The smoke should have been warning enough.
Josiah Mercer had spent six bitter winters in the high country teaching himself a single, unyielding rule: never investigate things that did not belong to him.
Smoke beyond his eastern ridge belonged to somebody else. A gunshot echoing through the timber of the lower valley belonged to somebody else. The iron-rimmed tracks of a stranger’s wagon or the deep drag of unshod ponies crossing the abandoned stage road belonged strictly to somebody else. That was the solemn, silent bargain he had struck with God and his own conscience after the bloodbath at Chickamauga: if the wider world agreed to leave him alone in the high shadow of the peaks, he would return the courtesy without exception.
He had buried enough men in shallow trenches to know what meddling cost.
Yet on that raw, overcast November evening, a slender pillar of charcoal-gray smoke climbed straight into the leaden sky above Widow’s Canyon. The air was dead calm, thin and biting with the scent of pine needle freeze and unshed snow. The column rose too steadily, too deliberately, to be the wandering tongue of a dead campfire or the creeping menace of a brush fire catching the scrub oak. It climbed in a sharp, disciplined thread that broke through the mist hovering over the canyon’s jagged jaws.
A signal.
Josiah stood outside his cabin of hand-hewn spruce logs, his double-bitted ax buried two inches deep in a seasoned round of tamarack. His hands, rough and permanently stained by pine pitch and woodsmoke, rested lightly on the polished hickory haft. From the small pole corral forty yards down the slope, his chestnut gelding, Gideon, raised his broad head, nostrils flaring as the faint, dry musk of burning sage drifted across the clearing.
“You see it too, don’t you?” Josiah said aloud, his voice raspy from disuse.
The horse flicked an ear backward, blowing a cloud of white steam into the frost.
“Course you do. Damned fool fire where no fire ought to be.”
Talking to Gideon had become one of Josiah’s few surviving social habits. Horses did not ask why a thirty-five-year-old mountain recluse woke with his knuckles white and bleeding against the floorboards before the gray dawn broke. They did not ask why the deep rolling crack of summer thunder caused his shoulder blades to lock up like rusted hinges. And they certainly did not care that before he became an invisible phantom living on beans, salt pork, and solitude in the Colorado territory, he had been Sergeant Josiah Mercer of the 2nd Tennessee Volunteers—a boy of twenty-two who had marched south under the illusions of brass buttons, parade fifes, and the idiotic notion that bravery was merely the absence of terror.
Chickamauga had dismantled that vanity within forty-eight hours. Courage was not fearlessness; it was shaking until your teeth rattled while the man beside you choked on his own blood, and dragging your boots forward through the sulfur stench anyway because there was no backward road left. Josiah had done that until the war ran out of mud and men. Then he had simply grown tired of walking forward into other men’s graves.
He turned toward the cabin door, stepping inside the dim, fragrant interior. From the pegs above the stone mantle, he lifted his Winchester 1873 rifle, levered the action back just far enough to verify the gleam of brass in the chamber, and dropped a handful of extra .44-40 cartridges into his sheepskin coat pocket.
Ten minutes later, he had Gideon cinched tight beneath an old McClellan saddle.
The wind had teeth as they left the cleared boundary of his homestead. Two nights prior, an early squall had dusted the ridge with four inches of wet snow, but the pale, indifferent sunlight of the afternoon had turned the lower trails into slick troughs of frozen red clay and crusted ice. The horse picked his footing carefully, shod hooves ringing against granite outcroppings.
As Josiah rode deeper toward the throat of Widow’s Canyon, the landscape fell unnaturally silent. That unsettled him more than any gunshot. In these mountains, there were always ravens quarreling in the crown of the dead pines, or the nervous chattering of squirrels caching nuts before the true winter locked the earth down. Today, there was only the whistle of cold draft between the sandstone bluffs.
Widow’s Canyon narrowed sharply near the old post route, pinched between two vertical walls of rusty red rock that seemed to lean toward each other like ancient gossips. Josiah reined Gideon in behind a thicket of mountain juniper.
“Stay,” he murmured, dropping the split reins to the ground.
Gideon gave a low huff, ears pinned, breath fogging.
Josiah racked a round into the Winchester’s chamber and moved forward on foot, his moccasin-soled boots making no sound against the frozen slush. He cleared the bend, his rifle raised to the hollow of his shoulder.
He saw the charred remnants of an ancient stagecoach depot first—a rotting corral post, half-collapsed by years of snowdrift.
Then he saw the smoke. A small iron brazier sat on a flat rock, fed with green pine needles and dry punk-wood.
Then he saw the rope.
And then, his mind ground to a dead, disbelieving halt.
Suspended from a crossbeam that jutted from the ruined timber gate, hanging completely upside down, was a woman.
Her ankles had been lashed together with braided rawhide and hoisted four feet clear of the earth. Her hands were bound behind her back, the cord drawn snug. Her thick, ink-black hair spilled downward, brushing the frost-bitten mud. She wore a heavy buckskin cloak trimmed with fur, though it had parted around her shoulders to reveal an ankle-length dress of deep woolen red.
Josiah froze behind a boulder, his thumb poised on the Winchester’s hammer.
There was no blood pooling on the ground beneath her skull. No circle of bandits lurking in the rocks. No sound of approaching riders. The clearing was empty save for the thin drift of sage smoke and the creak of the hemp rope under her weight.
“Ma’am?” Josiah called out, keeping his voice low, gravelly, and steady.
She did not stir.