should. A freighter who hauled through Bear Creek in the first snow brought
it as an item among items, between the price of salt and the state of the road:
Whitlock had resigned the delegate seat before the assembly could take it
from him, which the freighter called smart and Amos called arithmetic. The
company was under investigation — the 1869 papers, referred to the attorney
general, were now being read in the government's own house. The book, the
grand history that was to have made the man immortal, had been
remaindered; the freighter had seen a crate of them in a storehouse in Las
Cruces, sold by the pound for wrapping. Amos received all of this without
comment. The man had tried to write the record in other people's blood and
had ended as a footnote in the record he tried to write — reduced, filed, and
superseded, which is the precise fate the record keeps for those who falsify it.
It was enough. Amos was done with Whitlock the way a man is done with
weather that has passed: he noted the damage, and he did not write letters to
the sky.
The council made its offer on the last evening. The guest lodge at the creek
side of the camp was Amos's for the winter if he wanted it — not as charity
and not as payment, Kito said, but as an entry in the record: the friend in the
story should not have to hear the story secondhand from freighters. There
would be meat, and a place at the fires, and, Sela added in the tone of a
woman closing an argument, somebody to notice within the day if the old
man took sick, which was more than a cabin up Bear Creek was prepared to
111
offer.
He declined it, standing, because some things a man says on his feet, and he
said it plain. He had a cabin. He had cattle fattening on creek pasture that the
band's herders had kept for him, and that he was obliged for. And he had a
door up there that he had left standing open when he rode out in the autumn
— left open on purpose, in the worst of it, as a sign to himself about the kind
of man he intended to come back as, if he came back. He said he was still
learning the use of that door. He said a man should live in the house his life
made, and his life had made that one, with the mantel and the peg and the
creek below it. And he said — this last without looking at any of them in
particular — that a guest who stayed past the welcome became a relative, and
he had seen what this band did for its relatives, and he could not afford the
mending.
Kito inclined his head and let it stand, the way the band let true things stand.
Sela said he would be hungry by the second week and would send no word,
out of pride, and that the band would send meat anyway, out of the opposite,
and that this was not an argument but a forecast. Amos said he had no doubt
of it. And that was the refusal, gentle on both sides: a door held open
between the valley and the cabin.
They rode with him to the fork where the Bear Creek trail leaves the valley's
road, because that is where a parting belongs — not at a lodge door, with the
host watching the guest out of sight like a debt being collected, but at a
turning in the country, where each party's road is visible to the other. Kito
rode, and Sela, and Tasun — which Amos had not expected; the old
story-keeper had not been on a horse for any distance since the summer, and
he rode the whole way upright and unhurried, his face arranged to forbid
comment on the subject of his comfort. Yano did not ride. Yano stood at the
112
last lodge and raised one hand, once, at the distance — the whole of that
man's ceremonial vocabulary, and worth more for its scarcity than a volume
of the other kind.
At the fork they dismounted, all four, in the late light, and Sela took the
stones from the bag at her belt.
They were white, the two of them — river stones from the creek below
White Mesa, alike as two hands, worn smooth by the water. Nahlin had kept
one half of the parley for twelve years in the ground of his authority, and his
people had kept the keeping of it. Amos's half had been the telling. In Santa
Fe Sela had put both stones into his hands for the carrying home — an
errand, then — and he had understood, riding down the capital road with
them knocking softly together in his saddlebag, that an errand is not the end
of a parley's meaning. Now she took them from him, held them a moment in
her own two hands, and gave them back one at a time, the way a thing is
given when the giving is the message.
"Take them both," she said. "A parley is two stones, Amos. He kept his half
twelve years in the ground. You keep both now, and remember for us —
Tasun is old, and a record with two keepers is a record that survives." She
closed his fingers over the second stone with her own hand, brief and