The Cowboy Found 200 Horses Stolen from the Tribe... 20 Apache Women Whispered, “Now We Are Yours”

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

People came from across the territory.

Ranchers.

Merchants.

Newspaper reporters.

Government officials.

Members of the Apache communities.

And families who had lost loved ones during the operation.

Elias attended with Clara.

His mother had remained in Abilene, but she had sent a letter to the court describing what she had witnessed the night Samuel died.

Her testimony had been accepted as evidence.

So had the medical report.

So had the photograph of Vale, Crowe, and Dr. Finch.

Henry Vale sat at the defense table.

He wore a dark suit and appeared composed.

His injured shoulder had healed, though he still moved stiffly.

Silas Boone sat several rows behind him, guarded by two deputies.

Caleb Rusk was among the witnesses.

He looked thinner.

His wife and daughter had returned to Santa Fe with him, but they remained under protection.

The trial began on a Monday morning.

The prosecutor, a stern woman named Eleanor Shaw, called the first witness.

It was Reverend Matthew Cole.

He testified about Samuel Mercer, the land agreements, and the documents hidden beneath the church.

Then Joseph Redbird described the removal of the families from the northern valley.

His voice was steady.

His testimony was devastating.

He spoke of children separated from their parents.

Of horses taken during the night.

Of homes burned.

Of families forced to walk through the desert without food or water.

Several people in the courtroom began to cry.

Vale remained motionless.

Then came the testimony of Dr. Albert Finch's former assistant.

The man described the payments made to the doctor.

He described the bottles of medicine delivered to Samuel Mercer.

And he explained that the symptoms recorded in the medical report were consistent with deliberate poisoning.

The courtroom became silent.

Elias sat beside Clara.

His hands were clasped tightly.

For eleven years, he had believed his father had died naturally.

Now strangers were speaking about his final days.

The prosecutor approached the witness stand.

"Did Dr. Finch know that Samuel Mercer was being poisoned?"

"Yes."

"How do you know?"

"Because he told me."

"Did he administer the substance himself?"

"Yes."

The prosecutor paused.

"And who paid him?"

The witness looked toward Vale.

"Colonel Henry Vale."

A murmur spread through the courtroom.

Vale leaned toward his lawyer.

The prosecutor continued.

"Was Nathaniel Crowe involved?"

"Yes."

"Did Silas Boone provide the money?"

"Yes."

The witness lowered his eyes.

"They all knew."

Caleb Rusk testified on the fourth day.

He entered the courtroom without looking at Elias.

He described the first meeting between Crowe and Vale.

He described the stolen horses.

He described the bribes, the forged documents, and the plans to remove the Apache families from their land.

Then he spoke about Samuel Mercer.

The courtroom became completely silent.

"Mr. Mercer hired me when I was seventeen," Rusk said.

The prosecutor approached.

"Why?"

"Because I was stealing."

"And what did he do?"

"He gave me a job."

"Did he know you were stealing?"

"Yes."

"Why didn't he turn you over to the sheriff?"

Rusk looked down.

"Because he believed I could become something better."

The prosecutor waited.

"Did you become something better?"

Rusk shook his head.

"No."

"Why?"

"Because I wanted money more than I wanted to be a decent man."

His voice cracked.

"I betrayed him."

He described the night Vale visited the Mercer home.

He described standing outside while the colonel entered.

He described the argument.

And finally, he described hearing the gunshot.

"Did you know Colonel Vale had killed Samuel Mercer?"

"Yes."

"Did you report it?"

"No."

"Why?"

"Because I was afraid."

The prosecutor looked at him.

"And when you were offered the chance to tell the truth, what did you do?"

Rusk swallowed.

"I tried to steal the evidence."

"Why?"

"Because Crowe had taken my family."

The prosecutor nodded.

"Did Mr. Mercer stop you?"

"Yes."

"Did he kill you?"

"No."

"Why not?"

Rusk looked toward Elias.

"Because he was a better man than I was."

The courtroom remained silent.

Then the prosecutor asked one final question.

"Do you regret what you did?"

Rusk's eyes filled with tears.

"Every day."

Vale was the last major witness.

He refused to testify at first.

But when the prosecutor introduced the medical records and the original payment ledger, his lawyer advised him that silence would only make matters worse.

Vale took the stand.

He spoke calmly.

He admitted that he had organized the operation.

He admitted that Crowe had financed it.

He admitted that Boone had helped purchase the stolen horses.

But he denied that the murders had been intentional.

The prosecutor approached.

News in the same category

The Cowboy Found 200 Horses Stolen from the Tribe... 20 Apache Women Whispered, “Now We Are Yours”

45 Part