She denied everything. She said she had never heard of any bags, that she had no idea what he was talking about, that Desmond Preston was a difficult man who had caused trouble for the association since the day he moved in. She said the umbrella dispute had been a misunderstanding, and that she had withdrawn the notice, and that Desmond had held a grudge ever since.
When Wells asked where her son Brandon had been on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday nights, she said he had been home all night, every night, that he was always home at night, that he had no reason to be out on the easement path behind Desmond's house at half past two in the morning. She said Brandon was a good boy, that he worked at an electronics store, that he lived with her because housing was expensive and he was saving money, and that she would not have her son accused of something he had not done.
Wells asked about the white SUV. Cynthia said it was hers, that Brandon sometimes drove it because his own car was unreliable, that it was parked in her driveway most nights. She did not ask why he was asking about the SUV. She did not seem surprised by the question, which Wells noticed, and noted, without saying so.
Then her tone changed. She leaned forward in her chair, the pearl earrings catching the light, and told Wells that Desmond was harassing her. That he had been harassing her since the umbrella incident. That he had sent her photographs of the design manual as if she did not know her own rules. That he had written to the board behind her back. That he had recorded her at his front door without telling her, or at least without asking her properly. That she felt unsafe in her own neighborhood, and that she wanted it on record that Desmond Preston was the problem, not her.
Wells listened to all of it. He did not argue. He did not tell her about the trail camera, or the router logs, or the partial plate, or the phone data he had not yet obtained. He asked a few more questions — had she ever walked the easement path, had she ever spoken to Desmond about his pool, had she ever received any complaints about Desmond from other residents — and she answered each one with a firm no, or a version of a no that blamed Desmond for the question itself.
When he stood to leave, she walked him to the door and said, with the same composure she had worn all afternoon, that she hoped he would look into Desmond's behavior, and that the association had standards, and that standards mattered. Wells thanked her for her time and left.
That evening, on the phone, Wells told Desmond what Cynthia had said, and what she had not said.
"She denied everything," Wells said. "She said Brandon was home all night. She said you're harassing her. She didn't ask about the note. She didn't ask about the raccoon. Most people, when you tell them a dead animal was thrown into a neighbor's pool, they ask about the animal."
Desmond wrote that down. He did not say anything about Cynthia's composure, or her robe, or her sunglasses. He did not need to. Wells had seen it himself.
"What's next?" Desmond asked.
"We canvass," Wells said. "We talk to the neighbors. We check the SUV. We follow the evidence where it goes."
Desmond thanked him and ended the call. He sat at the kitchen table for a while, the legal pad in front of him, the notes from the call in his own handwriting. He thought about Cynthia standing in her doorway in a floral robe, telling a detective that her son had been home all night, and about how easy it was to say a thing like that when you were used to people believing you. He thought about the trail camera, still mounted behind the fence, still watching the easement path. He thought about patience, and about how long it sometimes took for a lie to run out of room.
He put the legal pad back in the binder, closed the binder, and went to bed early. He was tired, in the way he had been tired since Monday, but it was a different tired now — not the tired of waiting, but the tired of knowing that the work had begun.
On Saturday morning, Detective Wells canvassed the street.
He started with Walter Sims, who was out at dawn walking his dog, as he was every morning, and who had lived in Cedar Ridge longer than almost anyone else on the block. Walter was seventy-one, retired, and observant in the way that people who walk the same route at the same hour every day become observant — not because they are looking for trouble, but because they notice when something is out of place.
Wells found him on the sidewalk near the greenbelt entrance, the dog sniffing at the grass, Walter holding the leash with one hand and a paper coffee cup with the other. Wells introduced himself, asked if Walter had seen anything unusual on the easement path late at night, and waited.