The HOA Dumped Trash Into His Pool for 30 Days, Then One Torn Bag Exposed a Police Evidence Scandal

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Keep copies of everything," Raymond said. "Every notice, every letter, every photograph, every report. Keep a copy at home and a copy somewhere else. And Desmond — if you hear from Cynthia directly, write down what she says, word for word, and date it. I have a feeling you are going to need all of it."

"Thank you, Raymond," Desmond said. "I will."

After he hung up, Desmond sat at the table for a long time, turning the conversation over in his mind. He had not expected sympathy from the board. He had expected a form letter, or silence, or a polite dismissal. What he had gotten instead was something else entirely: a vice president telling him, in careful, measured words, that the president of his homeowners association had a history of doing exactly what Desmond believed she was doing to him now.

He opened his folder, added a page to it — Call from Raymond Cho, Saturday, re: letter to the board. Sympathetic. Says Cynthia has targeted others before. Advised: keep copies of everything. — and he wrote the date at the top, and he put the folder back on the shelf where he kept it, next to the router logs and the photographs and Officer Osei's card.

He thought about Raymond Cho for the rest of the day, and about what it must have cost the man to make that call. Raymond was the vice president of the association, and he had to sit in meetings with Cynthia Larkin, and vote on her motions, and listen to her talk about discipline and standards, week after week. Saying what he had said to Desmond — that the enforcement had not been the same for everyone, that he had seen it, that Betty Sandoval had seen it too — was not a small thing for a man like that. It was the kind of thing you said when you had been quiet for too long and the quiet had started to feel like agreement. Desmond respected it. He also understood, without Raymond having to say it, that the vice president could not fight this battle for him. Raymond could confirm the pattern, and he could preside over a meeting, and he could vote — but the evidence, the documentation, the record, all of that had to come from Desmond. That was fair. It was his pool, his fence, his mornings. He opened his notebook that evening and wrote down one more line, under the account of the call: Raymond Cho is not the enemy. Neither is Betty Sandoval. The board is not one person. He wanted to remember that, too, when the time came to stand in front of all of them.

Chidi Okafor came to Desmond's door on Sunday afternoon, and he did not come to borrow anything or to make small talk. He came because Raymond Cho had told him about the letter, and because, as he put it, standing on Desmond's porch with his hands in his pockets, "I think we have the same problem."

Chidi was in his late thirties, a pharmacist, with a wife and two young children, and he lived three houses down from Desmond, in the house with the basketball hoop in the driveway — the same basketball hoop that had been the subject of what Chidi described, with a tiredness that suggested he had told the story many times, as "months of fines."

"It started with a notice," Chidi said, sitting at Desmond's kitchen table with a glass of water he had not asked for but that Desmond had set in front of him anyway. "The hoop was too tall, they said. Then it was the wrong color. Then it was too close to the street. Then it was a safety hazard. Every time I fixed one thing, there was another notice. Every time I asked which rule I was breaking, the answer was different. I paid the fines because I did not want trouble. I paid them for months. And then one day I was driving through the neighborhood and I counted seven other basketball hoops. Seven. None of them had a single notice. None of them had a single fine."

Desmond listened, and he thought about the umbrella — dark blue versus navy — and about the pool furniture notice, and about the trash cans, and about the visitor's tires touching the decorative curb line. He thought about the way each notice, on its own, had seemed small enough to ignore, and the way all of them together had formed a pattern that was impossible to miss once someone else described it to you.

"Did you ever ask why it was only you?" Desmond asked.

"I asked," Chidi said. "I asked Cynthia directly. She told me that the board enforces the rules as complaints come in, and that if I had a problem with a neighbor's hoop, I was welcome to file a complaint myself. As if the point were the hoops. The point was never the hoops."

He looked down at his glass of water for a moment, and then back at Desmond.

News in the same category

The HOA Dumped Trash Into His Pool for 30 Days, Then One Torn Bag Exposed a Police Evidence Scandal

45 Part