see and a man on a ridge cannot. Through the smoke hanging over White
Mesa it came up muffled and unhurried, volley after volley, and then, after a
while, it stopped being volleys and became single shots, spaced, almost
leisurely. Amos stood between two troopers with his hands chained and
heard all of it, every round, and said nothing, and has heard it every year
since — in October, mostly, when the cottonwoods turn, but sometimes in
the spring too, at dawn, when the light is the same.
There was no court-martial. Whitlock was too good a soldier for that, in his
way: a court writes things down, and courts ask questions in a room with a
clerk, and the questions would have started with a parley and a stone and
ended with a colonel's word, and the colonel's word was going to be worth
railroads someday. So there was a paper instead. A resignation, accepted. A
dismissal dressed in the clothes of an honorable discharge, a month's pay, a
signature — his own, which the orderly put in front of him with the pen
already inked — and the colonel's advice, given in that pleasant parade
voice, to go far and keep his version to himself, since the official one was
already being drafted and would say that the scout had been confined for
insubordination bordering on drink, and that the attack had been a necessity
12
of war, and would not say anything at all about a stone.
Amos went. He has never defended himself — not to Barlow, not to the
agency clerk who asked him once, straight out, in '74, not to himself at three
in the morning, which is the only court whose verdict he would have valued.
A defense is a thing a man makes to people who can give him something
back. The dead cannot give anything back. And the arithmetic under the
night was his and he knew it: he had carried the camp's location out of that
valley in his own hand, in his own report, up the eleven miles and onto the
colonel's desk. Without his report, Whitlock's column would have groped the
whole cordillera for a month and found cold ashes. With it, they had formed
in the dark on ground they had never seen, and fired at dawn into a camp that
was sitting still because Amos Decker had told it to sit still. The fire he had
set with such prayer and horsemanship had been too late, or too early, or the
wind had pressed the smoke down and blinded the very people it meant to
warn — he has never known which, and the not-knowing is not a comfort. It
is the opposite of a comfort. It is the hole in the middle of the twelve years.
Someone else had guided the column in. That much he has always known. A
column does not find a hidden valley in the dark and deploy at dawn on
ground it has never walked without a guide who knows the trails — and
Amos was in the guardhouse. He has his suspicion about whose hand was on
the bridle that night: Obie Lark, the post's civilian contractor, a smiler who
dealt in mules and beef and information at the same markup, had been a poor
man in September of '69 and a comfortable one by Christmas, flush with
Consolidated Copper scrip and quick to spend it, and gone from the post's
employ within the month for a contracting job with — Amos has always
noted the embroidery of it — with Whitlock's own mining company, two
years before the company properly existed on paper. But suspicion is not
13
proof, and proof, if he had it, would not acquit him. Lark may have held the
bridle. The map had still come out of the valley in Amos Decker's dispatch
case, under Amos Decker's white stone. For twelve years he has let the
territory believe whatever it believed. He bought the Bear Creek ground with
his savings, and built the cabin, and put the stone on the mantel where the
lamp light found it at supper, and waited — though if you had asked him
what he was waiting for, he would have had to think, and the thinking would
have surprised him with its answer: he was waiting to be found.
It came at dusk, two days after the ride, and it came the way Amos had
always known it would come if it came at all — not with a rush or a shot, but
with a silence arriving ahead of it, like weather walking in front of a storm.
He was coming up from the creek with two buckets when he felt it first in the
small of his back, and then he heard what he was feeling: nothing. The
canyon wrens that scolded him every evening from the corral fence were
gone quiet. The jays were gone quiet. The creek, which had run at the same
voice for twelve years, sounded suddenly loud, the way a voice is loud in a
room where everyone else has stopped talking. He set the buckets down full
in the yard, slowly, not spilling, and stood still, and let the old instruments
take their readings. In the corral his mare had come to the rail with her ears
up and working like signal flags, facing north, facing the ridge. She was not
afraid. That told him as much as fear would have. Whatever was out there