Commissioner Otto Lindgren arrived at Elgin Crossing on the morning stage with two carpetbags and a face like a man who had been deciding other people's water for thirty years and had enjoyed almost none of it. He was sixty-eight, Swedish by birth and territorial by exhaustion, and by noon he had done three things Jonas would remember for the rest of his life: he had walked the whole of the Old Cut with his own boots, he had read Ah Sing's journal standing up in the station house with his lips moving, and he had held the 1885 stake in both hands for a full minute, turning the brass cap to the light the way a jeweler turns a stone he suspects.
Then he had the oar brought in — Jonas had carried it up from the landing himself at first light, across his shoulders like a yoke, through a town that had come out of doorways to watch — and Lindgren laid the oar and the journal and the stake side by side on the post office counter, under the mail slots, where Mabel Truit was already moving the letter scales aside with the proprietary air of a woman loaning her altar to a court.
"You understand," Lindgren said at last, in front of perhaps forty people pressed into a room built for twelve, "that what these objects allege, Mr. Bellamy, is not a small thing. They allege that the Uintah Canal Company's filing of this spring is founded on a false initiation date, and that the abandonment affidavit underpinning it — bearing *your* signature, sir, sworn in 1878 — is contradicted by a decade of recorded use. If I entertain this, the company will have me in front of a territorial judge before the month is out, and they will have *you* in front of one considerably sooner. I do not conduct entertainments. I conduct rulings. So we will do this in the open, in the order the law requires, or we will not do it at all."
"The open is what we came for, Commissioner," Wenonah said, from her place by the window, where she stood not behind Jonas but beside the counter itself, a claimant in her own right and not any man's exhibit. "The dark has had its ten years."
Lindgren looked at her a moment, and something in the old surveyor's face acknowledged something in her that had nothing to do with the case. "Then hear the shape of it, all of you, because I will say it once." He set his hand flat on the counter, and the room went quiet the way rooms do when a man is about to divide water in a dry country — entirely, and with the body. "The ruling will be given at this crossing, on the second day of June, at ten o'clock in the morning. On that day I will weigh the canal company's priority — and the allegations against it — against the marsh claim. But the law of this territory is not sentimental, and neither am I. A claim is proved by use. Beneficial use of the water of Willow Marsh, by the marsh claimants, must be *completed* — water actually diverted, actually standing on the ground it is claimed for — before the deadline fixed by statute. That deadline is midnight ending the thirty-first of May. Mrs. Truit's station bell will mark it, as it marks the mail closing, and there will be no argument about the hour, because I will be standing in this room when it rings."
"And if the water is in the ground before the bell?" Jonas said.
"Then on June second the claimants hold a perfected use with an ancient priority of fact, and the company holds—" Lindgren picked up the stake, weighed it, set it down with a care that fooled nobody "—a filing I will then examine with the full attention it has earned. And if the water is *not* in the marsh before the bell, Mr. Bellamy, then all of this—" the flat hand swept the counter, stake, journal, oar "—becomes history. Interesting, regrettable, publishable history, which the canal will file under the riverbed when it dries. The law does not award water to the side with the better story. It awards water to the side that *wets the ground*. You have until the bell. I suggest you all stop standing in my light."
He set the date the way a man sets a fence post, and Jonas felt the whole town's weight shift onto the deadline the way a ferry's load shifts when the current takes the hull — slowly, then all at once. Nine days. Nine days to dig a channel that honest engineers would have scheduled across a season; nine days to turn a river that did not wish to be turned; and threaded through the nine days like a fuse through powder, the other condition, the one Lindgren had stated as procedure and Jonas had heard as a sentence: before any of it could be weighed, the ferryman's own sworn words of 1878 had to be publicly taken back by the ferryman's own living voice. A living witness outranked a dead record — and a living witness recanted only in the open, or not at all.