Clara gathered fallen branches while Elias examined the journal.
The leather cover had become brittle with age. Several pages were damaged, but the writing remained legible.
Most of the entries concerned shipments.
Dates.
Names.
Amounts of money.
Descriptions of wagons.
Some entries referred to military supplies. Others mentioned livestock purchases and payments to men working for the territorial government.
Then Elias found a name he recognized.
Thomas Bennett.
Beside it was a date from twelve years earlier.
Bennett has the original transfer records. Must arrange safe passage before Vale discovers the duplication.
Elias read the sentence twice.
"Clara."
She looked up.
"What?"
He showed her the entry.
Her face went pale.
"Thomas had the records?"
"Apparently."
"He never told me."
"Perhaps he didn't want you involved."
Clara stared at the journal.
"Then he must have hidden them somewhere."
"That's what I think."
She sat beside the fire.
For a long moment, she watched the flames.
Then she spoke quietly.
"My brother used to say that men like Vale never thought of themselves as villains."
Elias turned a page.
"What did he think they were?"
"Necessary."
She looked into the fire.
"Thomas said that was the most dangerous kind of man. Someone who could do terrible things and still sleep peacefully because he believed the world needed him."
Elias closed the journal.
"Your brother was right."
Clara looked at him.
"Is that why you left the army?"
Elias was surprised.
"Who told you I served?"
"You carry yourself like a soldier."
"That isn't an answer."
"No," she said. "It isn't."
He considered telling her.
Instead, he placed another branch on the fire.
"I served for three years."
"Where?"
"New Mexico. Arizona. A little farther south."
"Why leave?"
"Because I stopped believing the orders I was given."
Clara studied him.
"Did someone die?"
Elias looked into the flames.
"Yes."
He did not elaborate.
He remembered a young private named Daniel Foster, nineteen years old, who had joined the cavalry because his family needed the money.
Foster had been kind, nervous, and constantly hungry.
During a patrol near the border, an officer had ordered the unit to fire on a group of riders approaching a supply wagon.
The riders had been unarmed.
Two were women.
One was a boy.
Foster had hesitated.
The officer had ordered him to fire.
He had refused.
A second later, the officer shot him.
Elias had spent the next three years remembering the sound of the boy crying beside the road.
He had resigned his commission shortly afterward.
He had never told anyone the whole story.
Clara seemed to sense that there was more beneath his words.
She did not press him.
Instead, she asked, "Do you think people can change?"
Elias looked at her.
"Some."
"Even men like Vale?"
"I don't know."
She watched the fire.
"I used to think my brother could fix anything. He could talk to anyone, settle arguments, make people listen."
"And now?"
"Now I think some men only understand what they want to understand."
Elias nodded.
The fire crackled between them.
After a while, Clara leaned back against a rock.
She looked exhausted.
"You should sleep," Elias said.
"So should you."
"I'll take first watch."
"Why?"
"Because I'm already awake."
She gave him a tired smile.
"You're a very poor liar, Mr. Mercer."
He almost smiled.
"Get some rest, Miss Bennett."
Clara wrapped her coat around herself and settled beneath the trees.
Within minutes, her breathing grew slow and steady.
Elias remained beside the fire.
He opened his father's letter again.
He read the words several times.
Your father was still alive when I left his house that night.
The sentence haunted him.
What had Vale done?
Had Samuel been beaten?
Threatened?
Had he been forced to watch his family suffer?
And why had Elias never suspected anything?
He remembered his father's last winter.
Samuel had seemed tired. He had complained about headaches and occasionally lost his balance. Once, he had dropped a hammer while working at the forge.
Elias had attributed it to age.
Now he wondered whether his father had been ill at all.
Perhaps he had been poisoned.
Perhaps the man who had attended his funeral had been responsible for his death.
A cold anger settled in Elias's chest.
He closed the letter.
Beyond the trees, a coyote called.
Another answered from the distant ridge.
The desert was speaking again.
Elias looked toward the darkness.
Something moved beyond the rocks.
He stood quietly.
His hand found the revolver.
A figure emerged from the shadows.
It was a boy.
Perhaps sixteen years old.