The first thing I noticed was not the little girl’s mismatched shoes.

Chapter 19

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Wells did not look up when I came in. He turned the note over, then turned it back, as if the paper might have changed its mind overnight.

Morning, Luke, he said.

Morning, Sheriff.

Come and look at this with me, he said. "You've got good eyes for a man who reads a room."

I stepped closer. The note was written in blue ink on lined paper torn from a notebook, the top edge ragged where it had been pulled free. The handwriting leaned to the right and hurried in places, the letters crowding together at the ends of lines, as if the writer had been afraid of running out of room. It said, in plain words, that Sarah Collins gave Royce Dalton permission to pick up Maisie Collins from school and to care for her until further notice, and it was dated three days before the pickup. Underneath was a signature that tried very hard to look like Sarah's.

Wells tapped the signature with the end of his pen. "Her name is spelled right," he said. "The letters are close. But look at the pressure."

I looked. The strokes were heavy in the wrong places, pressed hard where Sarah's own writing, on the school form beside it, moved light and quick. On the school form her S flowed in one motion, open at the top, the way a person signs something a hundred times a year signs it. On the note the S had been drawn, not written, built up in small careful pieces, and the pen had paused in the middle of the C, leaving a dark dot where the writer had stopped to think about what came next.

Somebody copied it, I said.

Somebody practised it, Wells said. "That's my guess. A handwriting examiner is coming in from the county this afternoon to look at both of them properly. He'll want samples from Sarah, and samples from Royce, and he'll want to know what else Royce wrote in his own hand. That takes time. Forgery cases are slow the way a good fence is slow. You don't rush them or they fall over."

Hernandez slid a second folder across the counter. Inside were printouts, neat columns of numbers and times, the kind of record that looks dull until you know what it means.

Phone records, Hernandez said. "Royce's, and Sarah's. The judge signed for both."

Wells walked me through them the way a man walks another man through a route he has already ridden, pointing out the turns before they arrive. Royce's phone had been busy in the days before the pickup. Calls to Dale Kessler, short ones, late at night, three on the evening before he took Maisie, one that lasted forty-one minutes. A call to a motel outside Kingman, made the morning of the pickup, before school was even out. No call to Sarah at all. Not one. Not in the week before, not in the month before. A man who claimed a mother had asked him to take her child had never once picked up the phone to speak to that mother.

Sarah's records told the other side of the story in the same plain language. On the afternoon Maisie was taken, at three-fourteen, she had called the school. At three-twenty-one, she had called the school again. At three-thirty she had called the sheriff's office. Before four o'clock she had called three friends, one after another, her voice, I imagined, getting thinner with each call, asking if anyone had seen a little girl in a yellow shirt. She had called the care home where she worked to say she would not be in. She had called her neighbour. The record did not show panic. It showed a mother working through a list, doing everything a person can do when the worst thing has happened and there is still daylight left to do something about it.

She called everybody she could think of, Wells said quietly. "Within the hour. That's not a woman who handed her daughter over."

I thought about Sarah sitting in her kitchen that afternoon, the phone pressed to her ear, Maisie's empty bedroom down the hall, and I felt the same anger I had felt in the diner, only colder now, settled deeper, the kind that does not shout.

Royce was brought in that afternoon to give his handwriting samples, and I watched from the hallway as Hernandez led him past. He was wearing the same dark work shirt, washed now, and his trimmed beard had been combed. He walked calmly, the way a man walks when he has rehearsed what he is going to say. He did not look at me. He looked at the floor tiles and counted them, or pretended to.

Later, Wells told me what Royce had told his lawyer, and then what the lawyer had told the county attorney. Royce had a new story. The first had been that he was a family friend doing a favour. The second had been that Sarah had given him permission in a note. Now there was a third, the simplest one of all. Sarah, he said, had asked him to take Maisie. She had been overwhelmed at work, she had asked him to keep the girl for a few days, and then she had changed her mind and called the police out of spite, or fear, or confusion. He was only trying to help. He was only trying to be a family.

News in the same category

The first thing I noticed was not the little girl’s mismatched shoes.

45 Part