The Card Catalogue An Original Novel

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

At two o'clock the moderator called Article 14, and Franklin Doyle rose from his seat near the front, and the room rearranged itself the way rooms do when a man with a plan stands up.

Connie watched him settle his papers. She had known Franklin Doyle since he was the boy who had returned a library book three months late and wept when she forgave the fine β€” he had been fourteen, and the book had been a manual of small-engine repair, and she had never forgotten either fact, because a librarian does not forget what a child is ashamed of. He was fifty-five now, chairman of the board of selectmen, owner of Doyle Motors, and he had modernized everything he had touched, and he could not understand why the town would not modernize itself at his pace. He was not unkind. That was the difficult part. He was not unkind; he was in a hurry. And somewhere over the winter, in a hurry, he had decided the library was the past.

In the back row, his daughter Margaret sat very still. Margaret Doyle was twenty-six, a third-grade teacher at the Corners elementary school, and Connie had taught her her letters at story hour on Saturday mornings twenty years ago, the way she had taught half the town's children their letters on Saturday mornings. Margaret had her father's straight back and her own quiet eyes. She was not looking at her father. She was looking at Connie.

The moderator read the article aloud in the formal voice of small-town ritual: "Article 14. To see if the town will vote to discontinue the Ames Free Library effective July 1, 1975, and authorize the board of selectmen to sell the library building and lot to Granite State Bank for the sum of forty thousand dollars." The secretary's pencil scratched. Someone in the middle rows coughed. Connie folded her hands in her lap and sat very still, and she thought, with the clear cold calm that forty-one years of opening doors at nine had taught her: whatever happens in this room, the library opens at nine tomorrow. That much was hers, and no vote could take it from her β€” not tomorrow, anyway.

Franklin Doyle laid out his case the way he laid out everything: plainly, in order, as if the numbers had already decided and the town were only there to be informed. The library cost $18,400 a year, he said, and he put the figure on the blackboard in chalk, and most of it was one salary and coal. The building and lot were worth $40,000 to Granite State Bank, cash in hand, for a branch and parking β€” he put that figure under the first one, and drew a line, and the line said what he did not say. The bank would keep the facade. The books could go to the school, which had a library of its own. The future, he said, had come to the corner of every living room β€” the television, he meant β€” and the future did not need a building full of books.

Connie sat with her hands folded and listened the way she listened to everything in a meeting, which was completely. She had a rule about meetings, as she had a rule about everything: you did not speak until you had heard, and you did not hear until the other person had finished. It was a rule that had served her for forty-one years, and it served her now, though it cost her something she had not expected to pay, which was the sound of her own life being described, accurately, as an expense.

People spoke. Dr. Weiss spoke, briefly, about the journals β€” the medical journals, which the library received on standing order, which three generations of nervous patients had been told to "ask Mrs. Hale for something calming" about, though he did not put it that way in the meeting; he put it as professional necessity, which it also was. A man in the middle rows asked whether the school library could truly absorb the collection, and the principal said yes with a promptness that suggested he had been asked to be ready, and a murmur went through the rows at that, because the town knew a rehearsed answer when it heard one. A mill worker Connie knew only as one of the Kowalski boys stood up and said the bank would pay taxes where the library paid none, and sat down to a few nods, and Connie noted, with the part of her mind that never stopped being the librarian, that nobody in the room had asked what $40,000 bought a town that had already decided it could not afford $18,400.

George Atkins asked about the coal contract, which made everyone else check their watches, and which Connie noted was the kind of question that filled time without moving it β€” though she was fond of George Atkins, in the way she was fond of everyone she had watched grow up, and she knew his mother had received books from the library's book cart for twenty years, housebound, and she wondered, briefly, whether George had ever connected the cart to the budget line. Probably not. Men like George connected things slowly, and then all at once, and she had a feeling β€” nothing more than a feeling, which she filed away β€” that the spring would do the connecting for him.

Then Margaret Doyle stood up in the back row.

She was twenty-six years old, and she stood the way her father stood, straight-backed, and she said, very quietly, so that the room had to go silent to hear her: "I learned my letters at Mrs. Hale's story hour." And she sat down. Her father did not look at her. Connie looked at the back of Franklin's neck, which had gone red above his collar, and for one moment β€” one unguarded, unhurried moment β€” Franklin Doyle did nothing. He stood with his papers in his hands, and he looked at the floor, and the whole gymnasium watched a man decide, in front of everyone, whether his daughter's sentence would change his. Then he lifted his head, and the moment closed, and he went on with his closing, because a man in a hurry needs a sentence that ends things, and he had plainly decided in advance what his would be. But Connie had seen the pause, and she kept it, the way she kept everything, filed in order, where it belonged. A pause was not a change. But it was a record that a change had once been possible, and Connie had learned, in forty-one years of keeping records, that such things mattered more than people thought.

He turned, not to the moderator but to the third row, and he looked directly at Constance Hale, and he said it into the record, so that the secretary wrote it down and the Gazette would print it without comment the following week:

"Mrs. Hale, this town cannot afford to keep a museum β€” or its curator."

The gymnasium went very quiet. Connie sat with her hands folded in her lap, and she said nothing. She had a method for insults, as she had a method for everything: she said nothing in the moment, and the library opened at nine the next morning, as always. Adele Fournier's hand tightened on hers β€” Adele, who had lost her son in Vietnam and whose letters Connie had read aloud at the back table, because Adele's eyes and her English both failed her at the sentences that mattered. In the back row, Tom Reilly looked at the floor. He was forty, a mill worker, a big quiet man, and Connie had known him since story hour, and she watched him look at the floor, and she filed the observation away with all the other observations she never voiced.

Franklin sat down. The moderator called the question.

The vote, when it came, was long in the taking. It was a paper ballot, because someone had demanded it β€” Connie never learned who, though she suspected Dr. Weiss, who understood that a secret ballot let a town vote its conscience instead of its neighbors β€” and the tellers moved down the rows with their boxes, and the town voted the way towns vote, one by one, with their heads down. The gymnasium was very quiet except for the scratch of pencils and the creak of the bleachers. Connie voted to keep the library, because she had promised herself in 1934 that she would always vote for the town to keep doing what it had promised to do, and then she folded her ballot, and she dropped it in the box, and she sat with her hands folded and waited.

The counting took twenty minutes. The tellers worked at the table by the stage, and the town watched, and nobody left, because leaving would have meant admitting it mattered, and staying meant the same thing. Connie watched Franklin Doyle watch the tellers. She watched Margaret Doyle, in the back row, with her hands in her lap. She watched Tom Reilly, who had come in his mill jacket straight from his shift, staring at his own folded ballot as if it might still change its mind. And she thought about how a town was not a place, not really β€” a town was a set of promises, renewed or broken, one article at a time, on the first Tuesday in March.

News in the same category

The Card Catalogue An Original Novel

30 Part