Ray's expression hardened.
“Then we keep looking.”
Frank nodded.
They did.
The next several weeks were spent tracing the remaining names and comparing the records. Martin Hale was eventually located in a small town in Arkansas. He was ninety-one, living in a care facility, and suffering from memory problems. He could not provide a detailed account of the original investigation, but he remembered being questioned about missing cargo in 1981 and being told that the matter had been resolved.
He also remembered a warehouse supervisor named Peter Lawson.
“Peter was frightened,” Hale said. “He thought someone was following him. He said the company had two sets of books, and that the second set showed where the missing cargo really went.”
“Did he say who was responsible?” Frank asked.
Hale shook his head.
“He said the people who moved the cargo were not the same people who signed the paperwork. He believed someone in the regulatory office was making sure the trucks could move without being inspected.”
“Did he mention Edmund Vale?”
Hale frowned.
“I don't remember the name. But I remember a man from the state office who came to the warehouse. He wore a dark suit and carried a leather briefcase. He asked for records that weren't on the official inventory.”
“Did you know his name?”
“No. But Peter did.”
“Could Peter have written it down?”
“Maybe. He kept notes. He was careful.”
Hale looked toward the window.
“After the investigation started, Peter disappeared. People said he had run off because he was afraid of being charged. I never believed that. He was scared, yes, but he wanted someone to know what was happening.”
Denise Lawson was deeply moved when Frank told her about the conversation. She searched through her father's remaining papers and found a small notebook she had overlooked. It contained several pages of freight codes and dates, along with a list of names.
One name was underlined twice.
Edmund Vale.
Beside it, Peter had written:
He doesn't move the cargo. He makes sure nobody asks where it went.
The notebook also contained a reference to a meeting scheduled for March 17, 1981.
R.D. to meet Reeves. If meeting fails, contact Carter family through alternate channel.
The note was followed by a second entry, written several days later:
Alternate channel compromised. Do not contact directly.
Frank read the page slowly.
Ray stared at the date.
“That was the meeting I was supposed to attend.”
Samuel looked at his brother.
“Peter knew about it.”
“Or someone told him,” Ray said.
Frank pointed to the final line.
“Either way, someone knew the meeting had failed and that the alternate channel had been compromised. That information was circulating among people who were supposed to be separate from one another.”
Margaret Ellis agreed that the notebook was significant. It connected Peter Lawson's observations with the failed meeting between Ray and the person claiming to be Daniel Reeves.
But the notebook did not identify the person who had compromised the meeting.
That answer came from an unexpected source: a retired deputy named William Mercer, who had served in the county sheriff's office during the early eighties.
Mercer had been a junior officer at the time and had no apparent connection to the Pike investigation. When Margaret contacted him, he initially said he remembered little about the period. Then Frank mentioned Howard Vance.
Mercer became quiet.
“Howard was a difficult man,” he said. “He had friends in places where a deputy shouldn't have had friends. He could walk into the courthouse and speak to people who wouldn't have recognized the rest of us.”
“Did he work with Vernon Pike?” Frank asked.
“I never saw them together. But I heard stories.”
“What kind of stories?”
“That Vance was passing information to people outside the department. Names, addresses, reports. Anything that might help someone stay ahead of an investigation.”
“Was he ever investigated?”
“Not seriously. There were complaints, but they never went anywhere.”
“Did you know Daniel Reeves?”
Mercer thought for a moment.
“I remember a federal investigator who came through in 1981. He was asking about a missing witness and a set of freight records. He met with Vance at the station.”
“Did you hear what they discussed?”
“No. But I saw Vance leave the meeting with a folder. Later that day, he told us that the federal investigator had found nothing and that we should stop wasting time on the case.”
Frank's attention sharpened.
“Did the investigator agree to close the case?”
“Not that I knew. He looked angry when he left.”
“Could you identify the investigator?”
Mercer thought carefully.
“I believe it was Reeves, but I can't be certain. It's been a long time.”
“Did you ever see Vance with a man in a brown coat?”
Mercer looked at Frank.
“Yes.”
“Can you describe him?”
“He came to the station twice. He wasn't a local. He had a limp, and he always seemed to know when someone was asking questions about Pike. Vance treated him like a superior, though he wasn't in law enforcement.”
“Did you know his name?”
“No. But I heard Vance call him ‘Mr. Harlan’ once.”
Frank felt the pieces shift.
Daniel Harlan.
The records consultant who had stored the cabinet.
The man connected to Thomas Weller.
The man whose company had held a sealed cabinet marked with Vernon Pike's initials.
Could Harlan have been the man in the brown coat?
The possibility was strong, but it still required confirmation. Harlan had died in 2019, and the available photographs were limited. Margaret requested family photographs and professional records from his estate. Robert Harlan provided several images, including one taken in the late eighties.
The man in the photograph wore a brown coat and stood beside a dark sedan.
The face was clearer than the image Walter had kept.
Dr. Porter compared the photographs and concluded that they were likely of the same person.
Frank showed the image to Ray.
Ray stared at it for a long time.
“I think that's him,” he said. “I can't swear to it, but I remember the way he stood. I remember the limp.”