The second room was smaller and less organized.
Old desks had been stacked against one wall. A broken copier sat beneath a sheet of plastic. Cardboard boxes filled the floor space, and several metal cabinets stood with their drawers partially open.
Near the back was a narrow desk with a locked drawer.
Unlike the cabinets in the first room, this desk looked as though it had been used recently. A paper calendar lay on top, turned to a month from the previous year. Beside it was a pen with its cap missing. A thin layer of dust covered most of the desktop, but the area around the pen was relatively clean.
The evidence technician documented the scene.
Lang shook his head.
“I don’t recognize this desk.”
“Was the room part of the authorized police storage area?” Wallace asked.
“Not according to the floor plan. It was supposed to be used for facilities records.”
“Could the police have stored things here anyway?”
“They could have. But there’s no record I’ve seen authorizing it.”
Victoria examined the calendar from a distance. Several dates had been marked with small circles. The markings might have been ordinary appointments, but the calendar was not an official county document, and no one could yet say who had placed it there.
“Is this within the scope of the warrant?” Laura asked.
Wallace checked the language.
“The warrant authorizes the search for specified complaint records and associated transfer or storage documentation. We can document the desk and examine it for those materials. If we encounter unrelated personal records, we stop and seek further guidance.”
The drawer was locked.
The locksmith opened it after the exterior had been photographed and the action documented. Inside were several loose papers, a small envelope, and a folded sheet of county letterhead.
The letterhead bore the name of Deputy Chief Robert Vance.
Victoria’s attention sharpened.
The letter was dated eighteen months earlier and addressed to a county facilities supervisor. Its subject line read: “Temporary Archive Access.”
Laura read the first paragraph aloud.
This correspondence confirms that members of the Blackwood Police Department may require periodic access to the annex for the purpose of reviewing archived complaint materials and associated administrative records. Access should be coordinated through the deputy chief’s office.
The letter did not explicitly authorize the storage of additional records. It did not identify which employees had access or explain how visits were supposed to be documented. It also did not extend the original storage agreement.
But it established something important.
Someone in the deputy chief’s office had arranged periodic access to the annex long after the original transfer had become unclear.
“Is this letter in the official facilities records?” Victoria asked.
Laura searched the digital files on her tablet.
“No. I found the original temporary storage agreement, but not this correspondence.”
“Could it have been filed under a different category?”
“Possibly. We’ll need a full search of the facilities archive before we can say it’s absent from the official records.”
Wallace examined the letter’s signature. It appeared to bear Vance’s name, but no one treated that as proof that Vance had personally signed it. The signature would need to be authenticated, and the paper’s origin would need to be established.
“Do we have a date for the last documented visit?” Victoria asked.
Laura checked the maintenance and access records.
“The building access system recorded several entries, but the logs are incomplete. The most recent identifiable entry was seven months ago. There are two later entries tied to a generic facilities credential, but we can’t tell who used it.”
“Then we need to identify the credential and determine whether it was assigned to a person or a team.”
Laura photographed the letter and entered it into the evidence log.
Underneath it lay a small envelope. The front was blank, except for the words “For the next review” written in blue ink.
The envelope had not been sealed.
Wallace paused before allowing it to be opened. He reviewed the search authorization and determined that the envelope could contain materials related to the complaint archive. He directed the technician to photograph its position and exterior, then remove the contents.
Inside was a single sheet of paper.
It contained a list of names, dates, and short phrases. Some were ordinary administrative notes: “return copies,” “confirm receipt,” “awaiting signatures.” Others were less clear.
Beside one name was the phrase “do not duplicate.”
Beside another was “hold pending instruction.”
Near the bottom, one line read:
“Original statements remain separate until cleared.”
No signature. No letterhead. No explanation of what “cleared” meant.
Laura read the sentence again.
“Could this be a routine records-management instruction?” she asked.
“It could,” Victoria said. “Documents sometimes remain separate because they contain protected information or because a review is ongoing. But we need to establish who wrote this, what records it refers to, and what ‘cleared’ meant in this context.”
“What if it refers to complaints that were being investigated internally?”
“Then we should find the corresponding investigation files.”
Laura photographed the note and began matching the listed names to the complaint database.
One name belonged to a former records clerk who had retired three years earlier. Another was a current administrative employee. A third was a former officer who had left the department after an unrelated disciplinary matter.
At the bottom of the page, one date was circled twice.
It was the date on which Thomas Reed’s complaint had been closed.
Victoria felt the room grow quieter around her.
The date alone did not establish that the note referred to Reed’s case. The list might have included many records, and the circle could have been added later for reasons they did not understand.
Still, the coincidence warranted examination.
“Mark the date as a potential connection,” Victoria said. “Don’t write that it relates to Reed until we can establish that.”
Laura made the notation.
A few minutes later, she discovered that one of the other dates corresponded to a complaint involving a woman named Angela Morris, who had reported that an officer searched her car after she had explicitly refused consent. Her complaint had been closed without a documented witness interview.
Another date matched a complaint filed by a young man who alleged that an officer had threatened to arrest him if he continued recording a traffic stop.
The pattern was beginning to emerge, but it was still incomplete.
Several of the listed cases involved allegations against different officers. Some had been closed by Ellison; others had been reviewed by different supervisors. The note might have been a working list used by someone responsible for tracking supplementary materials. It might also have reflected an unofficial procedure for keeping original statements separate from the files used in formal reviews.
The crucial question was whether that separation had been lawful, routine, and properly documented—or whether it had prevented relevant evidence from reaching the people responsible for deciding the complaints.
Victoria turned to Wallace.
“We need the identity of the person who created this list, but we also need the people who acted on it. Start with the records clerks and administrative employees who handled these cases. We’ll interview them separately, and we won’t show them the full document until counsel has reviewed the interview plan.”
“Agreed,” Wallace said.
Laura added, “We should also identify who had access to the room.”
“Yes. Everyone who had keys, credentials, or documented authorization. We need the access history, not just the names we suspect.”
At 1:18 p.m., the team completed the preliminary search of the second room. The materials were secured for further examination, and the rooms were photographed in their final documented state. The team did not remove unrelated county records, and any material whose relevance remained uncertain was left in place pending review.