Davis took the GPS sheet too, and he looked at it, and he looked up at the street, and then he looked back down at the sheet, and Mike could see him doing the quiet arithmetic in his head, matching numbers to ground, matching ground to numbers, the way a man does when he is trying to decide whether the person in front of him is telling the truth or telling a story.
"And third," Mike said, and this was the one that mattered most, the one he had been saving, "this is the plat map. This is the county plat for Oakwood Estates, filed with the county recorder, and it shows the utility easement running along the south boundary of this lot. Ten feet wide. It runs the full length of the lot, and it is marked, right here, in black and white, as a utility easement for the County Power Authority. It has been there since the subdivision was platted. It was there before this house was built. It was there before the fence went up. It was there before the HOA existed. It is on the map, and the map is the law."
He spread the plat map out on the hood of the truck, weighting the corners down with a wrench and a roll of tape so the wind would not take it, and Davis leaned over it, his hat shading his eyes, his finger following the thin black line that ran along the south edge of Brenda's lot. The line was labeled, in small, neat print, and Davis read the label out loud, slowly, as if he wanted everyone standing nearby to hear it, as if he wanted the words themselves to settle the argument.
"Utility easement," he said. "Ten feet. County Power Authority."
He stood up straight then, and he looked at Brenda, and his face was calm, and his voice was calm, and there was nothing in either of them that suggested he was about to do what she wanted him to do.
"Ma'am," he said, "I've looked at the papers. I've looked at the work order, and I've looked at the GPS coordinates, and I've looked at the plat map. These men are not trespassing. They have lawful access to this easement. The easement is on the county plat, it is ten feet wide, and it gives the power company the right to enter it, to excavate in it, and to repair the cable in it, especially in an emergency. I understand that you don't like it. I understand that you don't want them here. But they are not breaking the law by being here. They are doing their jobs."
The words landed on the street like stones dropped into still water, and for a moment nobody said anything at all. The neighbors along the sidewalk exchanged glances. Dave let out a breath he had been holding since the patrol car pulled up. And Brenda, standing on her driveway with her clipboard still clutched to her chest, went very still, and then very red, and then she began to speak, and the words came out of her in a rush, as if she had been holding them back behind a dam and the dam had just broken.
She did not argue about the map. She did not argue about the work order. She did not argue about the GPS coordinates, because there was nothing to argue about, and she knew it, and the knowing of it only made her angrier. Instead she argued about something else entirely, something that had nothing to do with the law and everything to do with the way she saw the world, and her voice rose as she spoke, higher and sharper, until it carried across the whole street and the neighbors could hear every word of it, whether they wanted to or not.
"I pay my mortgage!" she shouted, and her voice cracked a little on the word mortgage, as if the word itself carried a weight she could barely lift. "I pay my taxes! I pay my taxes every single year, on time, in full, and this is my property, my house, my lawn, and I am telling you, officer, that no piece of paper from fifty years ago is going to tell me what I can and cannot do on my own land!"