The HOA President Called Police on a Lineman for 'Trespassing' — Then They Dug Beside Her Fence
Oakwood Estates was not a neighborhood so much as a fortress of suburban uniformity, and everybody who lived inside it knew it, because Brenda made sure they knew it. The houses stood in two neat rows along Elmwood Drive, two storeys tall, beige and stone gray and colonial blue, each one set back from the curb by exactly the same distance, each one wearing the same approved shade of paint that the association called Heritage White, although half the houses were not white at all and nobody had ever seen the sample card. The driveways were oil-free, because oil stains were a violation, and the mailboxes were uniform, exactly forty-two inches high, black metal on black posts, each one standing at attention like a small soldier at the edge of the lawn. The lawns themselves were the real religion of Oakwood Estates. They were green and flat and edged with a precision that looked less like gardening and more like engineering, and the reason they looked that way was that Brenda walked them every morning with a tape measure in one hand and a clipboard in the other, and she measured.
Brenda was the president of the homeowners association, and she ruled the neighborhood the way a queen rules a small country that has never once been invaded, which is to say completely, and with the full confidence of someone who has never been told no by anyone who mattered. She was over fifty, with dyed platinum blonde hair cut into a sharp bob that did not move when she walked, and she was usually dressed in a pastel golf shirt and khaki capri pants, the clipboard tucked against her ribs like a shield. She was out before most of the neighborhood had finished its coffee, patrolling the sidewalks in the early light, stopping at every lawn, bending at the waist with the tape measure, and writing things down. Grass was not allowed to exceed three inches. That was the rule, written in the association handbook in plain black letters, and Brenda enforced it the way other people enforced speed limits, which is to say she enforced it personally, and she enjoyed it. A blade of grass that stood a quarter of an inch too tall was a violation. A blade of grass that stood half an inch too tall was a violation with a fine attached. She had fined people for holiday decorations left up past January second, and she had done it on January third, in the morning, with the clipboard already full. She had once threatened to sue a family because their mulch was the wrong color, too reddish-brown, a phrase she had written on the violation notice in her neat, looping handwriting, as though the color of mulch were a matter of public safety. Nobody in Oakwood Estates had ever quite figured out how to argue with her, because Brenda did not argue. She cited. She pointed at the rule. She wrote the number down. She moved on to the next lawn, and the next, and the next, and by the time she reached the end of Elmwood Drive the whole neighborhood had been measured, weighed, and found either compliant or wanting, and Brenda knew exactly which houses were which.
Her mornings followed the same pattern every single day, and Brenda loved the pattern the way other people loved a favorite song. She was up before six, and she made her coffee strong and black, and she stood at the kitchen window while she drank it, looking out at her own lawn in the early light, checking it the way a general checks a battlefield before the fighting starts. Then she put on her pastel golf shirt and her khaki capri pants, and she picked up the clipboard, and she went out the front door with the tape measure clipped to her waistband, and she started walking. She walked the same route every morning, down one side of Elmwood Drive and back up the other, and she stopped at every house, and she looked, and she measured, and she wrote. The tape measure was yellow and battered, the numbers worn smooth in the middle from years of use, and Brenda could read it without looking, by feel, the way a musician can find the right note without looking at the keys. Three inches was the limit. She could tell three inches from three and a quarter inches just by running her palm across the top of the grass, and she did, every morning, lawn after lawn, her hand moving across the green in a slow, flat sweep, her eyes half-closed in concentration, the clipboard tucked under her arm. When the grass was right, she gave a small, satisfied nod and moved on. When it was wrong, she knelt, and she measured properly, with the tape, and she wrote the number down in the little box on the form, and she dated it, and she initialed it, and she slipped a copy of the notice into the mailbox, and she moved on. It was not personal. Brenda had said that many times, at meetings, at the mailbox, on the phone, and she believed it. It was not personal. It was the rules. The rules were the same for everyone, and Brenda was the person who made sure they stayed the same, and if that made people avoid her on the sidewalk, that was their problem, not hers.