There was a brief silence.
Richard leaned forward.
"Do you want me to move Thomas out of the department entirely?"
Alan considered the question.
"Not yet. Let him understand that this is not the hill he wants to die on."
Kenneth looked down.
"I don't like how this is being handled."
Alan turned.
"Then perhaps you should spend less time worrying about how things are handled and more time ensuring they are profitable."
The three men left.
Evelyn remained in the alcove.
She waited several minutes before moving.
Her hands were cold.
She had heard enough to understand that Thomas's complaint and the financial irregularities might be connected.
She immediately contacted Naomi.
The next morning, Naomi arranged for the outside auditor to expand the scope of the review.
The investigation would now include vendor approvals, executive discretionary spending, and possible retaliation against employees who had raised financial concerns.
Evelyn also requested that the board's independent directors receive a preservation notice.
The company was required to preserve relevant records.
No emails, approval logs, or personnel files could be altered or destroyed.
Naomi was firm.
"This is no longer just a culture review."
"I know."
"If there is evidence of financial misconduct, we will need to treat it as a separate legal matter."
"Understood."
"And Evelyn?"
"Yes?"
"Do not let your anger make decisions for you."
Evelyn looked at Martin's old photograph.
"I'm not angry enough to forget what he taught me."
Naomi paused.
"Good."
Evelyn ended the call.
She was not trying to destroy Hawthorne and Beck.
She was trying to determine whether it could still become the company Martin had imagined.
But the people protecting Alan were beginning to sense danger.
And one of them had already decided to find out who was asking questions.
THE EIGHT-MONTH INVESTIGATION
The fifth month began with a change in the building's atmosphere.
Evelyn noticed it immediately.
The executive floor became quieter.
Doors remained closed longer.
Managers stopped discussing sensitive matters in hallways.
The cleaning staff received new instructions about access to certain offices.
A facilities supervisor announced that all cleaning contractors would need to confirm their assigned areas at the beginning of each shift.
On the surface, the changes appeared ordinary.
But Evelyn understood what they meant.
Someone was becoming concerned about information moving through the building.
She did not know whether Alan had discovered her identity.
She suspected he had not.
Still, she adjusted her routine.
She stopped spending unnecessary time near executive offices.
She avoided asking questions.
She concentrated on documenting events through legitimate observations and information supplied voluntarily by employees.
The sealed folder she had been assembling became thicker.
It contained summaries rather than stolen documents.
Every item had a source.
Every allegation had been marked as verified, unverified, or requiring additional investigation.
Naomi insisted on that distinction.
"An allegation is not a conclusion," she reminded Evelyn.
"I know."
"Then we must keep it that way."
Evelyn agreed.
She had no intention of replacing Alan with another kind of injustice.
The Former Director Returns
Patricia Shaw had been out of Hawthorne and Beck for more than a year when she agreed to assist the independent review.
Her departure had been described as voluntary.
But the documents she had preserved showed that she had repeatedly requested a formal investigation into the company's complaint-handling process.
She had also questioned the practice of allowing executives to close complaints involving their own departments.
Her final internal memorandum had recommended that serious complaints be reviewed by an independent committee.
The recommendation had never been implemented.
Evelyn met Patricia again at Naomi's office.
This time, Robert Haines joined them.
The meeting lasted nearly three hours.
Patricia explained how the HR system had changed.
Robert reviewed the financial implications.
Naomi examined the legal issues.
By the end, they had identified three major areas requiring investigation.
First, employee complaints were being classified and closed without adequate independent review.
Second, management decisions affecting employees who raised concerns appeared to lack consistent documentation.
Third, certain executive expenses had insufficient supporting records.
The team did not yet know whether the three issues were directly connected.
But they agreed that the company's internal controls were inadequate.
Evelyn listened as the others discussed possible next steps.
Finally, she spoke.
"What would Martin have done?"
Robert looked at her.
"He would have demanded an independent review."
Patricia nodded.
"And he would have protected the people who spoke up."
Naomi closed her notebook.
"Then that is what we should do."
The Board's First Request
Evelyn formally requested an expanded report from the audit committee.
The request was submitted under her shareholder rights.
It was detailed and specific.
She requested information about:
-
Executive discretionary spending.
-
Vendor contracts and payment approvals.
-
Employee complaint records.
-
Retaliation allegations.
-
Terminations following formal complaints.
-
Changes to internal reporting procedures.
-
The independence of the company's compliance function.