The Nanny Who Made Boston's Most Feared Crime Boss Believe in Home Again

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"He's exactly as advertised," Claire said.

"Yes," Rosa said. "That is the surprise people keep having." And she led the way upstairs, toward the small, silent country of Lily's rooms, where a six-year-old girl was waiting to be the reason.

Chapter 3: Lily

Lily Mercer was sitting at the small table in her playroom when Claire first saw her, and her first impression was not of a child at all but of a piece of furniture the room had been arranged around, the way the whole house seemed arranged around an absence.

She was small for six, fine-boned, with her father's darkness scaled down and softened: dark hair in a single braid Rosa had clearly done that morning, going crooked now at the end of the day; a gray cardigan buttoned wrong by one button, which nobody had corrected; dark eyes that went to Claire when she entered, evaluated her in one complete pass — shoes, hands, face, the way she closed the door behind her — and then went back down to the plate in front of her with the air of a judge who had reached a verdict and found it not worth announcing.

On the plate was a piece of toast. It had been cut into four triangles. One triangle had a bite out of it. The others stood in their places like guests at a table where the host had died two years ago and nobody had told them to go home.

"Lily," Rosa said from the doorway, gently, in the voice of a woman laying a cloth over something breakable, "this is Ms. Bennett. She's come to look after you, the way Miss Delaney did. She's going to have lunch with you, if you'll let her."

Lily did not answer. She picked up a second triangle of toast, considered it with an exhaustion entirely unsuited to her age, and put it down again in precisely its original position.

"May I sit?" Claire asked.

The dark eyes came up again, surprised — and Claire understood, in that small startled lift, that the other nannies had not asked. They had sat, the way weather arrives, and begun. Lily gave a shrug of one shoulder, which Claire chose to receive as a royal assent, and sat down across the small table and folded her hands in her lap and did not say anything at all for a while.

This was her trade, though nobody who watched it believed it was work: waiting inside a child's silence without trying to evict it. Children could smell an extraction the way dogs smell weather. If you came at a grieving child with questions, you got the answers she had learned to give adults to make the adults stop, and they were worth nothing, and everyone in the transaction knew it except the adult. So Claire sat, and looked around the room the way Lily had looked at her, without hurry. There were books, shelved low, spines out, read-looking. There was a piano through the open door of the next room, a small upright, its lid closed and a thin, even film of dust on the lid that told its own story in house language: not neglected, exactly; avoided. There were drawings pinned in a row above the table, and it was to these, eventually, that Claire's attention honestly went, because one of them was magnificent.

It showed a horse. The horse was purple, a deep, committed, crayon purple pressed hard enough to shine. It had a mane like a storm cloud and a tail like a second storm cloud, and it had — Claire counted, because counting was clearly what the drawing was inviting — six legs. Not four legs drawn badly. Six legs, each one placed with intent, two of them in the air in the middle of a gallop, drawn by a child who had looked at the problem of how a horse runs and decided that four was not going to be enough to get it where it needed to go.

"That's a very fast horse," Claire said.

Lily looked up. "It's purple," she said, in the tone of someone correcting a fact before it could spread.

"It is very purple," Claire agreed. "I think the purple helps. Nobody could catch it. It has enough legs to run and enough left over to kick anyone who tries."

For a moment — it was not a smile, and Claire would not insult the moment later by calling it one — the child's whole face changed its weather. Something went through it like light through trees: brief, and entirely real, and gone before it could be asked to stay. Lily looked at the drawing as if she had not seen it properly before.

"His name is secret," she said.

"That's sensible," Claire said. "With legs like that, everyone's going to want him. I'd keep his name secret too."

Lily considered this with the gravity of a head of state. Then, with one finger, she pushed the plate of toast an inch across the table toward Claire — not offering it, exactly; moving it out of the center of her own country, making the smallest possible room. Claire took a triangle, the one with the bite's neighbor, and ate it plain, without butter, without comment, and Lily watched her do it with an expression that Claire, who had read children's faces for six years the way her father had once read tide tables, translated without difficulty: You eat the toast here. Nobody eats the toast here. Why do you eat the toast here?

"Someone should," Claire said. "It's good toast. Rosa doesn't make bad toast, I can already tell. It would be a shame to waste it on a staring contest."

From the doorway, Rosa made a sound that she covered with a cough, and went away down the hall making it again.

That first afternoon did not improve, exactly. Improvement was not a word that applied to that house yet, and Claire, who noticed routines, noticed the shape of Lily's the way she had noticed the street and the gate: lessons endured rather than attended, with a tutor who spoke to the child in the bright, carrying voice people used across a great distance; a rest hour in which Lily did not rest but lay looking at the ceiling with the discipline of a small soldier; a walk in the garden that went around the terrace paths in a route so fixed that Claire could see the stones worn differently where their circuit always turned. Lily did not play. That was the detail Claire carried downstairs with her at seven, when Rosa came up to take the evening, and could not set down. She had seen children angry, children frightened, children performing wellness for frightened adults; she had seen grief in children before and knew its ordinary disguises. This was none of them. This was a child who had quietly stopped doing the things that children do when they believe the world is a place that notices them — playing chief among them, that serious, pointless, necessary work — and nobody in the silent house had known how to ask her to start again, because asking would have meant admitting, out loud, in a room, that she had stopped.

"How was she?" Rosa asked in the kitchen, in a low voice, though there was no one to overhear; the whole house spoke in low voices, Claire had already learned, the way people do in churches and in hospitals and in houses where the head of the family might be listening from behind any door, though he never was.

"She showed me the horse," Claire said.

Rosa stopped with a plate in her hand. "She talked to you about the horse?"

"She told me his name is secret," Claire said. "Which is not the same as telling me the name."

"No," Rosa said slowly. "But it is not nothing. It has not been put to many people, that drawing." She set the plate down with great care, as if it were the thing under discussion. "The others mostly tried to get her to the piano. Mr. Mercer had it tuned. He keeps having it tuned. It is the most in-tune piano in Boston, and she will not touch it, because her mother—" She stopped.

"I know," Claire said gently. "I won't ask, Rosa. I promised him I wouldn't, and I don't need to know to feed her toast."

"You will hear it anyway," Rosa said, after a moment, in a different voice, an older one. "Not from me tonight, and not as gossip. But a woman cannot work in a house and not know what broke it. It would be like working in a lighthouse and not knowing about the rocks." She looked toward the dark windows, and the gates beyond them, and the locked gate in the trees. "Tomorrow, maybe. When you've had a day of the quiet and earned it."

Chapter 4: The Nannies Who Quit

She heard it the next evening, in pieces, the way true things are usually told in houses: a sentence from Rosa over the washing-up, a correction from Marcus in the hall, three words from the woman who came twice a week to do the heavy cleaning and spoke about the family the way people speak about weather they had personally survived. Claire assembled it the way she assembled everything, by paying attention to what had changed and what had never been allowed to change back.

Rebecca Mercer had been dead two years.

News in the same category

The Nanny Who Made Boston's Most Feared Crime Boss Believe in Home Again

30 Part