A Photograph of a Young Woman
She knew that face. She had seen it before, in the library, in the big photograph that stood on the table beside Alessandro’s chair. That photograph showed Elena Romano as an older woman, with grey in her hair and lines around her eyes, but with the same smile, the same dark eyes, the same gentle face. Clara had dusted that photograph many times, and she had always thought that Elena looked kind, and sad, and strong, all at once.
But the photograph in the box was different. It showed Elena as a young woman, before the sadness came, before the house grew quiet, before the secrets began. She was young and bright and full of life, and she held a baby in her arms as if the baby were the whole world. Clara wondered who the baby was. She wondered if it was Lucia, small and new, or if it was someone else, someone she had never heard of, someone who had been hidden away.
Clara went to the library one afternoon, when the house was quiet, to look at the big photograph again. She dusted the table, slowly, and she looked at Elena’s face. The older Elena smiled at her from the frame, and Clara smiled back, though her heart was heavy. She thought about how much a photograph could hold, and how much it could hide, and how a smile could stay the same, even when everything else had changed.
Lucia came into the library while Clara was working. She was carrying a book, and she smiled at Clara, as she always did, kind and gentle. She put the book down on the table and stood beside Clara, looking at the photograph of her mother. For a moment, neither of them spoke. The library was quiet, full of afternoon light and the smell of old books and polished wood.
“She was beautiful, wasn’t she?” Lucia said softly. “My mother. I was very young when she died. I hardly remember her. I remember her voice, a little, and her hands, and the smell of her dress. But mostly I remember her from this photograph. I look at it, and I try to remember more, but I cannot.”
Clara nodded, and she did not speak. She wanted to tell Lucia about the box, and about the letters, and about the photograph of the young woman holding a baby. She wanted to tell her about the hidden son, and about the secret that Alessandro had kept for so many years. But she did not. She knew that it was not her secret to tell. She knew that if Lucia was meant to know, her father would tell her himself, in his own time.
Lucia touched the frame of the photograph with one finger, gently, as if she were touching her mother’s face. “My father never talks about her,” she said. “He never talks about the past at all. Sometimes I think he is afraid of it. Sometimes I think he keeps it all inside, and it makes him ill. Dr. Ortiz says he must rest, and must not worry, but how can he rest, when he carries so much inside him?”
Clara looked at Lucia, and she saw the sadness in her eyes, and the love, and the worry. She saw a daughter who loved her father, and who wanted to help him, and who did not know how. Clara thought about the box beneath the mattress, and about the letters tied with ribbon, and about the photograph of the young woman, and she wondered if knowing the secret would help Lucia, or if it would only hurt her more.
That night, Clara went to her room and took out her own small box, the one her mother had left her, with letters tied with ribbon, and a photograph of a young woman. She looked at her mother’s face, young and smiling, and she thought about how all mothers were young once, and how all families had secrets, and how love could make people hide the very things they loved most. She put the box away, and she went to bed, and she dreamed of a garden, and of a young woman holding a baby, and of a house on a hill, full of light and full of silence, waiting for the truth to be told.
She hoped that one day the truth would come out very soon and set them all free at last.