“They called me after the case was closed. The lieutenant said there wasn’t enough evidence to support my allegation. He said I should be careful about accusing an officer of stealing anything.”
Victoria listened without interrupting.
“I was careful,” Reed continued. “I never said the officer stole the package. I said one container was missing after the search. I asked them to find out what happened to it. I gave them the names of the people at the destination because they could confirm the delivery was incomplete.”
“Were those people ever interviewed?”
“Not that I know of.”
“Did anyone contact you again after the closure?”
“Once. A few weeks later, I called to ask whether I could submit additional paperwork. The person who answered said the case was closed and there was no reason to reopen it. After that, I stopped calling.”
“Why?”
“Because I needed work. I was already losing deliveries. The company that contracted with me said they didn’t want drivers involved in disputes with law enforcement. Nobody said that was the official reason they stopped giving me routes. They didn’t have to.”
Victoria closed her eyes briefly.
“I’m sorry that happened to you.”
“I don’t need sympathy,” Reed said. “I need somebody to tell me whether the truth matters.”
“It does. But I won’t promise you an outcome before we finish the investigation.”
“I wouldn’t believe you if you did.”
That answer earned a small, involuntary smile from Victoria.
“Then we understand each other.”
She explained that investigators would need to compare his original statement with the delivery manifest, his photographs, and any surviving records from the contractor. She asked whether he still had copies.
“I kept everything,” Reed said. “Not because I thought anyone would help me. Because I knew somebody would eventually ask me to prove what I had said.”
“Could you provide copies to the independent investigators?”
“Yes.”
“Please don’t send the originals by ordinary mail. Laura Chen will contact you to arrange a secure transfer and document the chain of custody.”
“All right.”
Before ending the call, Reed asked one more question.
“Did you find other people’s complaints there?”
Victoria looked back toward the storage room.
“Yes.”
“How many?”
“We’re still inventorying the materials. I don’t want to give you a number that might change.”
“Are they going to get the same chance I’m getting?”
“That is what we’re working toward.”
Reed was quiet for a moment.
“Then make sure you do it,” he said. “Some of those people probably stopped believing anybody would ever listen.”
“I will do everything within my authority to ensure their complaints are reviewed fairly.”
He thanked her, and the call ended.
Victoria lowered the phone.
Laura had been standing several feet away, giving her privacy. Now she approached.
“How did he take it?”
“He wants the records examined, not an apology. He’s willing to cooperate.”
“That helps.”
“It also reminds us what’s at stake. We can’t let the discovery of a missing statement become the entire story. We have to find out what happened to the complaint, whether the investigation was adequate, and whether other people were denied the same process.”
Laura glanced toward the storage room.
“What if the records were moved here for ordinary reasons, and the department simply failed to maintain the archive properly?”
“Then we report that.”
“And if they were moved to conceal them?”
“Then we report that, too, if the evidence supports it.”
Laura studied her for a moment.
“You really believe we can get to the truth without deciding in advance what it is.”
“I have to believe it. Otherwise, we’re just another group of people using authority to make a story fit what we already think.”
They returned to the room, where Wallace was reviewing a newly discovered envelope.
The envelope contained a series of photographs showing the interior of a police interview room. The images were dated, but the date stamp had been applied by a digital camera whose clock could have been incorrect. The photographs appeared to document an incident involving a man who had complained that an officer struck him while he was handcuffed.
The complaint database described the allegation as “unsubstantiated due to insufficient corroboration.”
Yet the envelope also contained a handwritten note indicating that a second officer had been present during the incident.
The note did not identify whether that officer had been interviewed.
Laura searched the database.
“No witness interview is listed,” she said.
“Could it have been recorded under a different file number?” Wallace asked.
“Possibly. We’ll check the related personnel and incident records.”
Victoria read the note again. It was brief and difficult to interpret. The handwriting could have belonged to an investigator, a records clerk, or someone else who had handled the file.
No signature appeared.
“Preserve the note with the photographs,” she said. “We’ll need a handwriting examination only if it becomes material to identifying who created it.”
Wallace nodded.
At 10:05, a state police analyst called with preliminary findings from the digital records team. Laura put the call on speaker after confirming that the conversation could be documented.
The analyst explained that the shared administrative account had been used to access the complaint database on several dates corresponding to file closures. However, the logs did not identify individual users. The system administrator had confirmed that the account was originally created to support routine records maintenance and that its password had been shared among a small group of authorized employees.
“Can you narrow down the user based on workstation information?” Laura asked.
“Sometimes. The logs include device identifiers for most sessions, but several of the older records are incomplete. We’re comparing the identifiers with the department’s workstation inventory.”
“Can you establish whether files were deleted?”
“Not yet. We found changes to several attachment references. That could mean a document was moved, renamed, reindexed, or removed. The current database doesn’t preserve enough history to distinguish those actions in every case.”
“Can the backups help?”
“They may. We’ve requested archived backups from the county’s information technology contractor. We’re also checking whether the records management system kept separate audit logs.”
Victoria leaned toward the phone.
“Have you identified any evidence that the shared account was used outside its authorized function?”
“Not conclusively. The access pattern is unusual, but unusual activity is not necessarily unauthorized activity. We need to compare the sessions with the work schedules and maintenance records.”
“Please preserve the original logs before performing further analysis. And make sure the report distinguishes confirmed facts from hypotheses.”
“Understood.”
When the call ended, Laura looked at Victoria.
“The logs may never identify the person.”
“They might not. That doesn’t mean we stop looking. It means we look for independent evidence—workstation assignments, schedules, access records, and testimony.”
“What if the password was shared by six people?”
“Then we may need to establish who had the opportunity to use it, who actually used it, and whether anyone can corroborate the activity. We do not select the person whose name seems to fit the theory.”
Laura entered a note in her tablet.
The investigation had reached the point where every new discovery created a choice. The team could rush to assemble a dramatic explanation, or it could take the slower route of verifying each connection. The first approach might produce a compelling narrative in a day. The second might take weeks.
Victoria knew which one could survive scrutiny.
At noon, the team had completed the initial inventory of the first storage room. The materials relevant to the identified complaints had been secured, and the remaining boxes were photographed and logged for continued examination under the warrant.
The adjacent room required additional review because its contents included a mixture of county personnel records and police administrative files. Wallace contacted the judge’s clerk and obtained clarification on the permissible scope before the team entered. The clarification was documented, and the team proceeded only after confirming that the relevant categories fell within the authorized search.