Frank made another note.
The second 2011 entry named Judith Crane, who had apparently requested access to one of the personnel boxes. Her stated purpose was “family history research.” The authorization had been signed by a different administrator who had since retired.
Frank asked whether the facility could contact the retired administrator and request any recollection of the visit.
Mercer said he would consider it.
The review lasted nearly two hours. By the end, Frank had enough information to establish that the records had been accessed several times, but not enough to explain why the requests had been made or what happened during the visits.
He thanked Mercer and left with Samuel.
Outside, Samuel removed his glasses and rubbed his eyes.
“We have a name, Thomas Weller, and another name, Judith Crane. That's something.”
“It's a start,” Frank said. “But the important question is why someone wanted to review the correspondence in 2011.”
“Could it have been the man in the brown coat?”
“Possibly. We don't know his name. We need to see whether Weller or Crane had any connection to Pike, the accounting firm, or the original investigation.”
They returned to the hotel and contacted Margaret.
She recognized the name Thomas Weller.
“Weller was a private investigator,” she said. “He worked for several law firms in Oklahoma. I remember seeing his name in a case file years ago, but I don't know whether he was involved in the Pike investigation.”
“Can you find out?”
“I'll try. What about Judith Crane?”
Margaret paused.
“I don't recognize that name. But I'll check.”
Ray joined the conversation.
“Could she have been related to one of the warehouse employees?”
“That's possible,” Margaret said. “But we shouldn't assume a family-history request was connected to the investigation. We need to establish her identity first.”
Frank summarized the access register and the 1994 disposal order.
Margaret was particularly interested in the incomplete authorization.
“If a box was designated for destruction, there should normally be documentation identifying the box, the approving party, and the method of disposal. If those details are missing, that does not automatically prove wrongdoing, but it does create a gap we can investigate.”
“Could the box have contained the blue folder?”
“Possibly. But Eleanor's recollection suggests the folder was removed separately in 1989. The disposal order occurred five years later. They may be unrelated.”
Samuel looked toward Ray.
“Unless the folder was returned to the archive after the original transfer.”
Frank nodded slowly.
“That is another possibility.”
Ray opened his notebook.
“If someone brought the folder back in the nineties, it might have been placed in one of the existing boxes. Then someone could have requested it in 1997 or 2003.”
“Or it could have been stored somewhere else entirely,” Frank said. “We need evidence before choosing between those explanations.”
The next two days were spent tracing the names in the access register.
Thomas Weller had died in 2018. His professional records were held by a small law firm that had acquired part of his practice. The firm confirmed that Weller had conducted background investigations for clients involved in civil litigation, but it could not identify the client associated with the 2011 archive visit.
His surviving files were incomplete.
However, an old invoice book listed a payment from a company called Northstar Risk Consulting. The invoice date was three weeks before Weller's visit to the archive.
Frank felt a flicker of recognition.
Northstar had appeared in one of the ledger's coded entries.
He immediately sent the information to Margaret and the forensic accountant.
The accountant compared the invoice date with the ledger. A payment to Northstar Risk Consulting had been recorded on the same day Weller's invoice was issued. The amount was not identical, but the entries were close enough in time to justify further examination.
The accountant cautioned that the match was circumstantial. Northstar could have been a legitimate consulting firm, and the payment might have been unrelated to the archive visit.
Yet the coincidence was worth investigating.
Margaret searched the company's registration history. Northstar Risk Consulting had been established in 1986 and dissolved in 2004. Its registered agent was a man named Harold Voss, a former insurance executive who had served on the board of a transportation trade association.
Voss had also been listed as a consultant to one of Vernon Pike's companies.
Frank read the information twice.
“That's our first clear connection between the ledger and the archive access,” he said.
Samuel leaned over the table.
“Does it prove Weller was working for Pike?”
“No. It proves that Weller received a payment from a company connected to a consultant who had ties to Pike. We need the contract, the client instructions, or some other evidence showing what Weller was hired to do.”
Ray pointed at the ledger.
“What about the 1994 disposal order? Could Northstar have arranged that?”
“We don't know yet,” Frank said. “But we're going to find out who signed the authorization.”
Margaret managed to locate a former employee of Northstar named Patricia Lowe. She was in her seventies and living in Kansas. When Margaret contacted her, Lowe said she remembered the company but had no interest in discussing its clients.
Then, after Margaret explained that the inquiry concerned a historical investigation and possible document destruction, Lowe asked for time to think.
Two days later, she called back.
“I can't give you client names without reviewing my records,” she said. “But I remember a matter involving a trucking company and a set of records that someone wanted kept out of a lawsuit.”
Margaret asked whether the company was Midland Storage and Freight.
Lowe was silent.
“I can't confirm that over the telephone.”
“Would you be willing to meet with counsel?”
“I might. But I want to know whether this is a criminal investigation.”
Margaret explained that they were gathering evidence and had not yet determined what legal action might be appropriate.
Lowe agreed to a meeting in Kansas City.
The three men traveled there the following week, taking the documents they had already collected. They did not bring the original ledger or Walter's letter. Margaret had arranged for secure copies to be available for review.