While the association prepared for its next election, a dispute over fishing access drew people back to the terminal for reasons none of the reformers had anticipated. The western inlet had long been used by small boats whose owners paid little more than a maintenance contribution to the old Family. The arrangement had never been written down with much precision. In practice, a handful of retired captains decided who could moor there, often favoring households with long ties to Rookhaven. After the governance separation, the property trustees inherited a landing whose actual boundaries were unclear and whose right of access appeared in several conflicting documents.
The problem surfaced when a young fisherman named Malik Rowan requested permission to use a vacant berth. His family had moved to Rookhaven only five years earlier. He owned a small repaired boat and had begun selling his catch to local restaurants, but he lacked the capital for a berth at the commercial marina. The inlet appeared to have space, and the posted rules listed an ordinary monthly fee. The harbor manager nevertheless refused him, saying the berths were reserved for established families. Malik asked which written policy established the reservation. The manager pointed to a ledger from Gideon's administration and told him the custom had always been understood. Malik filed an appeal.
At the hearing, the manager explained that the inlet's shallow water and narrow turning area could not safely accommodate an unlimited number of boats. He had used the old family register to prioritize those who knew the harbor. Malik agreed that safety mattered but asked whether ancestry was a reliable measure of seamanship. He produced his training certificates and a survey of his boat. Several older fishermen responded angrily, accusing him of treating a communal resource as though it were a public parking lot. They had maintained the moorings for decades and feared losing access to people who had not contributed to the work.
The trustees asked Nell Harrow to inspect the landing and advise on capacity. Her report found that some existing berths were unsafe and that the turning area could accommodate fewer boats than the manager had assumed. The true problem was not one young fisherman's request but an allocation system that had never confronted scarcity openly. Several current users paid no fee at all under inherited arrangements. Others maintained parts of the landing themselves. The property body had to decide whether to formalize the use of the berths, charge transparent fees and provide exemptions without rewarding people solely because their grandparents had been known to Gideon's father.
Mara attended a consultation at Malik's invitation. She remembered the first notices asking households what they could now refuse, and wondered whether reform had done enough to explain what people could now request. Malik did not want a personal favor. He wanted fair consideration under a rule that applied to everyone. He had brought photographs of his boat, repair invoices and a map of the inlet. When Mara asked what he feared most, he said that he would be told the rules were open while an unwritten tradition continued to decide the outcome. She recognized the danger immediately. The formal end of inherited allegiance did not erase inherited access to valuable things.
Gideon attended a separate meeting with older boat owners. They spoke of winter storms and years spent replacing ropes, boards and damaged mooring posts. Many regarded the inlet as something they had kept alive through labor rather than property granted by a chief. Gideon agreed that contributions mattered. He asked whether they believed a person who was willing to contribute now should be excluded because his parents had not done so. The room grew uncomfortable. A man named Errol Thane said new arrivals would take the best spaces and leave when the work became unpleasant. Gideon suggested that maintenance duties be written as part of an ordinary berth agreement and compensated or credited transparently, rather than assumed from family identity. Errol called the idea an accountant's solution to a sailor's problem.
Thomas Veer, who had come to the meeting out of curiosity, answered that sailors had always needed accounts of tides, fuel and maintenance. The question was whether those accounts could be read by the people expected to live with their consequences. He described a winter when a repair fund had been exhausted because someone believed a respected old captain's promise without checking the price. The memory softened the room. Several boat owners agreed to join a working group if current safety risks were addressed first.
The trustees issued temporary rules preserving existing access while unsafe berths were inspected, with new applications placed on a public waiting list. Malik was disappointed. He had hoped that fair procedure would produce a quick berth. Mara told him that fairness could not manufacture space where none existed. He answered that he knew, but had expected the system to reveal sooner how much space was truly available. The criticism was justified. The old register had concealed both the physical limits and the privileges attached to the landing. The new rules could be better without being immediately generous to everyone.