting lounge because the smaller table made it harder for anyone to hide behind the distance between chair and doorway. Dorian's ledger lay in the middle, tied with a piece of red cord. A separate notebook, bought for a few coins from the stationery shop, was open beside it. Tamsin had insisted on fresh paper for new decisions. Gideon suspected the gesture was theatrical until he watched her turn back pages in the old ledger. Its entries were written in the language of favours, exceptions, trusted men and arrangements. Names appeared without dates; dates without signatures; sums without reasons. Every ambiguity had been survivable while someone with personal authority could announce what it meant. The new council had to find meanings that would remain stable when the person with the loudest voice left the room.
Captain Silas Norr from the northern landing reported thirty-one households with inherited duties and eleven receiving assistance. Captain Jo Renn of the eastern shore reported fewer formal obligations but an informal practice of sending adolescents to help during festival weeks. Captain Bel Kestrel, who represented the warehouses, said that her territory had accumulated three kinds of service in exchange for medical help, emergency loans and warehouse work. She had tried to separate them on paper and found herself unable to tell whether a gift had become a loan merely because the recipient had later offered labor.