"That man abandoned you before you were born."
Elias had believed him.
Now the silver hawk hanging from his neck seemed suddenly heavier.
Takakota.
The name he had only recently learned.
His father.
A man he had spent his entire life believing had abandoned him.
A man Samuel had apparently murdered.
Ayanna watched his face.
"You know this man."
Elias folded the paper.
"He raised me."
The cave became silent.
Neheni, the oldest of the women who had first found Elias, stepped closer.
"Then we return to White Mesa."
"No."
Elias's voice was quiet.
"I go alone."
Ayanna shook her head.
"No."
"This is family."
"So was Takakota."
Elias looked at her.
She did not move.
"You came here thinking you were alone," she said. "You are not alone anymore."
Something inside him wanted to reject those words.
Because being alone was easier.
If he rode north alone, no one could stop him.
He could find Samuel.
He could put a bullet through his chest.
Then the past would finally be silent.
Simple.
Clean.
Finished.
But Nehoni seemed to read his thoughts.
"Revenge is easy when the dead cannot disagree."
Elias glared at her.
"He murdered my father."
"Then learn why."
"What reason could matter?"
"Maybe none."
She looked toward the documents.
"But if you kill him before he speaks, you may kill the whole truth with him."
Elias hated that she was right.
He hated it because, for the first time in his life, he understood that killing Samuel would not answer every question.
It would only end the conversation.
And Elias had spent too many years living inside a lie.
He wanted the truth.
Even if the truth destroyed the last thing he had ever called family.
They left the cave before sunrise.
The desert was cold enough to make Elias's fingers ache.
Ayanna rode beside him.
Neither spoke for the first hour.
Behind them, the cliffs of White Mesa glowed faintly beneath the morning sun.
Elias kept thinking about Samuel.
He remembered a winter when he had been ten.
There had been snow for three days.
Their small house had nearly run out of wood.
Elias had awakened during the night to find Samuel feeding the last pieces of furniture into the stove.
"You'll freeze," Elias had said.
Samuel had shrugged.
"You're the one growing."
Elias had never forgotten it.
There had been another memory.
When Elias was seventeen, he had fallen from a horse and broken his ankle.
Samuel had carried him six miles.
Six miles.
Elias remembered looking over his uncle's shoulder, watching the ground pass beneath them.
He had felt safe.
How could a man who had done such things also murder his father?
That was the question that tortured him.
Ayanna finally spoke.
"You are remembering him."
Elias looked at her.
"How do you know?"
"Because you look like someone trying to solve a puzzle with pieces he hates."
He almost smiled.
"You always talk like that?"
"Only when you need it."
He looked ahead.
"What if he had a reason?"
"Then you will hear it."
"What if the reason is unforgivable?"
"Then you will decide what to do with it."
Elias touched the silver hawk around his neck.
"Do you think people can love someone and still destroy them?"
Ayanna thought for a moment.
"Yes."
"How?"
"Fear."
The answer came without hesitation.
"Fear makes people protect the wrong things."
Elias remembered Nehoni's words.
He remembered Mercer.
He remembered the documents.
By late afternoon, they reached a narrow valley.
Neheni led them toward an abandoned trading post.
Inside the ruined building they found more evidence.
A map.
Several letters.
And a list of names.
Takakota had not merely collected proof.
He had been building a case.
Years earlier, a railroad syndicate had begun planning an expansion route through the territory.
The route crossed several valleys used by Apache families.
Buying the land legally would have been expensive.
Removing the people by force would have been dangerous.
So the syndicate found another solution.
They created enemies.
Men were hired to attack settlers while wearing Apache clothing.