The board chair, George Whitaker, called her the following afternoon.
George was seventy-one and had served as chairman for nearly a decade.
He had known Martin since the company's early years.
He was generally regarded as reasonable, but he had also supported Alan's appointment.
"Evelyn," he began, "your request is extensive."
"I realize that."
"Some of these matters have already been reviewed."
"Then providing the records should be straightforward."
George sighed.
"I don't want you to misunderstand me. I share your interest in good governance."
"Then we agree on the objective."
"Of course. But there are reputational considerations."
Evelyn looked out her office window.
"George, are you more concerned about the company's reputation or the company's conduct?"
The chairman was silent.
"I don't think that's a fair distinction," he finally said.
"Neither do I. That's why I want the records."
George promised to discuss the request with the audit committee.
Evelyn thanked him.
When the call ended, she wrote one sentence in her notebook.
The board is beginning to recognize that questions are not going away.
The Executive Expense Trail
Robert's preliminary financial analysis identified several patterns.
A consulting vendor called Meridian Advisory Partners had received repeated payments.
The invoices described services as strategic planning, leadership development, and operational support.
Those descriptions were broad.
The company had paid the vendor more than $300,000 over eighteen months.
A second provider had received substantial payments for executive travel coordination.
A third had been used for special client development services.
None of those payments was automatically improper.
But the documentation was incomplete.
Robert wanted to know who had approved the contracts.
The approval logs indicated that some transactions had passed through Richard Phelps's department.
Others had been approved by Kenneth Doyle.
Several carried authorization references associated with the CEO's office.
Robert was careful.
"We cannot say that these payments were fraudulent," he explained. "We can say the control environment was inadequate and the documentation needs independent verification."
Evelyn nodded.
"Continue."
The auditor requested the original contracts and supporting materials through formal channels.
At first, the company cooperated.
Then delays began.
One department claimed that records were being archived.
Another said that several invoices were unavailable because of a software migration.
A third requested additional time.
Naomi noticed the pattern.
"These delays are not proof of wrongdoing," she said. "But we need to document them."
Evelyn agreed.
Every request received a date.
Every response was preserved.
Every missing document was listed.
The investigation was becoming a record of both what the company could establish and what it could not produce.
A Conversation in the Parking Garage
One evening, Evelyn finished her shift later than usual.
She was walking toward the employee parking area when she heard someone call her name.
"Miss Lorraine?"
She turned.
It was Caleb Turner.
He stood beside a concrete pillar, holding his phone.
"Hello, Caleb."
"Do you have a minute?"
"Certainly."
He looked uncomfortable.
"I wanted to ask you something."
"What is it?"
"Do you think people can get fired for asking questions?"
Evelyn studied him.
"Why are you asking?"
He showed her an email.
It had been sent by his department supervisor.
The message instructed junior analysts not to contact the audit team directly about discrepancies unless their manager had approved the communication.
Caleb explained that he had noticed an inconsistency in a client report.
He had raised it with his supervisor.
The supervisor told him the discrepancy had already been addressed.
But Caleb had checked the underlying figures and found that the problem remained.
"I don't want to get anyone in trouble," he said.
"Are you certain the figures are wrong?"
"Yes."
"Have you documented what you found?"
"I have the original report, the revised report, and the calculation."
"Then preserve them."
Caleb looked worried.
"Should I send them to someone?"
"Use the company's formal reporting channel or seek independent advice if you believe the internal process is compromised. Don't distribute confidential client information casually."
He nodded.
"I just don't want to lose my job."
Evelyn softened her voice.
"Being careful is not the same as being silent. Make sure you understand the process, protect confidential information, and keep a record of what you report."
Caleb thanked her.
Before he walked away, he said something that surprised her.
"You know, Miss Lorraine, I think you understand this place better than most of the people who run it."
Evelyn smiled faintly.
"Perhaps I have more time to observe."
He laughed.
Then he left.
Evelyn watched him go.
She thought about Martin.
He had always believed young employees needed room to ask questions.
He used to say that an intern who was afraid to question an incorrect number would eventually become a manager who was afraid to question an incorrect decision.
Evelyn wrote that sentence down.