Sena rode beside Nathan on a buckskin mare named Sage. It was her first time on horseback in months, and she sat the saddle the way she did everything now — carefully, as if the world might revoke the privilege. The morning sun caught the new scar along her jaw, thin and pale, and the braid she had tied with a strip of blue cloth torn from one of Anna Cole's old dresses. Nathan had not offered it. She had found it in the rag basket and taken it, and he had pretended not to notice, because some things a person has to take for themselves.
"Florence by tomorrow evening if the mule holds," Nathan said. "Court convenes the morning after."
Zeke made a sound that might have been agreement. A fly worried his collar. He did not brush it away.
At midday they stopped where a dry wash cut the road, and Nathan unholstered his old Colt and held it out to Sena, butt first.
"You should know how," he said. "Voss's men don't fight with paper."
Sena looked at the revolver for a long moment. Then she looked at her own hands — the knuckles still scabbed from the chain, the palms callused from the curry comb and the harness needle.
"My hands are for holding," she said, "not for killing."
She said it without heat, the way she might have declined a second helping. Nathan held the gun out a moment longer, then holstered it.
"Fair enough," he said.
But Zeke, watching through his sweat and tremors, nodded slowly, as if she had said something worth remembering.
That night they camped under a stand of cottonwoods, and Zeke's shaking got worse before it got better. He sat apart, knees drawn up, breathing like a man climbing stairs. Pete had packed them salt pork and biscuits and a jar of peaches, and Sena divided everything into three exact portions without being asked, the way people do who have learned that fairness is something you practice, not something you receive.
"What is this paper they say I signed?" Sena asked. She spoke slowly, building the English the way she built fires now — one careful stick at a time.
"An indenture," Zeke said. His voice was raw. "A contract of labor. It says you owed a debt and agreed to work it off."
"I owed no debt."
"I know." Zeke stared into the fire. "Paper lies easier than people, Sena. That's why men like Voss love it. A man has to look you in the eye to steal from you. Paper just sits there, quiet, doing the stealing for him."
"Then we tell the judge the paper lies."
Zeke almost smiled. "In my experience, judges and paper are old friends."
Nathan threw another branch on the fire. "Tell me about March fourteenth," he said.
It was the date on the indenture — the date Sena had supposedly set her mark to it, in Voss's office, in the presence of witnesses.
"I was in my village," Sena said. "The snow had just left the high ground. My mother was mending a basket. Chenoa was —" She stopped. Her hands went still in her lap. "There was a preacher. He came through that week. He wrote in a book."
"A circuit preacher," Zeke said, sitting up straighter despite the tremors. "Name?"
"I do not know his name. He baptized children. He wrote everything in a book with a red cover."
Zeke closed his eyes. "San Xavier mission keeps circuit diaries. If that preacher filed his diary —" He opened his eyes. "It's a thread, Nathan. A thin one. But it's a thread."
They rode into Florence the next evening through heat that hung over the adobe streets like a held breath. The county courthouse was a two-story brick building with a flag out front and a watering trough that had gone green. Inside, the courtroom smelled of varnish, sweat, and old paper — the smell, Nathan thought, of every room where his life had ever been decided by other men.
Judge Harlow took the bench at nine sharp. He was a heavy man with muttonchop whiskers and a fisherman's squint, and behind him on the wall, mounted in a varnished case, hung a largemouth bass with a little brass plate beneath it. Nathan leaned forward to read the plate.
*Caught with H. Voss, Salt River, '74.*
Zeke saw him looking and made a small, hopeless gesture with one trembling hand.
Harlan Voss sat at the plaintiff's table in a black broadcloth coat, his silver hair combed back, looking for all the world like a banker come to foreclose on a widow. Beside him sat his lawyer, a man named Stiles, who had the smoothest hands Nathan had ever seen on a living man — hands that had never held anything heavier than a pen.
Sena sat between Nathan and Zeke at the defendant's table, her back straight, her eyes on the judge. She wore the blue dress Mabel Hutchins had refused to sell her and that Pete had bought instead, riding twenty miles to a Mexican trader at Picacho to get it. It was too big in the shoulders. She had taken it in herself with neat, furious stitches.
Stiles rose first, and he was everything Zeke was not: young, rested, certain.
"Your Honor," Stiles said, "this is a simple matter of contract. My client, Mr. Harlan Voss, entered into a lawful indenture of labor with the contracted party" — he nodded toward Sena without looking at her — "on the fourteenth of March of this year. The defendant, Mr. Nathan Cole, has unlawfully detained the contracted party and converted to his own use a freight wagon belonging to my client's company. We ask the court to order the return of both the wagon and the contracted party, and to award damages for the unlawful detention."
He said "the contracted party" the way another man might say "the mule."
Zeke stood. His hands shook visibly now, and he clasped them behind his back, which only made his shoulders shake instead.
"Your Honor," Zeke said, "the so-called indenture is a fraud. The mark upon it was not made by this woman. The date upon it is impossible. And the detention Mr. Stiles complains of was, in fact, a rescue —"