The Card Catalogue An Original Novel

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He still hadn't told Sharon. He would have to. He knew he would have to. The petition was at two hundred signatures and climbing, and the meeting would come, and when it came he would stand up, and a man couldn't stand up in front of his town and tell the truth about himself without first telling it at his own kitchen table. He knew that the way he knew the weight of his own hands.

Spring came on in New Hampshire the way it always did: grudgingly, then all at once. The mill yard turned to mud. The river ran high and brown. The library on Library Street opened at nine every morning, and Connie Hale was behind the desk, and the catalogue stood in its oak case with its brass rods, and Tom Reilly drove past it every day on his way to the mill and did not go in, because he was not ready, because the words were still stacked, because the door was still shut β€” but it was no longer locked, and he knew it, and the knowing sat in his chest now not like a stone but like something with wings, beating to get out.

Franklin Doyle had not set out to be the man who closed the library. He had set out, twenty years earlier, to be the man who modernized Hallowell Corners, and in his mind the two projects were the same project, and the fact that other people couldn't see that was one of the town's many small failures of vision that he had learned to work around.

Doyle Motors sat on Route 3 at the south end of town, a low brick building with a plate-glass showroom and a lot full of new models with the sticker prices in the windshields, and Franklin had built it from a two-bay garage his father left him into the largest dealership in the county. He was fifty-five, broad and ruddy, with a salesman's handshake and a selectman's gravity, and he chaired the board of selectmen the way he ran his business: briskly, confidently, and with a genuine belief that most problems were inventory problems β€” you cleared out the old stock to make room for what sold.

The library, in this accounting, was old stock. Eighteen thousand four hundred dollars a year for a building that sat half-empty, a coal furnace, and a woman of seventy-four who had been stamping books since before he was born. The bank's offer β€” forty thousand for the building and lot, cash, a branch and parking where a relic stood β€” was, to Franklin, the kind of number that ended arguments. He had made the motion at town meeting with the clean conscience of a man doing arithmetic in public.

The bank's man was named Richard Hale β€” no relation, he always said, to the librarian, though the coincidence had caused Franklin a moment's discomfort he had filed away. Richard Hale was thirty-eight, from Concord, with a briefcase and a suit that fit too well for Hallowell Corners, and he had come to Doyle Motors in April to talk about the branch. They sat in Franklin's office with the lot visible through the window, and Hale laid out the timeline: the option on the property ran through June, the bank's board needed the town's commitment by midsummer, the demolition could start in August, the branch could open by Christmas. He spoke of foot traffic and assessed value and progress, and Franklin nodded along, and it was all going exactly as planned, and then Hale said, "The librarian β€” Mrs. Hale. She's no relation, but I understand she's been there since β€” "

"Since 1934," Franklin said.

"And she'll β€” the town will take care of her?"

"She's seventy-four. She'll retire." Franklin said it with the briskness of a man closing a file. "It's all been considered."

Hale nodded, satisfied, and Franklin was satisfied too, and the meeting ended with a handshake, and Franklin stood at his office window afterward watching his lot and thinking about the way things got done: you identified the future, you priced the past, and you moved.

The following week Hale brought the bank's architect, and the two of them stood on the library lawn with a rolled set of drawings while Franklin watched from his car across the street β€” he had not told Hale he would come, and he was not sure why he had. The architect gestured at the building with his rolled drawings the way a man gestures at a stump that needs pulling, and Hale laughed at something, and Franklin felt an odd, small tug, like a fishline catching on a rock. He had been inside that building exactly once in his adult life, to get his daughter a library card when she was six. He remembered the smell of it β€” coal and paper β€” and the way the librarian had looked at him over her glasses, and he had not thought about it since.

At the dealership the petition was becoming a nuisance in the most literal sense: Becky Lawson's card table had acquired a satellite, and one of his own salesmen β€” young Pete Ducharme, who owed Franklin for the job β€” came to him sheepish and said his mother had made him sign, and what should he tell people, and Franklin said, "Tell them the town voted," with more heat than the question deserved. Pete backed out of the office. Franklin sat at his desk and looked at the March sales figures, which were good, and thought about forty-one votes, and about the way the meeting had gone quiet after his sentence, and he told himself the quiet had been agreement.

What he had not priced was his own daughter.

Sunday dinner at the Doyle house was a standing institution: roast, potatoes, Franklin at the head of the table, his wife Carol to his right, Margaret across from him, the good dishes because Carol insisted. Margaret was twenty-six, teaching third grade at the elementary school, living in the apartment over the hardware store, engaged to a young man from Keene who worked for the telephone company. She had her father's directness and her mother's tact, and she had, all spring, been saying less than usual at these dinners, which Franklin had noticed the way you notice a draft β€” vaguely, and with the assumption that someone else would deal with it.

This Sunday, in the second week of April, the draft became a wind.

It started with Carol mentioning the petition β€” "Becky Lawson was at the IGA again, Franklin, she must have two hundred names by now" β€” and Franklin saying, "It's a waste of everybody's time, the town voted," and Margaret putting down her fork.

"The town voted by forty-one votes, Dad."

"Forty-one votes is a vote."

"It's a vote that said we can't afford a museum." She looked at him levelly. "That's what you said. 'This town cannot afford to keep a museum β€” or its curator.'"

Franklin felt the sentence come back at him across his own dinner table and land. He had said it in the school gym, into a microphone, in open meeting. The *Gazette* had printed it. He had been rather proud of the phrasing at the time β€” it had the ring of something quotable, something a man says when he is winning an argument. Hearing it now, in his daughter's voice, in his dining room, it had a different ring entirely.

"I was making a point about the budget," he said.

"You were making a point about Mrs. Hale."

"Margaret β€” "

"I learned my letters at her story hour, Dad." Margaret said it the way she said everything: plainly, without raising her voice, which made it worse. "I was four years old. She sat me on a little chair and she read to us, and then she taught us the alphabet with the big cards, and I can still see her hands holding them up. Half my class learned to read in that room. You want to close it and sell it to a bank, and that's a budget decision, and I understand budgets. But don't pretend it's only a budget decision. You stood up in front of the whole town and called a seventy-four-year-old woman a curator of a museum, as if that were an insult, as if forty-one years of teaching this town's children to read were something to be embarrassed about."

The silence at the table was complete. Carol looked at her plate. Franklin looked at his daughter, and what he felt was not what he would have expected. He had expected to feel attacked. What he felt, underneath the attack, was a small cold draft of something he didn't want to name. He named it anyway, to himself, because Franklin Doyle was an honest man in his own accounting: it was shame. Not for the budget. Not for the bank. For the sentence. For the pleasure he had taken in the phrasing.

"You're being unfair," he said, but the briskness wouldn't come.

"Am I?" Margaret picked up her fork again. "Then tell me what you meant by it."

He couldn't. That was the trouble. He had meant it as rhetoric, and rhetoric, repeated back to you by your own child at your own table, turns out to have been the thing itself all along.

News in the same category

The Card Catalogue An Original Novel

30 Part