The Nanny Who Made Boston's Most Feared Crime Boss Believe in Home Again

Chapter 1

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Chapter 1: The House on the Hill

The agency called Claire Bennett on a Tuesday morning, while she was standing in her kitchen in South Boston counting out the last of the coffee into a paper filter she had already used twice.

"Mercer," the woman from Hartwell Domestic said, in the bright, careful voice people used when a job was either very good or very bad and they had not yet decided which way to sell it. "The Mercer household, in Brookline. Live-in nanny, one child, a girl, six years old. The salary is—" She named a figure, and Claire stopped counting coffee.

The salary was three times what Claire had made at the preschool in Dorchester, before the preschool lost its funding in March and let half its staff go with two weeks' notice and a sheet cake. It was more than the two part-time families in Cambridge and Somerville paid her combined, and those two families had let her go in the spring, one because the grandmother moved in, one because, as the mother had put it with terrible kindness, they were "downsizing everything, even help." Claire was twenty-nine years old. She had a degree in early childhood education she was still paying for, a landlord named Mr. Petrakis who had begun leaving notes instead of knocking, which she understood to be the final stage before knocking stopped mattering, and four hundred and eleven dollars in a checking account that her car, a 2014 hatchback with a passenger door that only opened from the inside, regarded as a personal insult.

"What's wrong with it?" Claire asked.

"Nothing is wrong with it," the woman said, too quickly. "The family is very private. The previous arrangements simply didn't work out."

"How many previous arrangements?"

There was a pause filled with the sound of keys being pressed by someone buying time. "The household has had some turnover."

"How much turnover?"

"Ms. Bennett, if you're not interested—"

"I'm interested," Claire said. "I'm interested the way you're interested in the weather before you walk to the train. I'd just like to know if it's raining."

Another pause. "Five," the woman said at last. "In two years. The most recent left on Sunday. The family would like someone to start Thursday, if the interview goes well. I should tell you that Mr. Mercer conducts the interviews personally, and he does not—" she searched for the word "—he does not warm to people quickly."

"Does the child?"

"The child," the woman said, and her voice changed in a way Claire would remember later, in the car, driving up the long hill, "the child is why they all stay as long as they do."

Claire had spent her entire adult life surviving on too little money and too little certainty, and it had given her one skill that no course had ever taught her: she noticed routines. Not faces, not furniture, not the things people wanted you to notice. Routines. The grocery clerk who suddenly locked the register drawer between customers. The boyfriend, years ago, who started taking his phone into the bathroom the same week he started being nicer about dishes. Danger, in Claire's experience, almost never announced itself. It altered routines. It changed the order of small things, it added a step or quietly took one away, and if you were the sort of person whose rent depended on reading a room correctly, you learned to watch the small things the way sailors watched the sky.

So she noticed things on the drive up the hill, and she kept noticing them.

She noticed that the street, one of those old Brookline streets where the trees were older than the houses and the houses were older than the country in places, had no other car parked on it, not one, on a weekday morning. She noticed that the Mercer gates were not the decorative kind, scrolled iron meant to suggest wealth; they were the functional kind, meant to stop a vehicle, with a camera housing above them that turned, very slightly, to follow her hatchback as she slowed. She noticed that a man in a dark coat was standing at the pedestrian gate before she had fully stopped the car, which meant someone had been watching the street, which meant the street was the sort of place that got watched.

"Ms. Bennett?" he said, when she rolled the window down. He was perhaps fifty, broad through the shoulders gone slightly to thickness, with a face that had clearly been handsome once and had settled for being trusted instead. "Marcus Hale. Head of security. If you'll leave the car here, I'll have it brought around. I check every vehicle personally the first time. After that you'll have a pass."

"You check it for what?" Claire asked, climbing out with her bag, because she had learned that asking plainly was faster than pretending not to wonder.

"For anything that isn't you," Marcus said, without smiling, though his eyes were not unkind. "You'll get used to us. Everyone says they won't. Then they do."

The house itself rose behind the gates in pale stone and dark slate, three stories and a mansard roof, with gardens that descended in terraces toward a lawn and, beyond a line of bare winter trees, the gray glitter of the Charles in the distance. It was beautiful the way a museum was beautiful, and Claire's first thought, uninvited and entirely accurate, was that it did not look like a house anyone lived in. It looked like a house that was being kept. Every window was clean. Every hedge was cut to the same line. Nothing was out of place because nothing, she suspected, was ever permitted to be in the way.

The front door opened before Marcus had finished with the car, and a woman came down the steps with the unhurried speed of someone who has run a house for so long that the house has started to run at her tempo. She was in her sixties, silver-haired, aproned over a dark dress, with flour on one wrist and an expression that took Claire in the way an experienced cook takes in a new knife: weight, balance, edge.

"Rosa," the woman said, and held out the hand without the flour. "I keep the house. You must be the new one." She said the new one without malice and without optimism, the way one might say the new weather. "Come. You will want tea. Everyone wants tea and says they don't. Mr. Mercer is in the city until four. I will show you the house, and then you will meet Lily at lunch, if lunch is a thing she agrees to that day."

"If?" Claire said, following her into a hall so high and quiet that her footsteps seemed to arrive a half-second after she did.

"Some days lunch is toast," Rosa said. "Some days lunch is the idea of toast." She led Claire through rooms that were all, in their different ways, waiting rooms: a formal parlor with the furniture arranged for guests who did not come; a dining room that could seat eighteen and had dust in the seams of the chairs; a library with a fire laid but unlit. "You will be on the second floor, next to Lily. Your hours are seven to seven, that is what Mr. Mercer will tell you, twelve hours, and he will mean it, he is fair about hours the way other men are not fair about anything. Sundays you are off unless there is an emergency. There has not been an emergency named as one in two years, though we have had several we did not name."

"Rosa," Claire said carefully, as they climbed a staircase wide enough for two people to pass without acknowledging each other, "the agency said five nannies in two years. Is that right?"

Rosa stopped on the landing, beside a tall window that looked down over the terraced garden, and she did not pretend to misunderstand. "It is right. Mrs. Alden, who was lovely, lasted eleven months, and then her daughter had a baby in Ohio and she went, and that one I do not count against the house. The others—" She shrugged, and the shrug had years in it. "Miss Tran cried in the pantry. Miss Okafor said the house made her dream about drowning, which I thought was dramatic, but she left in the night all the same, so perhaps she knew her own dreams. The last one, Miss Delaney, was here six weeks. She told me on her way out that it wasn't the child and it wasn't the work. She said it was the quiet. She said the quiet in this house has a weight, and she was tired of carrying it up and down the stairs." Rosa looked at Claire then, directly, without the armor of the tour. "She was not wrong about the quiet. I will not lie to a woman on her first day. This house has been a sad place for two years, and a frightened one, which is worse, because frightened people lock doors and then forget what the doors were for."

"And Lily?" Claire asked.

"Lily," Rosa said, "is the reason the quiet breaks my heart instead of just my nerves. Come and see where you'll sleep, and then I'll tell you about lunch."

News in the same category

The Nanny Who Made Boston's Most Feared Crime Boss Believe in Home Again

30 Part