THE LOST COWBOY CROSSED INTO APACHE TERRITORY — THEN THE WOMEN FOUND HIS SECRET

Chapter 5

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

As a man who had tried to expose a conspiracy.

Samuel confessed to the murder.

His confession shocked the territory.

But Elias refused to testify against him emotionally.

He testified only to facts.

What Samuel had done.

What he had hidden.

What he had confessed.

The prosecutor asked Elias whether he wanted Samuel executed.

Elias looked at the judge.

"I wanted him dead."

The courtroom became silent.

"Do you still?"

Elias thought about it.

"No."

"Why?"

"Because if I kill him, he becomes a dead man. People can turn dead men into whatever story they want."

The judge frowned.

Elias continued.

"I want him alive long enough for the truth to remain attached to his name."

That was the punishment Elias chose.

Not revenge.

Memory.

Samuel was sentenced to prison.

Before he was taken away, he looked at Elias.

There were tears in his eyes.

"I was your father in every way that mattered," Samuel whispered.

Elias stared at him.

"No."

Samuel looked wounded.

"You know I loved you."

"I believe you."

"Then why?"

"Because love does not erase what you did."

Samuel lowered his head.

Elias touched the silver hawk.

"You taught me to ride."

Samuel looked up.

"You taught me to shoot."

A pause.

"You taught me to survive."

Elias's voice became quieter.

"But you also taught me the wrong lesson."

"What lesson?"

"That protecting someone means deciding their truth for them."

Samuel looked away.

Elias walked out.

He never visited Samuel in prison.

Five years later, Samuel died there.

Elias eventually wrote him one letter.

It contained three sentences.

I remember what you did.

I also remember what you taught me that was good.

I refuse to become either your lie or your crime.

He never learned whether Samuel understood.

Eventually, it no longer mattered.

Elias stayed at White Mesa.

At first, he told himself it was temporary.

There were documents to translate.

Officials to meet.

Investigators to guide through old trails.

Witnesses to locate.

Questions about Takakota that needed answers.

Then winter came.

Elias remained.

Spring followed.

He remained.

He helped repair corrals.

He hunted.

He learned the names of plants he had never noticed before.

He learned which trails flooded after rain.

He learned that Apache horses could be stubborn enough to start arguments.

He also taught young men how to track.

His cowboy methods were strange to them.

Their methods were strange to him.

They spent weeks teasing each other.

"You move too loudly," one young man told Elias.

"Your horse is ugly," Elias answered.

The young man nearly challenged him to a fight.

Ayanna watched from nearby and laughed.

Life began to feel ordinary.

That frightened Elias more than danger ever had.

Because ordinary life could be lost.

One evening, Elias sat on a ridge overlooking the settlement.

Ayanna approached.

"What are you doing?"

"Thinking."

"Dangerous habit."

He smiled.

"You sound like Neheni."

"Then I am becoming wise."

Below them, children ran between shelters.

Smoke rose from cooking fires.

Someone was singing.

Elias touched the hawk pendant.

"I spent thirty years thinking my father abandoned me."

"Now you know he did not."

"That doesn't give me those thirty years back."

"No."

Ayanna never lied to make pain smaller.

That was one of the things Elias loved about her.

The realization came suddenly.

Loved.

He looked at her.

She noticed.

"What?"

"Nothing."

"You are a bad liar."

"I've been told."

She smiled.

Elias looked toward the valley.

"Takakota left his people for my mother."

"Yes."

"Do you think he regretted it?"

Ayanna considered.

"Probably some days."

Elias laughed.

"That's not romantic."

"Truth is rarely romantic."

She looked at him.

"But he chose her."

Elias became quiet.

Ayanna continued.

"Choosing someone does not mean the road becomes easy."

She pointed toward the valley.

"It means when the road becomes hard, you choose again."

"The next day?"

"Again."

"And after that?"

She smiled.

"You are a slow learner."

Elias reached for her hand.

She let him take it.

"I might need many lessons."

News in the same category

THE LOST COWBOY CROSSED INTO APACHE TERRITORY — THEN THE WOMEN FOUND HIS SECRET

7 Part